Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Security cooperation legitimizes irredeemable institutions like NATO, allow them to continue patterns of masculine colonization

Basticka and Duncansonb 18

Megan, School of Law, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK; Claire, School of Social and Political Science, University of Edinburgh, Edinburgh, UK, “Agents of Change? Gender Advisors in NATO Militaries.” International Peacekeeping. 2018. Pg 5-6. LJS.

Militaries are viewed by many feminist scholars as fundamentally inimical to feminism, institutions of destructive power and inherent misogyny.13 Militaries perpetrate devastating violence in war, which disproportionately affects women when the long term impacts, including of forced migration, and sexual and gender-based violence are considered.14 Even where described as ‘pacifying’ or ‘liberating’ missions, military interventions remain violent, for some feminists, often ‘wars of extraction’15, involving the logic of all war: ‘opposition, differentiation and the othering of peoples’.16 As well as perpetrating direct physical violence, militaries are implicated in equally pernicious structural violence. States’ military-industrial complexes organize economies around producing weapons rather than civilian goods and absorb vast amounts of funding that could otherwise be spent on achieving human security.17 The Women’s International League for Peace and Freedom (WILPF) highlights the opportunity-costs at play: the world’s total military expenditure in 2013 was estimated to be $1.747 trillion.18 Only a small fraction of that would be required to fund the measures to achieve the Millennium Development Goal for gender equality, such as women’s economic empowerment, family planning, and women’s participation and leadership. A feminist vision of peace and security, as articulated by WILPF and reflected in feminist scholarship, is for ‘a world free from violence and armed conflict in which human rights are protected and women and men are equally empowered and involved in positions of leadership at the local, national and international levels’, hand in hand with universal reduction and elimination of weapons,19 suggesting a vastly reduced (if any) role for armed forces and military alliances. Militaries are, moreover, viewed by many feminists as an institution where hegemonic forms of masculinity privileging practices of violence and misogyny, combined with myths of heroic protection of vulnerable civilians, are produced and reproduced.20 Militarized masculinity, constructed within militaries but with effects rippling through society, is theorized as focused upon domination of women (and subordinate males) and the denigration of the feminine.21 Indeed, many scholars argue that the capacity of women within the military to be agents of change of institutional culture or of military operations is limited, as they adapt their performance of femininity to fit their hyper-masculine environment.22 They likewise question claims that women make a distinct contribution as military peacekeepers: to protection of women and girls, prevention of sexual exploitation and abuse, or as role models for local women.23 As Heineken says, ‘Clearly one cannot bring about a different perspective to war and peace if women [in the military] are expected to embrace masculine norms and values and where gender difference is not recognised and valued’.24 As such, it is unsurprising that some feminist scholars and activists are sceptical of military engagement with the Women, Peace and Security agenda. They suggest that when taken up by militaries, the Women, Peace and Security agenda risks being used to lend legitimacy to the ‘war system’ rather than challenge it,25 even ‘militarizing feminism’.26 NATO is regarded with particular suspicion, by ‘Women Against NATO’, as ‘an ambitious, expansionist and belligerent war-machine, primarily serving the economic and strategic interests of the more powerful among its member states’.27 From this perspective, NATO invoking women’s rights is not progress, but the co-optation of feminism for militarist ends. More specifically, some feminists allege that NATO’s gender work too often carries the implication that gender is only relevant for the host country, as if western institutions had achieved gender equality; that it perpetuates colonial assumptions about the superiority of the west as the bearer of civilization and humanitarian values.28 One imagines that anti-militarist feminists would argue that Military Gender Advisors are either not-feminist or feminists wasting their time, legitimizing fundamentally problematic institutions.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.