Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

US control of digital infrastructure locks in a new imperial relationship that extracts value from the global South

Kwet, Michael 2019 [Visiting Fellow, Information Society Project, Yale Law School PhD Candidate, Sociology, Rhodes University; Digital colonialism: US empire and the New Imperialism in the Global South; Race & Class Volume 60, No. 4 (April 2019); Yale University; https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=3232297;]

Under digital colonialism, foreign powers, led by the United States, are planting infrastructure in the Global South engineered for its own needs, enabling economic and cultural domination while imposing privatized forms of governance. To accomplish this task, major corporations design digital technology to ensure their own dominance over critical functions in the tech ecosystem. This allows them to accumulate profits from revenues derived from rent (in the form of intellectual property or access to infrastructure) and surveillance (in the form of Big Data). It also empowers them to exercise control over the flow of information (such as the distribution of news and streaming services), social activities (like social networking and cultural exchange), and a plethora of other political, social, economic, and military functions mediated by their technologies. The control of code is foundational to digital domination. In Code: And Other Laws of Cyberspace, Lawrence Lessig (1999/2006) famously argued that computer code shapes the rules, norms, and behaviors of computer-mediated experiences in ways similar to architecture in physical space (e.g. imperial railways designed for colonization).23 As a result, “code is law” in the sense that it has the power to usurp legal, institutional, and social norms impacting the political, economic, and cultural domains of society. This critical insight has been applied in fields like copyright, free speech regulation, Internet governance, blockchain, privacy, and even torts. What has been missed, however, is how US dominance of code – and other forms of digital architecture – usurps sovereignty in foreign countries. The power of the United States over code and other digital infrastructure constitutes a new form of imperialism. Digital forms of power are linked together through the three core pillars of the digital ecosystem: software, hardware, and network connectivity.24 Software is the set of instructions that define and determine what your computer can do. Hardware is the physical equipment used for computer experiences. The network is the set of protocols and standards computers use to talk to each other, and the connections they make. Domination over these three elements – software, hardware, and networks – provides a great source of power over people. Let us consider each in turn. Software is the coded logic that constrains and enables particular user experiences. For example, software determines rules and policies such as whether or not users can post a message anonymously at a website, or whether or not users can make a copy of a copyright-restricted file like an e-book. The rules that a programmer codes into the software largely determines technological freedoms and shapes users’ experiences using their devices. Thus, software exerts a powerful influence on the behavior, policies, and freedoms of people using digital technology. Control over software is a source of digital domination primarily exercised through software licenses and hardware ownership. Free Software licenses allow people to use, study, modify, and share software as they see fit.25 By contrast, non-free software licenses grant a software designer control over users by precluding the ability to exercise those freedoms. With proprietary software, the humanreadable source code is closed off to the public, and owners usually restrict the ability to use the software without paying. In the case of Microsoft Windows, for example, the public must pay for the program in order to use it, they cannot read the source code to understand how it works, they cannot change its behavior by changing the code, and they cannot share a copy with others. Thus with proprietary licensing, Microsoft maintains absolute control over how the software works. The same goes for other proprietary apps, like Google Play or Adobe Photoshop.26 By design, non-free software provides the owner power over the user experience. It is authoritarian software. Control over hardware is a second source of digital domination. This can take at least three forms: software run on third-party servers, centralized ownership of hardware, or hardware designed to prevent users from changing the software. Let us consider each of these in turn. In the first instance, software is executed on someone else’s computer. As a result, users are dispossessed of their ability to control it. This is typically accomplished through Software as a Service (SaaS) in the cloud. For example, when you visit the Facebook website, the interface you are provided executes on third party hardware (i.e. on Facebook’s cloud servers). Because users cannot change the code running on Facebook’s servers, they cannot get rid of the “like” button or change the Facebook experience. “There is no cloud,” the saying goes, “just someone else’s computer.” Corporations and other third parties design cloud services for remote control over the user experience. This gives them immense power over individuals, groups, and society.27 In the second instance, people become dispossessed of hardware ownership itself. With the rise of cloud computing, it is possible that hardware manufacturers will soon only offer low-powered, lowmemory devices (similar to the terminals of the 1960s and 1970s) and computer processing and data storage will be primarily conducted in centralized clouds. With end-users dispossessed of processing power and storage, software and data would be under the absolute control of the owners and operators of clouds.28 In the third instance, hardware is manufactured with locks that prevent users from changing the software on the devices. By locking down devices to a pre-determined set of software choices, the hardware manufacturer determines which software is allowed to run when you turn on your device.29 Thus, hardware restrictions can prevent the public from controlling their devices, granting device manufacturers them power over users. Control over network connectivity is a third source of digital domination. Net neutrality regulation proposes that Internet traffic should be “neutral” so that Internet Service Providers (ISPs) treat content flowing through their cables, cellular towers, and satellites equally. According this philosophy, those who own the pipes are “common carriers” and should almost never be allowed to manipulate the data that flows through them.30 This constrains the ability of wealthy media providers to pay for faster content delivery speeds than less wealthy providers (such as grassroots organizations, small businesses, and common people). More importantly, by treating traffic equally, net neutrality prevents network discrimination against various forms of traffic critical to civil rights and liberties. For example, the Tor browser facilitates anonymous Internet communications, but the use of the Tor network can be detected by Internet Service Providers and throttled (i.e. slowed to a crawl).31 Net neutrality prevents this form of discrimination and protects the end user’s freedom to utilize the Internet as they wish, without third party favoritism, blocking, or throttling. Each of the three pillars of the digital ecosystem – software, hardware, and network – constitute a source of power and control. To illustrate the point, let us consider some concrete examples related to social justice in the Global South. The copyright industry is threatened by the mass sharing of paywalled publications over the Internet (what they derisively label “piracy”). Given that hard drive capacity and Internet speeds will rapidly increase over time, the capacity to share vast libraries of music, movies, books, and other media is steadily increasing. What will be done when each person has a 40 terabyte hard drive and can trade the entire collection of popular music from the last century within an hour? Advances in technology deepen the need for architectural control to police the copyright system. One way to stop file sharing is to control software. The industry built Digital Rights Management (DRM) software, for example, to prevent copyright-restricted publications from playing on a user’s computer unless the user pays to access it first. This works well with proprietary software because people cannot remove the DRM. However, if the DRM software is Free Software – which allows people the freedom to use, study, modify, and share the software – people can remove the DRM code that locks the content. Thus, industry is bolstered by proprietary software as a means to enforce copyright. A second way to prevent sharing is to take control of the hardware. If, for example, people stop running software on their own devices – and instead run their computer experiences through centralized cloud servers – then cloud providers can determine their “access” to copyrighted data. In this scenario, users cannot copy and trade media over the Internet because the data “streams” to their device from a content owner’s platform (e.g. Netflix or Spotify) which provides media content through their servers. Thus, the widespread distribution of storage capacity and broadband Internet threatens the copyright monopoly.32 A third way to prevent sharing media is to control the network. People may own and control their software and hardware, but if they can be spied on by an ISP or government, then they can be fined or arrested for copyright infringement, or have their Internet connection throttled or terminated. People might use privacy protection technologies to conceal their content sharing – such as the Tor network or Virtual Private Networks (VPNs) – but this can be thwarted by ISPs throttling Tor or VPNs. In this scenario, control of the network (ISP discrimination) is used to make anonymous content sharing impractical. Thus, public control of the network threatens copyright enforcement. To bring this back to colonialism, US multinationals have designed digital architecture which, in one way or another, allows them to accumulate vast fortunes based on rent or data extraction. In the case of copyright, control over software, hardware, or the Internet is used to protect the copyright monopoly in the name of intellectual property rights. Given that the marginal cost of producing digital works is near-zero, prominent intellectuals have challenged copyright paywalls in the interest of socioeconomic justice and out of concern that draconian technologies are needed to enforce digital forms of copyright.33 Free access to digital publications for all people on planet earth, irrespective oftheir wealth, could improve education, culture, equality, democracy, and innovation. Western technology has been engineered to block free sharing, which impoverishes poor people’s ability to obtain knowledge and culture and reduces communication between rich and poor. Facebook’s Free Basics service offers another case example of how Big Tech corporations expand empire in the Global South. Free Basics offers a stripped-down version of free Internet services to people with little or no disposable income. Facebook decides which content and websites the poor can access – while of course offering Facebook itself within the app. Free Basics is zero-rated by ISPs, meaning that data transfers inside the app are paid for by ISPs instead of their customers. The ISPs hope that the limited Internet experience will lead to paying customers who, having tasted a free sample, will purchase data for the full experience. Free Basics not only has Facebook playing Internet gatekeeper of the poor, it also violates net neutrality laws: zero-rated offerings place content providers on unequal footing. Several countries have terminated Free Basics, in part due to popular backlash.34 However, Internet.org has put over 100 million users from over 60 countries – including South Africa – into the Facebook platform, which channels them towards the Facebook ecosystem. Integrating platforms like Facebook outside the US does more than drain local advertising revenue: it undermines various forms of local governance. Seventy-five percent of web publisher’s traffic now comes from Google (46%) and Facebook (29%).35 Centralization of services into their hands provides them with centralized control over communications – by way of code. These two firms filter search results and news feeds with proprietary black box algorithms, granting them enormous power to shape who sees which news. Leftist outlets have published data suggesting that Google censors socialist views, while Facebook has been found to favor mainstream liberal media.36 Platforms also regulate freedom of speech and association.37 If an online social network detects certain keywords and forms of speech, they can censor it, or ban the user. Moreover, they can prohibit the right to associate with others in the pursuit of social, political, economic, cultural, and religious ends. This has been carried out against Palestinians (e.g. with the removal of the page for the political party, Fatah), as well as the far-right.38 As private overlords of critical information infrastructure, US multinationals have the power to regulate the press, speech, and association in foreign territories, as they see fit. These examples demonstrate how structural domination of the tech ecosystem undermines local sovereignty through privatized forms of political, economic, and social governance. This helps the US perpetuate copyright paywalls, control information flows, spread their platform monopolies, supplant local autonomy, filter communications, and deepen dependency on the US. In turn, corporations increasingly profit from Big Data surveillance, an exploitative human rights transgression against the Global South. We discuss this element next.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.