Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Gender is not the root cause of violence or ontological and cant explain the case -- violence is constructed by many axes of oppression

Olena Hankivsky 12, Professor in the School of Public Policy, Simon Fraser University, June 2012, Women’s health, men’s health, and gender and health: Implications of intersectionality, Social Science & Medicine, http://www.sciencedirect.com.turing.library.northwestern.edu/science/article/pii/S0277953612000408

Using an intersectionality framework, researchers have noted the explanatory limitations of single axis designs centered on sex and gender. Cole (2009) has warned that analyses that focus on gender are problematic because they often “implicitly assume a host of other social statuses that usually go unnamed in American culture: middle-class standing, heterosexuality, able-bodiedness and White race” (p. 173). Others have explicated similar limitations. For example, studies in the field of violence (Bent-Goodley, 2007; Craig-Taylor, 2008; Crenshaw, 1995; Nixon & Humphreys, 2010; Sandelowski, Barroso, & Voils, 2009) show that violence against women is not only a matter of gendered power relationships but is co-constructed with racial and class stratification, heterosexism, ageism, and other systems of oppression, some of which may be more salient within such interactions. Research on cardiovascular disease (CVD) (Brister, Hamdulay, Verma, Maganti, & Buchanan, 2007; King, LeBlanc, Carr, & Quan, 2007; King, LeBlanc, Sanguins, & Mather, 2006) shows that focussing on sex and gender often obscures the fact that CVD is disproportionately experienced by racial ethnic and low-income groups whose lives are shaped by intersecting processes of differentiation along the lines of age, sex, ethnic group affiliation, socioeconomic class, and geography. Finally, HIV/AIDS research (Dworkin, 2005; Elford, Anderson, Bukutu, & Ibrahim, 2006; Jackson & Reimer, 2008; Meyer, Costenbader, Zule, Otiashvili, & Kirtadze, 2010; Young & Meyer, 2005) demonstrates that gender and sexuality cannot be separated from other axes including race, class, age, religious affiliation, and immigration status and the structural economic, political, and social processes that shape them. For example, in her analysis of surveillance categories for HIV, Dworkin (2005) argues that pushing beyond a singular sex/gender system to explore the simultaneity of race, class, and shifting gender relations is vital to the future of the HIV epidemic and in particular, for making visible bisexual and lesbian transmission risks. Emerging research thus demonstrates that there are many groups which “do not necessarily identify gender oppression as the primary frame through which they understand their lives” (Nixon & Humphreys, 2010, p. 150). In Canada, as in many other jurisdictions, this is especially apparent with growing immigrant populations whose health is primarily affected by dislocation, isolation, loss of identity, culture, and meaningful employment and Aboriginal/Indigenous populations whose health and well-being is largely determined by unresolved colonial injustices and ongoing experiences of racism and poverty (Alfred, 2005; Waldrum, Herring, & Young, 2006). Further, the emphasis on gender (and sex) often leads to a focus on differences between women and men. This helps to explain why so much data continues to be collected, organized, and presented solely around sex and gender differences even when similarities between women and men are demonstrated (e.g. Hyde, 2005; Petersen, 2009), differences among women and among men are often as significant if not more than between women and men (Crawshaw & Smith, 2009; Varcoe, Hankivsky, & Morrow, 2007), and men are sometimes subordinate to some women and some women exercise power over some men (Pease, 2006). Nevertheless, numerous reviews of sex based and gender differences continue to be produced (Gochfeld, 2010; Read & Gorman, 2010). Moreover, even in some frameworks that seek to include considerations of both sex and gender, as in the sex and gender based analysis (SGBA) tool developed in Canada (e.g. Clow et al., 2009), proposed guides construct lines of interrogation that prioritize examinations of similarities and differences between women and men. As Clow et al. (2009) state, “SGBA reminds us to ask questions about similarities and differences among women and men, such as: Do women and men have the same susceptibility to lung disease from smoking? Are women at the same risk as men of contracting HIV/AIDS through heterosexual intercourse? Are the symptoms of heart disease the same in women and men?.” (p. 1). Within this type of construct, differences that are shaped and formed by factors outside of sex and gender are treated as secondary in importance, if at all.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.