Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Encoding gender reproduces logics of disposability and authorizes war power against “hated” bodies – blurring the lines between artificial intelligence and embodiment is key to disrupting the naturalization of gender and racial formations

Wilcox ’16 (Lauren Wilcox, PhD, is a Staff Research Scientist in People & AI Research.--“Embodying algorithmic war: Gender, race, and the posthuman in drone warfare”—Article--Volume 48 Issue 1, February 2016--https://journals.sagepub.com/doi/abs/10.1177/0967010616657947)//Marzz

In an early essay with contemporary resonances to the Black Lives Matter movement in the USA, Judith Butler analyzes the video-taped beating of Rodney King in Los Angeles in the 1990s and the acquittal (despite the video evidence) of the police who beat King as indicating that ‘the visual field is not neutral to the question of race; it is itself a racial formation, and episteme, hegemonic and forceful’ and therefore ‘seeing’ is thus not a matter of direct perception as a means to truth but ‘the racial production of the visible, the workings of racial constraints on what it means to “see”’ (Butler, 1993: 16). An ‘inverted projection of white paranoia’ posited the object of violence as subject of violence. This case also speaks to the blurred lines between the war power and police powers of drone warfare and the interventions in Iraq and Afghanistan and the use of violence against racialized bodies (Neocleous, 2014; Holmqvist, 2014). The designation of prayer as a signal of intent to do something ‘nefarious’, the movements of a vehicle as a ‘flanking maneuver’, the interpretation of movement of bodies in the back of a pick-up trick as the use of ‘human shields’ (not that these ‘human shields’ prevented the bombing of the vehicle), and perceived presence of only men and only adolescents or older suggests that greater accuracy of vision is unlikely to serve as a check on the mistakes of either algorithmic or visual analysis when the bodies are already perceived, or rather, felt to be dangerous. The logic of killing based not on identity but on these visual cues taken to resemble the algorithmic ‘pattern of life’ bears a striking resemblance to performative theories of gender in which ‘gender’ is not an essential identity one embodies; rather, one comes to be embodied as a subject through repeated behaviors and practices against a normative framework that renders some modes of life into the category of ‘hated’. J Halberstam writes, ‘Gender, we might argue, like computer intelligence, is a learned, imitative behavior that can be processed so well that it comes to look natural’ (Halberstam, 1991: 443). Halberstam purposefully blurs the line between artificial intelligence and embodied behavior in conjunction with Turing’s ‘other’ test. Somewhat less famous is Turing’s corollary test in which a person interacts over a terminal with a man and a woman in a different room, trying to ascertain from people who may be attempting to deceive the tester based on written language as to which respondent is embodied as a man or a women. While the first test simultaneously posits the possibility of ‘thinking’ without a (human) body (while constructing a cyborg whose represented and enacted bodies are linked via technology), the ‘gender’ Turing test opens up the possibility of failure to unite represented gender embodiment and enacted gender embodiment into a single identity. As Hayles writes, What the Turing test ‘proves’ is that the overlay between the enacted and the represented bodies is no longer a natural inevitability but a contingent production, mediated by a technology that has become so entwined with the production of identity that it can no longer meaningfully be separated from the human subject. (Hayles, 1999: xiii) Gender proves to be a feature of human embodiment that must be represented and read via different technologies, the reading of which will prove crucial for the process of racialization that makes certain bodies killable.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.