Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The aff’s use of diplomacy to uphold US interests represents a classist hegemonic project- policy makers have a vested economic interest in maintaining the social and political order

De Graaff and van Apeldoorn in 2011

Naná de Graaff VU University - Amsterdam, The Netherlands Bastiaan van Apeldoorn VU University - Amsterdam, The Netherlands, Varieties of US Post-Cold War Imperialism: Anatomy of a Failed Hegemonic Project and the Future of US Geopolitics, Critical Sociology 37(4) 403–427

We argue that in understanding the variations in US imperialism we also need to examine those ‘specific conjunctures’ in which one hegemonic project may take the place of another without necessarily being linked to a concomitant change in accumulation strategy. However, we stress with Jessop that in order to be successful hegemonic projects need to advance the interests of a dominant class fraction, and thus to be articulated to a successful accumulation strategy – whether old or new. Success is not guaranteed, but seeking to advance these interests is what a hegemonic project is about. Let us now turn to the important ‘geopolitical’ dimension of any hegemonic project as formulated within the national context of a leading capitalist state such as the USA. As states are key in providing the preconditions for capitalist markets to develop and for capitalist accumulation to take place (Van Apeldoorn and Horn, 2007), any national or transnational capitalist class is dependent upon the application of state power both nationally and internationally (see e.g. Wood, 2003). Hegemonic projects, as expressive of underlying class interests, will therefore have to articulate not just a vision with regard to how to establish control over subordinate social groups in a domestic context (i.e. a national-popular programme), but also with respect to world order and the position of the respective state or states within it. It is thus that, as Van der Pijl (2007) maintains, class forms the crucial nexus between global capitalism and geopolitics: rather than viewing them as autonomous, they must be seen as internally related. This is not to imply that geopolitical strategy is in any way determined by objective class interests. On the contrary, these interests must be articulated politically and ideologically, and their possible translation into state policy must be seen as a contingent outcome of social and political struggles. Our claim is, however, that the content of these political and discursive practices is shaped by the social position of the actors engaging in it and by underlying social relations.4 It is thus that we must analyse how actors formulating geopolitical strategies are, to use Gramsci’s (1971) terminology, organically linked to certain social forces and to class interests. It is such ‘organic intellectuals’, located both within and beyond the state apparatus, that must be seen as constructing a hegemonic project – formulating and disseminating a particular strategy – as an articulation of long-term class interests. It is thus that we seek to show how geopolitical strategy is not so much, as Harvey would have it, formulated by a class of state managers with separate interests and motivations (2003: 27), but by intellectuals, policy advisors and (in the end by) state officials who are in fact closely linked to private capitalist interests. Although the capitalist class of the most powerful state may be highly integrated into certain patterns of transnational class formation, it is plausible that it has, at the same time, a clear sense of a distinct national interest. Precisely because of the fact that it sits at the top of the international and global hierarchy, it is acutely aware of the interest it has in maintaining the current system and of what it has to lose if the system breaks down. We therefore hypothesize that hegemonic projects formulated within the context of such a dominant state will tend to express a strong geopolitical consciousness, and include a rather elaborate strategy with respect to how to exercise control over other states and their societies. It is from this perspective that we will below analyse the rise and fall of the neoconservative project in terms of a hegemonic project that has been formulated and propagated within the national political arena of the USA and has subsequently been very successful in shaping US foreign policy after 9/11.5 We explain the rise of this project by situating its origins within the contradictions and limits of what we see as the hegemonic project of neoliberal globalization that unfolded in the 1990s, while arguing that the effect of these structural dynamics were crucially mediated by the concrete agency of a political vanguard tied to dominant social forces within the USA. The neoconservative project, we argue, offered an answer to a crucial question facing the US ruling class: how to prolong US global hegemony at a moment when the ‘answer’ of the neoliberal project no longer seemed that compelling any more.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.