Patriarchy is the root cause of violence—masculine norms require violent actions for membership into privileged groups
Acheson 21
Ray, Director of Reaching Critical Will, the disarmament programme of the Women's International League for Peace and Freedom (WILPF). “’Terminally Unserious’: Ideologies and Oppressions of Nuclear Weapons.” Banning the Bomb, Smashing the Patriarchy. 2021. Pg 26-30 LJS
Based on what I have seen over the past fifteen years working around the United Nations and even longer as an antinuclear activist, I believe—as several feminists have argued previously—that a significant part of why this knot is so hard to untie is patriarchy. In fact, as a feminist disarmament activist, I have come to believe that more than anything else, the association of weapons with power is one of the foremost obstacles to disarmament. And, as feminist scholars have articulated time and again, that this association is gendered. Patriarchy is a system of power. It is, in the barest sense, a hierarchical social order in which women are subordinate to men. But it is more than that. It is an order that shapes and entrenches gender as a cultural construction and system that endows the hegemonic conception of what is a “man” with the “right” to dominate and rule over others. Understanding how patriarchy works requires us to understand how gender works. Gender refers to the socially constructed expectations and norms about how we are supposed to perform as women, men, and others, or in relation to sexual orientations; that is, concepts of masculine and feminine and the normative demands of how to behave in order to “properly” represent the bodies we inhabit or are perceived to inhabit. It comes from a particular—and unfortunately, very dominant—understanding of masculinity. This is a masculinity in which ideas such as strength, courage, and protection are equated with violence. It is a masculinity in which the capacity and willingness to use weapons, engage in combat, and kill other human beings is seen as essential to being “a real man.”77 Feminists have long explored the ways in which gender norms, particularly militarized masculinities, drive conflict and violence and the acquisition and proliferation of weapons. These scholars and activists argue that the association of power and strength, coded as masculine traits, with the accumulation and use of weapons, has a negative impact on disarmament and peace.78 Militarized masculinity harms everyone. It harms those who do not comply with mainstream gender norms— queer-identified people, nonnormative men—and it harms women. It requires oppression of those deemed “weaker” on the basis of gender norms. It also assumes men to be inherently violent and inclined to participate in violent acts—and thus also more expendable.79 And it makes disarmament seem weak. It makes peace seem utopian. It makes protection without weapons seem absurd. When it comes to nuclear weapons, several dimensions to the connection between patriarchal power and militarist masculinities contribute to the difficulty in advocating for nuclear disarmament. We can start with the “ubiquitous weight of gender” throughout the entire nuclear weapon discourse and the association of nuclear weapons with masculinity that Carol Cohn described in her groundbreaking work in the 1980s mentioned earlier. Her analysis of the gendered symbolism of nuclear weapons developed through a discourse of “defense intellectuals” provided the foundations for a feminist analysis of nuclear war, nuclear strategy, and nuclear weapons. She described the “sanitized abstraction and sexual imagery,” including metaphors that equate military and political power with sexual potency and masculinity—such as “vertical erector launchers, thrust-to-weight ratios, soft lay downs, deep penetration, the comparative advantages of protracted versus spasm attacks,” and discussions about how “the Russians are a little harder than we are.”80 She and Sara Ruddick suggested that this type of highly sexualized language serves to “mobilize gendered associations and symbols in creating assent, excitement, support for, and identification with weapons.”81 It is also “a way of minimizing the seriousness of militarist endeavors, of denying their deadly consequences.”82 In later years Cohn, along with Ruddick and Felicity Ruby, expanded the inquiry into the sense of masculine strength afforded by nuclear weapons, tying this into some of the broader feminist analysis about violent and militarized masculinities discussed above. They listened to a nationalist leader after India’s 1998 nuclear weapon tests explain, “We had to prove that we are not eunuchs.” They argue that this statement is meant to “elicit admiration for the wrathful manliness of the speaker” and to imply that being willing to employ nuclear weapons is to “have the balls” or to be “man enough” to “defend” your country.83 This link between masculinity and the power of force persists today. Think of Trump “becoming presidential” by launching missiles at Syria84 or of Kim Jong-un and his massive parades of missile hardware in a literal showcase of “mine is bigger than yours.”85 Think of Theresa May giving a resolute yes to the question of whether she would be willing to “personally authorize a nuclear strike that could kill 100,000 innocent men, women and children.”86 It is, after all, women leaders as well as men who are conditioned to prove their capacity to lead by a “manly” show of force. Simply adding women to the situation is not sufficient to achieve nuclear disarmament. And “men” as a category are not specifically or exclusively the problem. Gendered norms, in particular violent or militarized masculinities, are the main problem. The structural imbalance of power among gender identities is also the problem. A recent study published by New America paints a portrait of the nuclear policy field in the United States, dominated as it is by cisgender heterosexual white men who compose a self-described “nuclear priesthood” that espouse normative masculinized perspectives on security and weapons. Seeking a place at the table within this space, women (mostly white, cisgender women) tend to be inclined to try to gain favor with and impress the priesthood, seeing it as an important challenge to fit in and prove that women are “not afraid of nuclear weapons.”87 As a case in point, the U.S. nuclear weapon team under the Obama administration included women in the roles of secretary of state (Hillary Clinton), undersecretary of state for arms control and international security affairs (Ellen Tauscher), assistant secretary of state for verification, compliance, and implementation (Rose Gottemoeller), special representative of the president for nuclear proliferation (Susan Burk), permanent representative to the United Nations (Susan Rice), and permanent representative to the Conference on Disarmament (Laura Kennedy). Yet the Obama administration pursued the biggest nuclear arms buildup since Reagan and vociferously opposed negotiations of a nuclear weapon ban treaty. Similarly, as of the beginning of 2019, the CEOs of four of the five biggest weapon producers in the United States—Northrop Grumman, Lockheed Martin, General Dynamics, and the military wing“Terminally Unserious” 29 of Boeing—are now women.88 These women are not challenging the patriarchal structures and systems that have created the militarized world order; they are actively maintaining it and profiting from it. The solution to the dominance of toxic masculinity in disarmament discourse or capitalism in the nuclear-industrial complex is not simply to include women. Liberal feminism is “dedicated to enabling a privileged few to climb the corporate ladder or the ranks of the military,” through which it “subscribes to a market-centred view of equality that dovetails with corporate enthusiasm for ‘diversity,’” Nancy Fraser, Tithi Bhattacharya, and Cinzia Arruzza have written for a new feminist manifesto. Rather than abolish social hierarchy, liberal feminism “aims to feminize it, ensuring women at the top can attain parity with the men of their own class.”89 As Cynthia Enloe says, “You can militarize anything, including equality.”90 To actually challenge policies and practices of the elite decisionmaking class, it is imperative to create space—inside but also outside of existing institutions—where women and others of diverse gender identities, races and ethnicities, backgrounds and experiences—who are willing and able to approach the issue from different perspectives, including feminist and human security perspectives—can be fully engaged. A lesson from feminist, queer, and Indigenous struggles, among others, is that appealing to the establishment for rights or equality or a seat at the table is at best insufficient to achieve change, and at worst serves to reinforce existing injustices by just making problematic institutions or processes appear more palatable or equitable without actually changing anything those institutions do. In order for true alternative perspectives to be treated as relevant, credible, and expert—to the same extent as the dominant, toxic, militarized masculinity perspectives—we don’t just need diverse participation in mainstream institutions. We must consider and create alternative spaces and relationships in order to engage in meaningful processes. Just as Indigenous struggles refuse to center or appeal to whiteness, and queer struggles refuse to center or appeal to the cisgendered or straight community, we need to work with others whose beliefs are outside the dominant, mainstream narrative of nuclear weapons to generate a new sense of what is normative and credible.91 This is important for the story of the nuclear ban and for nuclear abolition more broadly, because changing what people view as credible and normative about nuclear weapons is vital to achieving change in nuclear weapon policy. We need to not center the dominant frameworks of thought on nuclear weapons—which were created predominantly by white, cisgender, heteronormative men—but to bring a robust critical approach to these frameworks by centering the perspectives, ideas, and frameworks of thought developed by others who have traditionally been excluded from this area.