Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Hegemony is upheld through a militaristic ideology – restricts opposition by entrenching itself as key to the economy and national security

Bernazolli and Flint ’09 (Richelle M. – University of Illinois at Urbana-Campaign; Colin- University of Illinois at Urbana-Campaign; “Power, Place, and Militarism: Toward a Comparative Geographic Analysis of Militarization”)

The Gramscian notion of hegemony, which sought to explain societal acquiescence to a capitalist system that created and maintained vast economic inequalities, held that the poor and working-class sectors of society adopt the dominant cultural group’s ‘values, norms, perceptions, beliefs, sentiments, and prejudices’ (Lears 1985, 569). Consider for a moment the role of the military in society, with its own particular values, norms, perceptions, beliefs, and practices. In order to gain and maintain support, or at least acquiescence, for a large, standing armed force and the different activities it takes on, with associated opportunity costs, those who do not necessarily have a stake in the well-being of this system must be somehow convinced that its health and viability is of critical importance to their own well-being. Society as a whole must be acculturated to adopt a particular worldview and set of cultural beliefs that will generate a certain level of acquiescence to whatever it is the military is doing at any time and in any place. In adopting a Gramscian view of hegemony, we do not wish to imply that there is necessarily a ruling military class analogous to the ruling economic class of which Gramsci spoke. Rather, we posit that hegemony – the ability to set agendas and define values and norms – has advanced militaristic goals as well as economic or class goals. Indeed, the various sets of goals are intertwined and often compliment each other. The point here is that Gramsci’s broad notion of power is of use in analyses that go beyond class in a capitalist society. For example, Flint (2006) notes that the Gramscian notion of power demonstrates how ‘geopolitical practices and ideas are disseminated and portrayed to wide audiences in order to justify them and make them appear “normal” while belittling alternative views’ (Flint 2006, 28). Cresswell (1996), in his theorizations of placediscussed above, employs Gramsci’s ideas in order to explain the role of place in constructing dominant ideologies. And Taylor (1999) adapts the Gramscian idea of hegemony from the scale of a particular society to the globe in order to explore the mechanisms by which the last three world hegemons (the Netherlands, Great Britain, and the United States) have each been able to construct and impose their own versions of ‘modernity’ on the rest of the world. Emphasizing that dominant worldviews do not take hold in a simple, top-down manner, Sharp (2000, 31) points out that hegemony, far from being constructed solely through political ideologies on the part of the elites of society, is produced and maintained ‘more immediately through detailed scripting of some of the most ordinary and mundane aspects of everyday life.’ It is this very banality that makes militarism more than merely an elite ideology, or a set of beliefs with which state institutions indoctrinate the less powerful sectors of society. This does not rule out the possibility of resistance to the dominant ideology. Just as Gramsci had to explain open revolts such as workers’ strikes and factory takeovers, the application of cultural hegemony to militarism necessitates an explanation of activities such as war protests. In actuality, maintaining hegemony does not require constant commitment from subordinates to the existing system; rather, the dominant group carefully defines the acceptable range of resistance to these processes. As Lears (1985, 569) points out, most of the time, the vast majority of people find it difficult, perhaps impossible, ‘to translate the outlook implicit in their experience into a conception of the world that will directly challenge the hegemonic culture.’ This explains why we may see protests to a particular event, such as the Iraq War, but not challenges to the overall role of the military in society (although it is the very nature of the military’s role in society that allows such wars to happen). Gramsci’s theories of common-sense power and cultural hegemony rest on his distinction between political society and civil society, a view echoed by Agnew (1987) and Kirby (1993) in their theorization of place. Political society consists of the juridical or coercive institutions, most notably the police and the military. Providing the necessary ‘direct domination’ or command, political society assures the discipline of those members of society who do not consent to the imposed order willingly. Civil society, on the other hand, consists of institutions such as schools, the media, churches, trade unions, and political parties. In contrast to political society, civil society corresponds with the actual function of ‘hegemony’; the diffusion of cultural values and norms that construct the ‘spontaneous’ consent given by the masses to the general direction imposed on social life by the dominant group (Bellamy and Schecter 1993, 118–119). The cultural hegemony of militarism, as with class-based hegemony, can be understood as the convergence of political and civil society in ‘perpetuating the existing order’ (Boggs 1976, 17). One way in which the military sector achieves ascendancy within the state is to become an essential component of the economy. Compared to the cultural or ideological side of militarization, the economic mechanisms of militarization are more tangible and readily quantified. Therefore, although defense spending is often shrouded in secrecy, researchers have been able to utilize secondary data in order to focus empirically on these economic processes, making them well documented in geography. For instance, Markusen et al. (1991, 5) provide ‘a preliminary sketch of a theory of location for the defense industries,’ which the authors note have altered the US economy in fundamental ways, contributing to the rapid development of certain regions and cities vis-à-vis others throughout the Cold War. The edited volume the Pentagon and the Cities (Kirby 1992) was compiled with an eye toward the end of the Cold War and what this geopolitical transition might mean for the many communities across the United States that had come to rely on defense spending for their economic survival. In addition, at this time, Crump (1993) looked at how the spatial distribution of Department of Defense services procurement lead to new patterns of regional development and economic inequalities (see Woodward 2004 for a comprehensive review of military economic geography).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.