Anti imperialism must be the center of any understanding of IR- it creates the tools needed move beyond theorization and create unifying struggles against capital
Anthony Pahnke in 2021
Associate Professor of International Relations at San Francisco State University; Regrounding Critical Theory: Lenin on Imperialism, Nationalism, and Strategy; International Studies Review, Volume 23, Issue 1, March 2021, Pages 181–203; https://academic.oup.com/isr/article/23/1/181/5850500
This article places key elements of Lenin's thought in discussion with dominant currents in Critical Theory. I argue that the latter shows signs of what I call depoliticization. This trend—in privileging norms such as neutrality and private, reclusive forms of reflection—leads theorists to wall themselves off from movements. Politics has become an area for the passive contemplating of affairs. Habermas, a principal voice in this variety of Critical Theory, advocates for dialogue as the preferred mode of social interaction. Such positions are blind to our historical moment when conflict and taking sides is the norm, on the right and the left.¶ Central pillars of Critical Theory—a concern with emancipation and the understanding that concepts must work against domination—remain relevant. Frankfurt School theorists, such as Horkheimer, is particularly instructive in this regard. Fraser's work, as well, offers a way to conceptualize Critical Theory as a project for emancipation that is rooted in connecting with social movement struggles. To further improve our understanding of how this connection can take place, turning to Lenin, as I argue, is crucial. Lenin's thought on imperialism offers a way for us to rethink the place of theory when it comes to the importance of making strategic interventions in political life, especially concerning questions pertaining to territory. In this regard, Lenin highlights the central, yet problematic necessity of working with the state, while also confronting movement divisions to build unity. In Lenin's hands, Critical Theory is a tool to mobilize people, draw distinctions with antagonists, and build movement unity. The many ways he practiced and theorized political action, including writing editorials, producing abstract intellectual works, and delivering statements for conferences, provide multiple illustrations on how to bridge social movement activity with theory.¶ Extreme inequality characterizes international political economy and life within many advanced capitalist states, as we live in what may be considered “a new gilded age.” Powerful states and corporations are connected, linked in ways that generate uneven, global chains of production, exchange, and circulation. Wars rage on in many parts of the world. Global flows have brought some of us together, while at the same time, stoked divisions within and between states. Lenin, at his time, saw similar problems and developments. As an organizer, he worked to build movements oriented around social transformation. He also saw nationalist movements, on the right and the left. While supporting the latter, he rejected the former. Furthermore, while seeing national self-determination as a potential force, Lenin also considered its limitations. His work on imperialism helped him reach this conclusion, which he used to mobilize rank-and-file movement members as well as other organizers. Lenin's relevance is here, precisely, in helping us think on how to bring people together and create unity out of fragmentation, setting the work of emancipation on a path toward creating new political, economic, and cultural relations.