Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The realist conception of “negative peace” leaves much to be desired – the aff’s flawed approach to containing conflict perpetuates the gendered status-quo and excludes non-state actors

McLeod and O’Reilly 19

Laura, Politics, lecturer in International Politics at the University of Manchester, UK; Maria, Postdoctoral Research Fellow in the School of Politics and International Relations at Queen Mary University of London. “Critical peace and conflict studies: feminist interventions,” Peacebuilding, 7:2. 2019.

Conflict management approaches – associated with international negotiation, mediation, and traditional peacekeeping – are largely inspired by the realist belief in the inevitability of conflict and the impossibility of achieving resolution.18 These focus narrowly on managing conflict situations and achieving ‘negative peace’19 by halting overt violence. The aim is to reinforce international order and security by ‘isolating’ and ‘containing’ conflict.20 There is shared agreement between critical and feminist PCS regarding the inadequacies of conflict management approaches for building sustainable peace. Traditional peacekeeping missions, for example, hold a mixed record in limiting armed conflict, and are ‘virtually uniform’ in their failure to achieve conflict resolution.21 They rarely created the conditions for peace, and worked largely to ‘freeze’ rather than resolve conflict.22 Women and gender issues were largely excluded from traditional peacekeeping missions: for instance, between 1957 and 1989, the number of women participating in the military component of peacekeeping missions was a mere 0.1%.23 Furthermore, the coercive power wielded by armed peacekeepers is criticised by feminists – for reproducing violent masculinities which (re)create gendered forms of insecurity,24 and for perpetuating relations of domination which are at the root of violent conflict.25 Traditional diplomacy, meanwhile, frequently produced settlements based on ‘peace without justice’ and often found it difficult to address the rising number of intra-state conflicts due to its state-centric view of conflict.26 Feminist scholars have documented the long-standing absence of women from formal peace negotiations.27 Obstacles include highly gendered norms and practices of diplomacy, which associate negotiations and mediation with men, masculinity, and military affairs.28 The lack of recognition of women as significant peace-making actors is another factor; as is the priority afforded to high-level political and military actors (usually men), at the expense of women’s interests and demands.29 From a feminist perspective, conflict management approaches, in theory and in practice, reflect and sustain a ‘cult of power’ within peace research – one which marginalises the perspectives and contributions of relatively ‘powerless’ non-state actors, including many women, girls, and non-binary people.30 Furthermore, the goal of promoting negative peace, is strongly criticised by feminists, who point out that this leaves (gendered) forms of direct violence (e.g. gender-based violence), structural violence (patriarchy), and cultural violence (militarism) unaddressed.31

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.