Feminist policy is the result of feminist activism—the alt is a pre-requisite—top-down gender policy in the West re-creates imperial violence
Wright, Hurley, & Gil Ruiz 19
Katharine A.M., Lecturer in International Politics at Newcastle University, UK; Matthew, Lecturer in Politics at Sheffield Hallam University, UK; Jesus Ignacio, former Chief of the NATO IMS Office of the Gender Advisor. “The long view Situating NATO’s engagement with women, peace and security.” NATO, Gender, and the Military: Women Organising from Within. Routledge Studies in Gender and Security. 2019. Pg 42-43. LJS
The realm of international peace and security remained resistant to advocacy around women’s rights and gender until relatively recently. A case in point is the fact that the UN Security Council with primary responsibility for the maintenance of international peace and security under the UN Charter did not consider gender issues until 2000 and the adoption of UNSCR 1325 on WPS. The internal politics of the Security Council were undoubtedly crucial to realise the adoption of this Resolution. Yet, the Resolution did not emerge in a vacuum with wider developments in global politics helping to make it possible (Tryggestad 2009: 542). The end of the Cold War also contributed, freeing the Security Council from its deadlock and allowing space for the emergence of gender onto the Security Council’s agenda. Further, the very type of thematic resolution which UNSCR 1325 is an example of would have been unthinkable during the Cold War but gained traction in the late 1990s and early 2000s (Tryggestad, 2009: 543). It is therefore salient to consider the wider global political landscape which contributed to the adoption of UNSCR 1325. Superpower politics during the Cold War shaped feminist advocacy at the UN and contributed to isolating the issue of ‘violence against women’ from the international agenda (Harrington, 2011). This has a significant impact on the efficacy of transnational feminist advocacy. For example, it led to the isolation of US women’s groups from more radical (and socialist) groups around the globe but also within the US itself. And while Non-Governmental Organisations (NGOs) could apply for ‘consultative status’ to give them access to UN debates and meetings from 1946, some of these NGOs inevitably became subject to intervention by the US and Soviet Union (Harrington, 2011: 561). A case in point is the communist Women’s International Democratic Federation which the Soviet Union used as a vehicle to promote Soviet propaganda (Weigand, 2002: 49). When women’s rights were discussed in a UN context, Cold War politics and the dichotomy between East and West defined the nature of discussion. At the 1975 UN World Conference on Women in Mexico, the Soviet Union wanted to debate a wide range of issues, including capitalism. In contrast, the US wanted to narrow discussion to women’s legal equality (Ghodsee cited in Harrington, 2011: 563). At the same, gender issues remained marginal to ‘everyday’ Cold War politics. The US and Soviet Union did not criticise each other over gender issues, even when there was a case to do so. This is despite the fact that the US was drawing upon women’s rights to oppose other regimes at the time (Enloe, 1989: 57). This silencing is particularly visible in relation to their respective international interventions in Afghanistan in the 1980s. For example, the US did not draw attention to the hypocrisy of the Soviet Union purporting to protect Afghan women, while the Red Army used prostitutes and perpetrated sexual violence. Likewise, the Soviet Union (and UN recognised NGOs) did not point out that the US, in supporting the Afghan Mujahedeen, was supporting a patriarchal regime pitted against one advancing women’s rights (Moghadam cited in Harrington, 2011: 563). The end of the Cold War appeared to open up space for the international community to consider women’s rights as an issue of international peace and security. However, the issues considered remained limited. This period of US hegemony coincided with the US emerging as a women’s rights champion, albeit supporting a narrow remit of issues. It was human trafficking, wartime rape and domestic violence which became prominent issues for the women’s sector at the UN (Harrington, 2011: 565). While Joachim has argued that this represented domestic feminist lobbying finding alignment with the Clinton administration’s world views (Joachim, 2003: 259), Harrington urges caution. She argues that violence against women emerged as an issue against the ‘new wars’ discourse because it provided a reason for policing and surveillance (Harrington, 2011: 566). Violence against women had become embedded within the militarised project of democracy promotion and the accompanying political and economic transformation it advocates. Women’s rights and gender issues were included instrumentally. They provided a means for states and institutions such as NATO to ‘criminalise’ their military targets through the ‘new wars’ doctrine pitting ‘alliances of democratic state and non-state actors against militia that control populations through rape and other forms of bodily atrocity’ (Harrington, 2011: 566). This dichotomy between the democratic West and the enemy ‘other’ also found a gendered articulation in the War on Terror. Bush, and later Obama, drew on a masculinist protectionist logic in their discourse on the War on Terror (Messerschmidt, 2016: 167). For example, the 2001 US-led intervention in Afghanistan drew on the emancipation of Afghan women as a supplementary justification. The logic invoked a rationale that to defend our universal civilisation we must rescue Afghan women (Cooke, 2002: 485–6). Ultimately, the implication of women’s rights in the ‘geopolitical manoeuvrings of powerful global actors’ makes the invocation of the ‘principled politics solidarity’ extremely problematic (Kandiyoti, 2007: 505). As Harrington (2011: 567) argues, it ‘contributes to a hegemonic conflation of women’s equality with “Western” (or Northern) civilization, and women’s oppression with an undeveloped “rest”, obscuring “Western” agency in both male privilege and violence against women’.