Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Perm do both—the aff acts as a critical friend to NATO which is key to nuanced understandings that change institutions and avoid co-optation

Wright, Hurley, & Gil Ruiz 19

Katharine A.M., Lecturer in International Politics at Newcastle University, UK; Matthew, Lecturer in Politics at Sheffield Hallam University, UK; Jesus Ignacio, former Chief of the NATO IMS Office of the Gender Advisor. “Introduction.” NATO, Gender, and the Military: Women Organising from Within. Routledge Studies in Gender and Security. 2019. Pg 5-6. LJS

Much to the benefit of the feminist IR, there are numerous critical engagements and conversations between feminists on approaches to the study of security, war and the institutions that wage them. Sylvester (2013) and Duncanson (2013) acknowledge a tension between what can be broadly described as an ‘anti-militarist’ feminism and what Sylvester calls ‘new’ feminist war studies that seek to centralise the accounts of women as agents within institutions of war (2013: 49) (see also Lobasz and Sjoberg, 2011: 574). Sylvester notes unease between women who self-identify as feminists but depart from common advocacy of peaceful conflict resolution, or a strident anti-militarism. Similarly, Duncanson (2013) identifies a tension between feminists who view militaries as useful in the pursuit of peace (Olsson and Tryggestad, 2001; Kaldor, 2012; Kronsell, 2012) and those who are much more sceptical about the role and place of militaries and militarism (Whitworth, 2004); between those whom she calls ‘feminist sceptics of military intervention’ and ‘feminist sceptics’ (Duncanson, 2013: 2). This tension becomes acute when considering sites of feminist research and the role of feminist researcher: as Sylvester (2013: 39) notes: ‘Gender and war is a very fraught coupling and the men and women who join the institution of war or work within it can put observers in a conundrum: to support them, take no position, look the other way?’ What Sylvester is commenting on is the notion that by centralising institutions of war and the individuals that choose to work within them as a site of feminist analysis, this somehow promotes, reinforces and legitimates those structures. Yet, Kronsell (2005, 2006, 2012) highlights how solely focusing on women at the ‘margins’ of International Relations, on those ‘outside of hegemonic institutions’ such as the military, tends to underestimate the significance of the transformative work of those women who work ‘inside’ such organisations (Kronsell, 2005: 289). In advancing a ‘revitalised’ standpoint theory, Kronsell (2005: 289) also argues that a reluctance to engage with women within hegemonic institutions perpetuates certain assumptions about them: Women within such institutions have been perceived as either co-opted or too few to be representative of women’s knowledge or standpoint. Standpoint theory’s tendency to emphasise knowledge generated by women only in particular ‘women’s spaces’ has led to the implication that an occasional woman with power is either a male in disguise or a mere token. It is not our intention to promote, reinforce or legitimate NATO as an international actor through this book. But it is our intent to offer a feminist critique of its gendered institutional norms, practices and structures by centralising the experience of those women who have worked and continue to work within it. We see our role as ‘critical friends’. In introducing this concept of a ‘critical friend’ we build on the work of Rech et al. (2015: 56). They contend that the study of the military, of militarism, and of processes of militarisation, should not be undertaken solely for its own sake, but should also be guided by the possibility of engagement with the forces and institutions responsible, and should not be bashful about doing so. This is because such institutions are ultimately accountable to the civilian world, and understanding how they function is necessary to critique them (rather than dismiss them) (Enloe, 1993; Rech et al., 2015: 56). Being a ‘critical friend’ means rejecting problem-solving approaches which ‘takes the world as it finds it’ and aims ‘to makes these relationships and institutions work smoothly by dealing effectively with particular sources of trouble’ (Cox, 1981: 128–9). Rather, it means adopting a critical approach which calls these institutions into question and accounts for the possibility of their change. In so doing it opens up the possibility for research to be normatively guided (Cox, 1981: 129–30). Being a ‘critical friend’ to military institutions therefore entails engaging in complex and nuanced arguments and situating these in broader political considerations and in more nuanced ways than simplistic ‘pro-military’ or ‘anti-military’ positions are able to accommodate (Rech et al., 2015: 56). It means a commitment to praxis, which necessities engagement. Military institutions are often secretive, complex and contradictory, this means critical agendas can be vulnerable to co-option (as we discuss in Chapter 4). Researchers as ‘critical friends’ therefore need to engage in an ongoing process of reflexivity from the outset of any project.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.