Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

NATO’s WPS agenda proves state action can be good—Gender Advisors materially improve the lives of marginalized people globally

Wright 22

Katharine A.M., Lecturer in International Politics at Newcastle University, UK. “Challenging civil society perceptions of NATO: Engaging the Women, Peace and Security agenda.” Cooperation and Conflict. April 2022. LJS

NATO’s own external presentation of the work of its Gender Advisors is largely extremely positive.52 The most comprehensive reviews of their work have been upbeat overall. Egnell, Hojem, and Berts’ presented Gender Advisors’ as having ‘made a gender perspective a real and permanent feature of Swedish contributions to international operations’53 We asked Gender Advisors what they felt had been their key successes. Their responses are scrutinized in two directions: first, internal: in terms of changing mindsets within their military structures as regards women and the relevance of gender (an aspect of regendering, discussed above) and changing their colleagues’ working practices; second, external: in terms of impacts upon communities – improving security for women and men, and increasing women’s participation. Changes in Military Practice and Mindsets Overwhelmingly, Gender Advisors tended to describe their success in terms of ‘institutionalization’ and ‘integration’ of procedures to include gender perspectives. The Gender Advisors generally conveyed a sense of slow but steady progress in acceptance of the relevance of gender to militaries, and processes to facilitate consideration of it in military operations. Lackenbauer and Langlais’ 2013 review had found that ISAF Gender Advisors had little structure for their work, having to decide on their own focus and tasks. The more recently deployed Gender Advisors we interviewed described established processes for Gender Advisors’ engagement in planning, identification of goals and indicators; more access to command; and fuller staffing of Gender Advisor posts. Those who been involved in the Resolute Support Mission in Afghanistan, which commenced in January 2015, described gender as integrated in the Mission’s indicators and reporting mechanisms; operational plans and standard operating procedures; facilities, activities, budgets; and focusing not only upon women but upon influencing men. Some Gender Advisors describe a key mark of progress as the recognition by the command that integrating gender perspective is their responsibility, advised and supported by their Gender Advisor, rather than the responsibility of the Gender Advisor. When it started in 2008 … they put a lot of responsibility on the Gender Field Advisor. And then it was very easy to criticise the work because it’s very difficult to be successful if you’re, like, alone and … no one really knows what is this about … now the organisation has a full understanding and acceptance of this, and that is that the work of integrating a gender perspective should always be the Commander’s … So absolutely, absolutely it has evolved. (Agnes) Another ISAF Gender Advisor recounted being in a senior staff meeting in which the commander asked who was going to a conference organized by Afghan women. When eyes slid to the Gender Advisor, the commander said, ‘I am on board. We will push this button. And if I do it, you have to do it too’ (meaning they all had to go to the conference). Although describing gender as a ‘button’ raises questions, the Gender Advisor interpreted this as the commander reiterating the importance for all parts of the Mission of engaging with Afghan women. As evidence of institutionalization through the headquarters or operation, a number of Gender Advisors described colleagues independently including gender in planning documents or analyses. Many highlighted changing their colleagues’ mindset as regard the relevance of gender. Security and Women’s Empowerment A number of Gender Advisors gave examples of how their advice had been used to mitigate the harm that NATO’s own activities might pose to women. Some mentioned using a gender perspective in analysing intelligence so as to mitigate ‘collateral damage’ in NATO targeting. One described broadening consultation with local communities to include women, so to understand what roads they used, to be able to avoid them. One spoke of ‘prevent[ing] an American General killing some women’ by advising on how funding might be provided to community projects without inflaming local rivalries. Gender Advisors, however, most often described their successes as hoped-for impacts of their individual contacts with local women: having facilitated their coming together, inspiring them to join the security forces, motivating them. The first thing I wrote was a zero … [but] I met Afghan women and would see them six months later with burkhas off, talking to soldiers, trying to negotiate for funds … maybe a little drop that fills up the bucket, for me, that is enough. (Workshop participant) I hope that I have motivated one woman to not give up and keep fighting for women’s rights. (Workshop participant) A number of Gender Advisors had worked to support Afghan security forces in integrating women, and felt that their advocacy with the Afghan authorities to emphasize the importance of women’s participation had been successful. One talked about directly supporting female police through helping them to set up their own network; another about Gender Advisors’ support to centres and protection units dealing with gender based violence. Others talked about being role models for Afghan women to join the security forces. We noticed that, although the description of a Gender Advisor’s role in Bi-Strategic Directive 40-1 refers to gender analysis and collection of data, none identified progress by reference to measured changes in, for example, prevalence of acts of violence or community perceptions of security.54 They did not claim systematic positive impacts upon the lives of communities affected by conflict or by NATO operations; rather small wins and hopeful signals.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.