Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

US democracy promotion is imperialist, hypocritical and bolsters authoritarian surveillance

Klyman 22

Kevin Klyman researches US-China relations and has written data protection policies adopted by the World Health Organization. “Biden’s Campaign for “Digital Democracy” Is Really a Giveaway to Big Tech”, Jacobin. 6/26/22. --JrH

American democracy promotion has been a calamity, to put it lightly. This century alone, the United States has helped violently overthrow the governments of Iraq, Afghanistan, Libya, Haiti, Bolivia, and Honduras, leaving and tens of millions more , all in the name of democracy. The irony is potent: at home, the United States responded to 2020’s mass protests against police brutality with yet more police brutality, and 2021 began with an attempted coup galvanized by the outgoing president and his political party. Despite the wreckage and the hypocrisy, democracy promotion remains a centerpiece of US foreign policy, and is mobilized as a justification for American goals, whatever they may be. With respect to technology, US policymakers have called for the promotion of “digital democracy” and opposition to “digital authoritarianism” emanating from China. The narrative of democracy triumphing over high-tech dictatorship obscures America’s real goal, which is to prevent Beijing from displacing Washington as the leader in global surveillance and the owner of much of the world’s internet infrastructure. US technology strategy has the same underlying motivation as many other policies that ostensibly aim to promote democracy: opening up markets so that American firms can sell their products abroad. What the tech industry and policymakers have dubbed “digital democracy” is just a recapitulation of US imperialism with respect to the pursuit of global technology dominance. Promoting digital democracy is dangerous for three reasons. First, the United States and other electoral democracies engage in indiscriminate mass surveillance around the world. Second, the US government foists technology policies on poor countries that largely benefit Big Tech. Third, the narrative that innovative American companies are more righteous than their illiberal Chinese counterparts manufactures consent for US-backed surveillance. Voting for the Panopticon “Digital democracy” is by nature defined against digital authoritarianism. The Brookings Institution — which from Google, Facebook, and Amazon — digital authoritarianism as “the use of digital information technology by authoritarian regimes to surveil, repress, and manipulate domestic and foreign populations.” This raises the question: What about when democracies use the same tactics? The Information Technology and Innovation Foundation — a think tank by Apple, Microsoft, and Uber — that democracies, unlike authoritarian states, would never abuse technology: “Authoritarian nations will use technology for authoritarian purposes. Democratic nations will use them for legitimate and civil-liberty-protecting purposes.” This kind of black-and-white thinking creates a self-reinforcing logic: when democratic states and their tech companies engage in surveillance, we can assume that it is for the cause of freedom, but when authoritarian states do it, it is for the purpose of social control. Was the NSA on Angela Merkel’s phone calls a triumph of representative government? Are YouTube’s efforts to Palestinian activists justified by the will of the majority? Is Facebook facilitating genocide in Myanmar and “what democracy looks like”? Apparently so. In truth, spying on people and stealing their data is abhorrent regardless of the nature of the government performing or sanctioning that surveillance. Regrettably, surveillance capitalism has become a in the global economy. Across the world’s democracies, republics, oligarchies, monarchies, theocracies, and dictatorships, accumulating data for profit has become the modus operandi of many companies. US technology strategy has the same underlying motivation as other policies that ostensibly aim to promote democracy: opening up markets so that American firms can sell their products abroad.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.