AI capitalism commodifies extracted data to reward dirty business practices of the powerful // OR (LINK) AI economies grows broader capitalistic economic system to reward and favor dirty business practices of the powerful
Verdegem 22, P. Dismantling AI capitalism: the commons as an alternative to the power concentration of Big Tech. AI & Soc (2022). https://doi.org/10.1007/s00146-022-01437-8 Dr. Pieter Verdegem is a Senior Lecturer in Media Theory in the Westminster School of Media and Communication and a member of CAMRI (the Communication and Media Research Institute). – Maren Lien
While data is often considered as a raw material or a commodity, it makes sense to conceptualise it as a form of capital too. This is part of a broader discussion about how value is generated in the contemporary economy (Arvidsson and Colleoni ; Mazzucato ), particularly how value is derived from data and what normative aspects are relevant in the context of data collection and extraction (Couldry and Mejias ; Mezzadra and Neilson ; Zuboff ). Sadowski () argues that treating data as capital allows for a more nuanced and detailed understanding of how AI capitalism functions and is organised. What is the problem with using data to create value, as a resource to develop and optimise AI systems? Mazzucato () analyses contemporary capitalism and highlights the critique that it rewards rent seekers over true value creators. Their rent seeking is based on overcharging prices, undercutting competition—by exploiting particular advantages, e.g., labour, or using a monopoly advantage. Where value creation refers to the use of different types of resources to produce new goods and services, value extraction is defined as “activities focused on moving around existing resources and outputs, and gaining disproportionally from the ensuing trade” (Mazzucato : 6). Data extraction is a particular type of value extraction. Sadowski (: 9) defines data extraction as: “data is taken without meaningful consent and fair compensation for the producers and sources of data”. Evgeny Morozov () follows a similar line of thinking and has coined data extractivism to refer to practices of tech giants launching products not for the revenue but for the data, which is afterwards monetised through different products and services (see also Couldry and Mejias ). It is clear we must scrutinise what the consequences are of data commodification and extraction in AI capitalism as well as considering alternatives.