Academic alts fail – they don’t make useable alts
Reid Blackman, October 15 2020, “A Practical Guide to Building Ethical AI”, Harvard Business Review, Reid Blackman, Ph.D., is the author of the book Ethical Machines (Harvard Business Review Press, July 2022) and Founder and CEO of Virtue, an AI ethical risk consultancy. He has also been a Senior Advisor to the Deloitte AI Institute, a Founding Member of Ernst & Young’s AI Advisory Board, and volunteers as the Chief Ethics Officer to the non-profit Government Blockchain Association. Reid’s expertise is relied upon by Fortune 500 and Global 1000 companies to speak to and educate their people and to guide them as they create and scale AI ethical risk programs., https://hbr.org/2020/10/a-practical-guide-to-building-ethical-ai
First, there is the academic approach. Academics — and I speak from 15 years of experience as a former professor of philosophy — are fantastic at rigorous and systematic inquiry. Those academics who are ethicists (typically found in philosophy departments) are adept at spotting ethical problems, their sources, and how to think through them. But while academic ethicists might seem like a perfect match, given the need for systematic identification and mitigation of ethical risks, they unfortunately tend to ask different questions than businesses. For the most part, academics ask, “Should we do this? Would it be good for society overall? Does it conduce to human flourishing?” Businesses, on the other hand, tend to ask, “Given that we are going to do this, how can we do it without making ourselves vulnerable to ethical risks?” The result is academic treatments that do not speak to the highly particular, concrete uses of data and AI. This translates to the absence of clear directives to the developers on the ground and the senior leaders who need to identify and choose among a set of risk mitigation strategies.