Use of the term “manpower” serves to gender labor in military institutions and devalue women’s roles
Wright, Hurley, & Gil Ruiz 19
Katharine A.M., Lecturer in International Politics at Newcastle University, UK; Matthew, Lecturer in Politics at Sheffield Hallam University, UK; Jesus Ignacio, former Chief of the NATO IMS Office of the Gender Advisor. “Gendering NATO’s core tasks Collective defence, crisis management and cooperative security.” NATO, Gender, and the Military: Women Organising from Within. Routledge Studies in Gender and Security. 2019. Pg 110-112. LJS
The use of ‘manpower’ to describe human resource management remains in common parlance by NATO and in the military setting more broadly. Yet it belies the contribution of serving women. Usually, it refers to the availability of suitable recruits to fill military capacity, and often the integration of women within the military service is understood as a means to shore up recruitment shortfalls. However, early Cold War manifestations within the alliance saw it also applied to the distribution of (men and women’s) labour across NATO member states, which was deemed relevant to European security and stability, when war was deemed highly possible (NATO, 1953). There was a particular focus on the availability of skilled labour or ‘manpower’ to support the defence industry, however, population surpluses and migration with Europe were also viewed as a potential source of unrest (NATO, 1953). For example, the Working Group on Labour Mobility considered the employment (and marital status) of civilian women across different industries (NATO, 1957), supporting the notion that women have always been of central importance to the functioning of the military, in roles from camp follower, to soldier (Enloe, 1989). It was therefore through discussion of recruitment shortfalls that NATO first considered the integration of women into NATO Forces in the 1950s (NATO, 1954). These preexisting institutional priorities are important to understand as a starting point when considering the push by Senior NATO Military Women to establish a Committee on Women in NATO Forces (as discussed in Chapter 3). Their efforts were not the first time NATO considered the integration of women, even if they did bring about a focal point and the establishment of formal gender machinery within the alliance. The Expert Working Group on Labour Mobility was tasked with addressing both surpluses and shortages of ‘manpower’, reviewing member countries’ immigration policies with the aim of facilitating labour mobility. The Working Group was specifically tasked with examining: (1) ways to intensify migration; (2) projects designed to mitigate the impact of manpower shortages on defence activities; and (3) preventive plans on labour market disturbance in the case of war. The Working Group was renamed in 1956 and became the Manpower Planning Committee (NATO, 2017). They considered the impact of Italy’s surplus and the UK’s shortfall of skilled workers in the defence industry (NATO, 1953). A particularly interesting aspect of the Working Group/Committee was that it requested reports from member states on their labour mobility status be submitted to them. The reports fed into the work of the group and provided a valuable overview of the status of labour mobility within the alliance. Questionnaires were issued to member states requesting information on ‘manpower’ mobilisation, the availability and training of scientific and technical ‘manpower’, arrangements for ‘manpower’ mobilisation in a crisis, the role of employment services and the status of ‘manpower’ employed by the host country of NATO HQ (NATO, 2017).3 So, while early consideration of ‘manpower’ issues was therefore solely instrumental, it remained deeply gendered, focusing implicitly on men’s recruitment. In a 1954 annual review on national military service, only a few countries enlisted women within the military (and this was primarily to release men for employment in more active roles due to manpower shortages) (NATO, 1954). Throughout NATO’s earliest years, most member states offered limited or no employment opportunities for women in the armed forces. By the 1960s and 1970s, many countries experienced a rise in public pressure for greater equality between women and men in society. Responding to these pressures, the armed forces, too, began increasing the numbers of women within the ranks, and eventually opened up more employment opportunities that were once exclusively reserved for men (Obradovic, 2014). NATO Officials have continued to shape and reshape their respective ‘personnel policies with one eye on the personnel needs dictated by military doctrine and the other eye on the preservation of the ideological bond between masculinity and military service’ (Enloe, 1993: 85). This does not mean, however, that the approaches of NATO member states have been consistent. Rather, member states have learned the value of women in the military through interaction with each other. This leads Enloe (1981) to argue that NATO has functioned as a ‘learning machine’ or ‘teaching machine’, sharing lessons on the integration of women into the armed forces. For example, the US was successful in increasing the number of women on active duty in its armed forces during the 1990s. These women were held up by these who would once have rejected such a move as an example of the US military’s ‘social enlightenment’ (Enloe 1993: 86). The US, a leading NATO ally, began to measure other NATO member states’ sophistication on ‘their ability to incorporate at least token numbers of women without jeopardising the military’s still crucial identification with masculinized patriotism’ (Enloe, 1993: 86). The official recognition of the Committee on Women in NATO Forces (CWINF) in 1976 led to a shift in focus for institutional consideration of ‘manpower’ issues. CWINF provided the framework for NATO’s role as a ‘teaching machine’ in respect of women’s integration. For example, the Netherlands took a proactive approach to the integration of women into the military through opening all ranks to women from the beginning of the integration process in the 1970s and putting in place an anti-discrimination policy (Carreiras, 2006: 151). This resulted in the Dutch Army being used as a test case by NATO, taking on a ‘ “pioneer” in eliminating restrictions on women in combat and operational functions’ (Carreiras, 2006: 155–6; Bolscher and Megens, 1991: 181). For a twenty-first-century NATO, globally engaged in a broad range of theatres and activities, the preoccupation with military recruitment persists. The move away from conscription towards all volunteer forces in an increasing number NATO member states has further elevated the issue of military recruitment (Obradovic, 2014). So, while the immediate motivation for addressing recruitment shortfalls may have changed, the concern remains a pressing one. As we discuss below in relation to crisis management (and in Chapter 5 on the value of a gender perspective), women’s integration into NATO armed forces is now based on a premise that they are an operational asset and provide ‘added value’. The reconciliation of a concern with ‘manpower’ and women’s status within NATO Forces continues to be a key challenge for NATO today, albeit in a different guise. Women’s integration in NATO Forces has never been motivated by a concern that NATO military forces reflect the composition of the population they are intended to protect. Perhaps unsurprisingly, given what we uncovered in Chapter 3, early reflections on the use of this term ‘manpower’ were unsurprisingly critical. For example, remarks by the first Chair of the Committee on Women in NATO Forces, Colonel Else Martensen-Larsen, in 1975, is indicative of the tension between valuing women as an asset and advancing the status of women within the military towards equality: Whoever first coined the word ‘manpower’ did a grave disservice to the women who today, in so many countries, are dedicating themselves to vital defence tasks. I have often thought that it would be worthwhile for the highest NATO authorities to take an active interest in women’s often difficult role as members of a marked minority placed in a predominantly male world. (For, if women have successfully invaded and conquered fields which were long exclusively the province of men, the armed services still remain in many countries a well-protected enclave.)