Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

“Digital democracy” is a myth – US mass surveillance, weakening data privacy protections, banning location all expose the coercive hypocrisy of US “digital authoritarianism”

Klyman 22

Kevin Klyman researches US-China relations and has written data protection policies adopted by the World Health Organization. “Biden’s Campaign for “Digital Democracy” Is Really a Giveaway to Big Tech”, Jacobin. 6/26/22. --JrH

Mejias asked Jacobin, “How can ‘digital democracy’ be so different from ‘digital authoritarianism’ if they run practically on the same technologies and infrastructures? We should be concerned about how easy it would be, technologically, to switch from the former to the latter.” “Belarus used equipment provided by the American company Sandvine to block millions of websites and censor news and social media in the midst of mass protests.” In the United States, algorithmic decision making is already used to  people,  them housing, and  if they receive medical care. The US government’s surveillance capabilities are only growing. The NSA’s surveillance programs are nine years after Edward Snowden exposed them, allowing the US government to covertly  the rest of the world’s internet traffic, read people’s emails, and hack into their devices. In addition, key provisions of the Patriot Act — which  the government to spy on Americans and people outside the United States with no oversight —  in effect. US tech companies devour as much sensitive data as possible. The  of all cross-border data traffic passes through the United States, with 70 percent of global internet traffic  through northern Virginia, the headquarters of many US intelligence agencies. Microsoft, Amazon, and Google  more than half of the world’s major data centers, and along with Meta, they  the rights to two-thirds of the capacity of the world’s undersea fiber-optic cables, which form the  of the internet. As Google’s cofounder Larry Page  twenty years ago, “Everything you’ve ever heard or seen or experienced will become searchable. Your whole life will be searchable.” Government of the People, by the Algorithms, for the Corporations America’s technology policy priorities abroad encompass three key objectives: banning data localization, weakening data protection laws, and eliminating digital services taxes. This deregulatory agenda would eliminate nontariff barriers employed by poor countries to develop their local tech ecosystems and keep predatory multinationals at bay. The US government and Big Tech have relentlessly pressured countries to abstain from adopting such measures — purportedly in the interest of democracy. Data localization regulations  that data generated in a country is stored or processed in that country. The Center for Strategic and International Studies — which Facebook  to work on data localization and digital authoritarianism —  that “data localization can be used as a tool of digital authoritarianism to limit democracy and human rights. . . . This is intended to facilitate these governments’ ability to carry out ‘a crackdown on free expression, privacy, and a range of human rights.’” This is undoubtedly true in many cases. China’s 2017 cybersecurity law  that foreign firms not only store data within China but also provide technical support to Chinese security services conducting investigations. But data localization can also have significant economic benefits for low-income countries. Requirements to store data where it is collected force multinationals to invest in local data centers and data processors, often creating more competition among local companies that store data. Local data storage also  the speed of digital services since the information that fuels applications does not have to be fetched from halfway across the world. Moreover, it lowers  because data does not have to pass through expensive international transit points. This is, in part, why the European Union has adopted de facto data localization requirements. In 2020, the total capacity of data centers in sub-Saharan Africa was just one-quarter that of the city of London. To rectify this gap, Africa’s largest economies, such as , , , Algeria, and , have adopted data localization rules, while countries like Ghana are in the process of implementing similar measures. These laws have  a gold rush on the continent, bringing in billions of dollars of investment and  local data center capacity in the last five years. In Kenya and Nigeria, the price of data has  by 90 percent, due in large part to localization.Data localization can also deliver myriad noneconomic benefits. Storing data locally makes it  for foreign governments to surveil a country’s citizens because they must do so from a significantly greater distance. In the case of the United States, “It is much cheaper for the FBI to issue a national security letter compelling a US-based data host to provide access to their data centres than it is for the NSA to gain access to data stores outside of the USA.” Furthermore, data that is stored locally can be audited by local regulators, enabling them to carry out their democratically mandated functions. Nick Dearden, the director of Global Justice Now, told Jacobinthat measures banning data localization are “going to make it impossible for regulators to properly control what Big Tech is doing and constrain these companies’ activities in the public interest.” Free-market ideologues have dismissed these justifications for data localization measures, paternalistically  that poor countries are “shooting themselves in the foot” by pursuing “digital mercantilism.” The Information Technology and Innovation Foundation has even gone so far as to  that the World Bank, International Monetary Fund, OECD, and US Agency for International Development “all need to cut off foreign aid” to countries with data localization laws.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.