Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The transition to AI including further drives the Global South into economic dependency upon colonial powers

Arun 19 (Chinmayi, Affiliate at Harvard at the Berkman Klein Center for Internet & Society & Fellow of the Information Society Project at Yale Law School, 07-20-19, “AI and the Global South: Designing for Other Worlds” Draft Chapter for the Oxford Handbook of Ethics of AI, https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3403010, pp. 2-3)-qcl

There is an increasing awareness that we should be thinking more about the impact of AI on the Global South. The broad concern is clear enough: if privileged white men are designing the technology and the business models for AI 9 , how will they design for the South? The answer is that they will design in a manner that is at best an uneasy fit, and at worst amplifies existing systemic harm and oppression to horrifying proportions. As ‘Global South’ advocates furrow their brows about AI, they may be thinking of web-based AI designed by people who live in worlds that rarely see power cuts or internet shutdowns and then deployed to the rural hinterlands of countries with poor internet connectivity and only a few hours of electricity a day. They may worry about the resources diverted from education and health-care budgets to technology-centric solutions from the companies that are building these systems. They may be concerned about the surveillance of Southern children through AI for Education, built by people whose own children go to private school and have restricted access to screens. In authoritarian countries, they may lose sleep over AI that uses facial recognition, drones and other forms of surveillance to oppress vulnerable populations. They may worry about the loss of jobs and the impact on economies as AI replaces low-skilled workers. These concerns are not without foundation. Ideas of the past like one laptop per child10 have resulted in spectacular failure despite the bright-eyed optimism and laudable intentions with which they were created. Technology designed out of context may fail to take local resources, social norms and cultural context into account. 'One day delivery’ can mean very different things in Boston and Hyderabad even if the system designed for both cities is the same. Facebook can be fairly harmless in most countries and find itself weaponised in a country with Myanmar’s sociopolitical context, to contribute to genocide.11 It can take effort for Google Maps to be able to account for the favelas of Rio de Janeiro.12 Technology policy frameworks can impact whole countries, as we might have learned from the debate on drug patents and public health in developing world. There are so many ways in which Artificial Intelligence can wreak havoc in Southern countries and affect the human rights of Southern populations. In the absence of local regulation in Southern countries, AI may be deployed in its experimental stages such that the people of these countries bear the risk of harm that may ensue. At a larger scale, AI may impact the economies of these countries by affecting their role in the global economy: several developing countries that benefited from their role in the Internet-driven global economy may gradually find the low skilled outsourced services they offer replaced by automation. The ‘call-centres’ of Bangalore, and employment and business they generate, can be undone as automation makes human intervention unnecessary. Automated cars may result in the cab drivers of New York - famously from all over the world - finding themselves out of work with a redundant skill. We need to begin our journey towards including the South as a priority, and we need to do go beyond the mere use of the phrase in policy documents or speeches. For this, we have to understand the many things we specifically worry about when we speak of the Global South. Who is being left out and endangered?

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.