Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Attempting to achieve gender equality through policy initiatives reinforces protective masculinity and the subordination of the feminine within NATO

Wright, Hurley, & Gil Ruiz 19

Katharine A.M., Lecturer in International Politics at Newcastle University, UK; Matthew, Lecturer in Politics at Sheffield Hallam University, UK; Jesus Ignacio, former Chief of the NATO IMS Office of the Gender Advisor. “NATO, women, and gendermen.” NATO, Gender, and the Military: Women Organising from Within. Routledge Studies in Gender and Security. 2019. Pg 91-95. LJS

As the above has demonstrated, gender work at NATO has largely been the domain of women. This has provided an opportunity for women to advance their own and other’s interests, but also serves to further a conflation of gender with women, or women’s issues, that can have restrictive effects on how the role and92 NATO women and gendermen place of women – and the utility of a gender perspective – is understood within NATO, as our analysis in Chapter 5 demonstrates. Drawing on the work of Hurley (2018a), here we want to explore what happens when military men start to engage in gender work within NATO. This is a relatively recent occurrence, there are still relatively few men working in senior positions to advance NATO’s engagement with WPS or working as gender advisors – though this number is growing at a significant rate. These developments are also complemented by an increased willingness by high-profile and senior men within NATO, including the Secretary General, to publicly advocate WPS and the work of the NCGP; for example the 2018 annual meeting of the NCGP was opened by a keynote address from Jens Stoltenberg. Though, as we have identified above, this is not the first time a Secretary General has expressed support and provided important influence in advancing NATO’s gender agenda. Here we conceive of the men ‘doing gender work’ as ‘gendermen’; and occupying a distinct position within NATO. They are men, working in predominantly female-occupied job roles in an organisation dominated by men (Hurley, 2018a). In many ways they challenge or transgress what are deemed to be ‘appropriate’ or acceptable norms within NATO. Here we explore how these perceived transgressions are policed and controlled by those same institutional structures and norms and can reinforce a masculinist protection logic (Young, 2003) that we argue in Chapter 1 underpins NATO’s broader engagement with WPS. Yet, we also argue that men engaging with gender work can offer opportunities for positive, incremental changes in the ways in which militarised masculinities are understood (Duncanson, 2013, 2015) and by extension an opportunity to expose and push for broader changes within NATO’s institutional structures that continue to privilege men and masculinity (Hurley, 2018a, 2018b). Men doing gender work at NATO identified some of the key challenges that they faced in advancing that work. Some of these challenges were informal, yet powerful ways of highlighting difference and reinforcing what was perceived to be acceptable: other people are not convinced, even my colleagues make a lot of jokes about me: ‘You are “genderman”, have you shaved your legs?’ These are jokes, but sometimes, inside their brains, there is some kind of truth. They don’t believe in this. Now seeing a man [doing this work], I think they will open their eyes a little bit more. Interview with NATO Official, 2012 in Hurley (2018) Lazar (2005, 2007) suggests that these sorts of ‘gender crossings’ – the transgression of expected gender norms, in this case a military man working on gender issues – emphasise the underlying dualism of the gender structure within any given organisation. Deviations from these gender-appropriate norms are often policed through criticism and containment, in both formal and informal ways – such as jokes and humour (Lazar, 2005: 8–9). Hearn has argued that ‘trivialisation through humour’ is one of myriad social and psychological resources that military organisations provide for the reproduction and changing of individual psychologies (in Higate, 2003: xiii). And yet, it is a particular form of trivialisation; one that seeks to feminise both the individual and the work that he is doing. This joke serves to both feminise the individual man and, by extension, identify his work as feminine and therefore unimportant within NATO as an institution of international hegemonic masculinity. The joke is used to link gender work at NATO with (a culturally specific) feminine practice – the shaving of legs – reinforcing an implicit and persistent conflation of gender with ‘women’s issues’. Women shave their legs, men do not; therefore gender is a woman’s concern, not a man’s (Hurley, 2018a). In this example, through working on gender issues, by addressing and highlighting the merits of the Women, Peace and Security agenda to other men within the organisation, the masculinity of the gendermen is questioned. As Duncanson (2015) notes, one of the ways in which hegemonic masculinity achieves its hegemonic status is through the feminisation of ‘other’ groups of men (in Hurley, 2018a: 13). And yet the response to this challenge is important too. The distinct and highly visible position that gendermen have is understood as an opportunity to change minds of other resistant men and, in doing so, increase the importance of gender within NATO: Some of them just don’t see the practical use. They just can’t get beyond the idea that women, approaching them, understanding them and that addressing their security needs matters at all … I know some men here will tell me, and they wouldn’t tell her [his female colleague], that they don’t quite buy the concept. So, I can have conversations with them as far as that goes and both they and I gain a better insight into the concept. Interview with NATO Official, 2012 in Hurley (2018) So, gendermen can use their distinct positions, and (re)negotiate their identities in the context within which they find themselves and in response to challenges, to change the minds and perspectives of these resistant colleagues. Yet what is highlighted here is the importance of men speaking to, listening to and being influenced by other men (rather than their women colleagues). This reinforces an understanding of whose voices – and what messages – are afforded respect and credibility within NATO, a point we develop further in Chapter 5. In addition to the risk of feminisation, a common concern of men involved or interested in gender-equality initiatives across a broad range of institutions was a perceived challenge to or misunderstanding of their heterosexuality. In their study of gender mainstreaming within EU member states, Ruxton and Van der Gaag (2013: 169) identify that there was ‘absolute terror in individual men [of] coming across as gay, as female and so on’. This conflation of gender and sexuality was also evident at NATO: I speak with my friends, and I say I work in gender and they start shouting about the gays and the lesbians and you have to say: ‘I don’t have anything to do with gays and lesbians, it is gender’. The thing is, what I do mainly is work to protect men and women, boys and girls who suffer the effects of operations, missions and worse; and in that moment people change their perspective and say: ‘oh my God’; and I say: ‘you can literally help them’. Here, then, there is a fear of feminisation and subordination through a perceived association of working on WPS at NATO with homosexuality (Hurley, 2018a). Interestingly all of the men we spoke to made explicit reference to their wives, girlfriends or children, often at the beginning of conversations, something that the women we spoke to very rarely did. Others made clear references to being ‘OK with gay men’ – even when the focus of the discussion was on a seemingly unrelated topic – with some even suggesting that a focus on LGBT rights should become part of NATO’s broader WPS engagement. Hurley (2018a; in Holmes et al., 2019: 25) has speculated that this might be one mechanism gendermen use to affirm their heterosexuality and to dispel any misperceptions or ambiguity regarding their sexuality, and/or be used as a bonding ploy when in conversation with other men (Conway, 2008; Schwalbe and Wolkomir, 2001). There was also a common articulation that engaging in gender work and promoting the WPS agenda at NATO was a way to protect the vulnerable, most commonly, though not exclusively, women and children. Chapter 1 has shown how masculine norms at NATO reinforce a particular hegemonic regime that becomes built into the structures of the alliance and are transmitted to member and partner states through NATO’s role as a ‘teaching machine’. Informing these norms is a logic of masculinist protection. There is broader evidence of this logic in the way that NATO framed its engagement with WPS under the banner of Protection, Participation and Prevention, as we have explored in Chapter 2 and go onto discuss further in Chapter 5. What the quotes above, and the accounts of the gendermen, highlight is an individualisation of this broader masculinist protectionist narrative: I tend to think that we work for men and women, boys and girls. You focus on the weakest part, the people that are suffering the most. So maybe men don’t suffer, but then I think that is happening more and more. In that way our objective is much more interesting and your work is much more rewarding, let’s say. Interview with NATO Official, 2012 in Hurley (2018) Here, then, gender work is framed as work that helps and is informed by a desire to protect. In similar ways to Young’s (2003) conceptualisation, this account of masculinist protection is expressed in benign terms yet a hierarchy between vulnerable, predominantly non-Western civilians, and a powerful Western military organisation acting a protector is established nonetheless: ‘the role of the masculine protector puts those protected, paradigmatically women and children, in a subordinate position of dependence’ (Young, 2003: 2). The masculinist protection narratives as a response challenges these individual gendermen face draws upon and reinforces broader constructions of hegemonic masculinity at NATO writ large. They provide a further mechanism through which the disruption of their ‘transgression’ can be normalised.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.