Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

US control of cyberspace leads to digital colonialism- the US will use data security to exploit the global South

Kwet, Michael 2019 [Visiting Fellow, Information Society Project, Yale Law School PhD Candidate, Sociology, Rhodes University; Digital colonialism: US empire and the New Imperialism in the Global South; Race & Class Volume 60, No. 4 (April 2019); Yale University; https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3232297;]

Today, a new form of corporate colonization is taking place. Instead of the conquest of land, Big Tech corporations are colonizing digital technology. The following functions are all dominated by a handful of US multinationals: search engines (Google); web browsers (Google Chrome); smartphone and tablet operating systems (Google Android, Apple iOS); desktop and laptop operating systems (Microsoft Windows); office software (Microsoft Office, Google Docs); cloud infrastructure and services (Amazon, Microsoft, Google, IBM); social networking platforms (Facebook, Twitter); transportation (Uber, Lyft); business networking (Microsoft LinkedIn); streaming video (Google YouTube, Netflix, Hulu); and online advertising (Google, Facebook) – among others. GAFAM now comprise the five wealthiest corporations in the world, with a combined market cap exceeding $3 trillion.10 If South Africans integrate Big Tech products into their society, the United States will obtain enormous power over their economy and create technological dependencies that will lead to perpetual resource extraction. As an empirical matter, this point has been understudied. Nevertheless, early research and anecdotes suggest the economic impact of Big Tech intermediaries is detrimental to local African industries. Murphy, Carmody, and Surborg studied the role of ICTs among small, medium, and microsized enterprises (SMMEs) in South Africa’s and Tanzania’s wood and tourism industries. They found that ICTs introduced the dominance of information intermediaries. Increased use of ICTs also led to greater worker surveillance in some instances. They concluded that ICT integration is, on balance, benefiting foreign-owned businesses and corporations.1 Similar conclusions can be derived from press accounts of the transportation industry. Since Uber began operating in Johannesburg in 2013, there have been labor strikes and violent clashes in the “South African taxi wars”. Several e-hailing taxi murders have been carried out by metered taxi drivers, who have warned that Uber will “burn” if it remains in South Africa. At the same time, many Uber drivers endure onerous working conditions for low pay.12 Uber has had devastating effects in Africa and beyond.13 The company takes around 25% commission for each trip, in addition to hidden costs,14 leading to an outflow of revenue from the local economy to foreign coffers. Moreover, they are able to undercut local markets by offering artificially low prices: Uber can operate at a loss – to the tune of billions – thanks to funding from Wall Street and other wealthy investors.15 With the backing of corporate finance, it leverages predatory subsidies, network effects, Big Data analytics, and the deregulatory effects of its position as an “intermediary” to stamp out competition and colonize the market. Within just two years, Uber sported a net worth of R1.65 billion (~$125 million) inside SA.16Similar problems have emerged in the media. In April 2017, the online news outlet GroundUp dropped Google Ads from its website. GroundUp’s Nathan Geffen explains the Google advertising model is “broken” for publishers who “have to put up with poor quality, misleading adverts in exchange for small change.” “The problem,” Geffen says, “is that nearly all the power in the online advertising relationship lies with Google.” The ad giant also serves up censorship threats: in one example, Google issued a warning to GroundUp for publishing a picture containing a painted bare breast as part of a protest action.17 In November 2017, Financial Mail’s Anton Harber wrote a feature story deeming Google and Facebook “the biggest threat to South African news media”.18 Google takes 70% of local online advertising, while social media – led by Facebook – takes another 12%. The major SA media groups are left with just 8% of the pie. The Google and Facebook “nemesis” are an expanding duopoloy: they take 77% of online advertising spend in the US and captured virtually all the ad growth in 2016.19 If this continues, Harber exclaims, “the big two could have a devastating effect on the media’s role in defining democracy”.20 These early case examples – the thin integration of ICTs into the wood and tourism industries in South Africa and Tanzania, Uber colonization of taxi markets, and the rising dominance of Google and Facebook in South African media – provide clear instances of digital colonialism whereby foreign corporations undermine local development, dominate the market, and extract revenue from the Global South. As we see next, this power is obtained primarily through the structural domination of digital architecture, which leads to more general forms of imperial control.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.