Alternative is democratic digital collective – solves surveillance capitalism, cultivates communal and accessible response to sociotechno exploitation
Martell 21
Professor Luke Martell has been a Lecturer, Senior Lecturer, Reader, and Professor of Political Sociology at Sussex. He was Head of the Department of Sociology, Chair of the Social and Political Thought Graduate programme, and President of the University and College Union branch. He is now a part-time Teaching Fellow in the Sociology Department. He teaches modules on 'The Death of Socialism?' and 'Alternative Societies'. His book 'Alternative Societies: For a Pluralist Socialism' will be published by Bristol University Press in 2023. “”, 8/11/21. https://www.ideology-theory-practice.org/blog/surveillance-capitalism-and-digital-alternatives --JrH
So, to recap and clarify key points. Oligopoly and the harvesting and selling of our digital lives has become a norm and a new economic sector of capitalism. State responses, to very different degrees, have been to resist monopolization and ensure modest privacy protections or awareness. Individual responses and those of some organizations have been to use software that blocks tracking and aims to maintain privacy and anonymity. But positive as these methods are, they are in part defensive, limited in what they can achieve against high-level attempts at intrusion, and some of these individualise action. Alongside such state and individual processes, we need a more pro-active and collective approach. This includes stronger regulation and breaking up and taking tech into collective ownership. In the sphere of alternatives, it means expanding and strengthening a parallel sphere, decentralised and federated. And alternatives require putting control in the hands of those affected, so collective democracy with inclusive participation. Then oligopolies are challenged and there is a link between those affected and those in control. But alternatives must be made accessible and more easily understandable to the non-techy and beyond the expert, and do not just have to be an alternative but can be a prefigurative basis for spreading to the way the digital and tech world is more widely. This involves supplementing liberal individual privacy and rights approaches, often defensive within the status quo, with collective democracy and control approaches, more proactive and constructive of alternatives. If there is an erosion of capitalism out of such an approach so there will be also to profit incentives in surveillance capitalism. With an extension of collective control not-for-profit, then motivations for surveillance and data capture are reduced. But this must be done through inclusive democratic control (by workers, users and the community) as much as possible rather than the traditional state, as the latter has its own reasons for surveillance. It should be supplemented by a pluralist, decentralised, federated, digital world to counter oligopoly and power. Democratisation that is inclusive globally is also suited to dealing with differences and divides digitally, e.g. by class or across the Global North and Global South. Taken together this approach implies pluralist democratic socialism as well as liberalism, rather than capitalism or the authoritarian state.