The alt is key—patriarchal norms surrounding cybersecurity prioritize masculine institutions and incentivize victim-blaming, which creates serial policy failure
Millar, Shires, and Tropina 21
Katharine, Assistant Professor of International Relations at the London School of Economics and Political Science; James, Assistant Professor with the Institute of Security and Global Affairs at the Leiden University, the Netherlands, and a fellow with the Cyber Statecraft Initiative at the Atlantic Council; Tatiana, Assistant Professor in Cybersecurity Governance with the Institute of Security and Global Affairs at Leiden University. “Defence.” Gender approaches to cybersecurity: design, defence and response. United Nations Institute for Disarmament Research 2021. Pg 40-41. LJS
Incident response – organizational measures to handle network intrusions, attacks, data breaches and other malicious cyber acts – is characterized by a hierarchy of priorities. Studies have shown that the cybersecurity industry reports on and responds to certain victims (commercial organizations, governments) that are associated with “traditional” security and the activities of elite men disproportionately, and it has a blind spot for threats to civil society and human security (e.g. non-governmental organizations, educational institutions and individuals).116 As schools, non-governmental organizations and individuals are more likely to be concerned with issues of social power, harms and equality, this prioritization has knock-on gender effects. The composition, expected practices and working hours, and workplace culture of incident-response teams also require a gender analysis. There is some evidence that “tech support” teams, which are often the first line of response following a security incident, are predominantly staffed by men, compounding the association of technical expertise with masculinity.117 The composition and culture of Computer Emergency Response Teams (CERTs or CSIRTs) is also a part of cybersecurity response. Research indicates that CERTs have distinct political strategies and characteristics, especially at the national and international levels, and it is possible that these characteristics include gendered dynamics.118 Information sharing – the process of trusted exchange of information about attacks and other security incidents, vulnerabilities, and cybersecurity practices – is also an essential part of responding to cybersecurity threats. The same masculine, national defence norms may also impede States and organizations from sharing information about cyberattacks and system vulnerabilities. Studies suggest that informal “trust communities” are the basis for much cybersecurity information sharing, rather than formal lines of communication between individuals with similar roles.119 The informality of these communities, and the consequent unconscious bias that this permits, means that they may have lower participation from women and minoritized groups, even when adjusted for overall proportions in the industry. Cybersecurity response can also demonstrate an unfortunate gendered dynamic of victim-blaming, wherein organizations or individuals with cybersecurity defence or identity-protection measures that are deemed to be “insufficient” are framed as “asking to be hacked”, which shifts responsibility onto the party that has been harmed, rather than the one who committed harm.120