Militaries act as organized reproduction of hegemonic masculinity and appropriate feminist analysis to violent ends
Wright, Hurley, & Gil Ruiz 19
Katharine A.M., Lecturer in International Politics at Newcastle University, UK; Matthew, Lecturer in Politics at Sheffield Hallam University, UK; Jesus Ignacio, former Chief of the NATO IMS Office of the Gender Advisor. “NATO as an institution of international hegemonic masculinity.” NATO, Gender, and the Military: Women Organising from Within. Routledge Studies in Gender and Security. 2019. Pg 21-23. LJS
Militarised masculinities (plural) have been the source of much scholarly debate and discussion in the field of Critical Military Studies (see for example: Henry, 2017b; Higate, 2018; Henry, 2018). Military institutions are spaces which privilege militarised masculinities over femininities. This matters because they function as sites for the production of culture and gender. For example, the social capital ascribed to forms of martiality (associated with masculinity) within most societies contributes to the ‘glorification of men’s participation in violence and war’ (Enloe, 1994; Henry, 2017b: 187). As a result, it is necessary to examine the socialisation process which takes place in militarised settings (Henry, 2017b: 187). It is also important to note that this process is far from homogenous, indeed, it is complex and often contradictory. The shape militarised masculinities takes differs among military institutions tasked with defence of the air, sea and land. Further permutations are found at national, regional and international level military institutions. One consistency is that it has always been a feature of sustaining militaries and militarism more broadly. Militaries have, traditionally, constructed a very narrowly defined, hegemonic ideal of militarised masculinity. In this sense the (re)production and promotion of hegemonic masculinity in a military context is devised in relation to the primary aim of the organisation, of war fighting and the deployment of violence. As Connell identifies: ‘studies of state military forces show an organisational effort to produce and make hegemonic a narrowly defined masculinity which will make its bearers efficient in producing the organisation’s effects of violence’ (Connell, 2005: 259). The military is therefore a space where qualities associated with war fighting, security and defence are ‘constantly associated with men’ (Hooper, 2001: 230) and men’s bodies, where soldiering is intimately fused with masculinity. As an institution of hegemonic masculinity the military also promotes the association of men, masculinity and soldiering via physicality and sexuality, largely in opposition/relation to the feminine other (Morgan, 1994; Bourke, 1996; Hooper, 2001; Via, 2010). The promotion – and often aggressive reinforcement – of heterosexuality has been seen as an essential tool for promoting social cohesion and comradery between men within the military (Kronsell, 2012: 44). Traditionally, this fusion of men, masculinity and soldiering within militaries has been facilitated by a literal exclusion of the feminine and homosexual other. Where women have been included in military forces, their inclusion was initially premised on exclusion from particular roles and occupations, particularly those defined as ‘direct combat’ roles (see for example, Kornblum, 1984; Horrigan, 1992). And homosexual men and women have traditionally served without22 NATO as an institution disclosure of their sexual orientation. In this regard, Hinojosa identifies that hegemonic masculinity in the military manifests in both ‘internal’ and ‘external’ forms. External in the sense that: ‘masculine power is embedded in the structure of the institution’ (2010: 180). Examples of this can include the banning of women from particular combat roles and the military rank system, which ‘ensures that some men maintain dominance over other men and women’ (2010: 180–1) and represent the gendered division of labour that characterises Connell’s (2006) conceptualisation of institutional gender regimes. Internal hegemony in Hinojosa’s conceptualisation is ‘the hierarchical structuring of masculinities such that some constructs are dominant and privileged over other masculinities and femininities’ (2010: 181). For example, subordinate masculinities in a military context are often patterned on a civilian/military divide, the variation of occupational roles and across the various branches of the armed forces (Higate, 2003; Barrett, 2008; Duncanson, 2009). Hinojosa’s study of the construction of particular hegemonic masculine ideals in the American military found that non-military personnel, service members of different branches, ranks and occupational specialities were cast as less physically able, less self-disciplined, less willing to take risks by pre-active duty servicemen, thereby creating patterns of ‘discursive domination’ (2010: 179). In this sense, hegemonic masculinities within a military context are both (organisationally) structural and a configuration of everyday gendered social practice whereby individuals construct gender identities in relation and opposition to other women and men (Connell, 2005; Hinojosa, 2010: 181). In relation to the military, Duncanson (2013) argues that there has been a ‘softening’ of dominant forms of masculinity (see also, Niva, 1998; Whitworth, 2004); as the hegemonic ideal appropriates certain characteristics from both subordinate masculinities and femininity in order to ‘refashion’ the ideal and respond to shifting cultural expectations (Duncanson, 2013: 61–2). Like Demetriou (2001) and Messner (2007), the sceptical view is that this appropriation, whilst refashioning expectations and masculine ideals within the military, reinforces difference and inequality. For example, Duncanson suggests that ‘the new man of the military often depends on the construction of those in areas of conflict as primitive, inherently and excessively violent and barbaric, or as helpless victims’ (Duncanson, 2013: 61, 2009). The assertion here is that even ‘ostensibly progressive masculinities can have a deeply regressive effect’ and ‘often further disempowers those already lacking power, security and wealth’ (Duncanson, 2013: 61). Therefore, hegemonic masculinities, as an assemblage of appropriated traits that continue to be premised on reformulated patterns of exclusion and subordination inhibit rather than indicate a potential for transformative change. In a military context, hegemonic masculinity has been used to explain why it is that the creation of the ‘New Man’ (for example, the heroic peacekeeper, the humanitarian soldier scholar) has not resulted in gender equality or for that matter, genuine peace and security on many military interventions. Yet, perhaps the utility of the concept leads to too hasty conclusions in feminist scholarship; to the automatic assumption that change in masculinities is little more than the ‘flexibility of the machinery of rule’ (Duncanson, 2013: 71). Duncanson offers an important note of caution on the negative connotations of appropriation, change and transformation of hegemonic masculinity, stating that it is too deterministic. She argues that ‘there is nothing in the concept itself which necessitates an interpretation that it always inevitably shifts in order that men retain power; that it can never be transformed, dismantled’ (Duncanson, 2013: 63). Connell and Messerschmidt argue that research on hegemonic masculinity ‘needs to give much closer attention to the practices of women and to the historical interplay of femininities and masculinities’ (Connell and Messerschmidt, 2005: 848). To do so, it is necessary to centralise interaction of women and men, of masculinities and femininities in and through specific institutional practices. In doing so, we provide examples of understanding the construction of particular hegemonic and subordinate masculinities and femininities within NATO. It is therefore necessary to avoid essentialism, and assumed (negative) types, while acknowledging the fluidity and hybridity between masculinities and femininities. Hegemonic masculinity therefore remains a valuable theoretical and analytical tool, particularly when applied to a militarised institutional setting such as NATO.