Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Reframing US policies as necessary and defensive perpetuates hegemony by presupposing the necessity of militarism for a secure world

Cypher ’16 (James M. - Research Scholar at the Global Institute for Sustainable Prosperity and a Research Professor in the Doctoral Program in Development Studies (UAED), “Hegemony, military power projection and US structural economic interests in the periphery,” Third World Quarterly)

Neoliberalism is a complex, quickly metamorphosing doctrine with many objectives, including especially a largely successful campaign to de-politicise the vast ‘underlying population’.34 As a consequence of this effort, it has only been in the context of the run-up to intervention in Iraq in 2003 that the intellectual hegemony of US militarism has been questioned within the country since the last aftershocks of the Vietnam war era. Notably useful in this short moment of re-politicisation have been the contributions of Blum, which offered a popular summary of US interventions, and Kolko, who presented a sophisticated critique of the pretentions of US power projection.35 Nevertheless, as the ‘perpetual war’ era of the 21st century was consolidated in Afghanistan and Iraq, such disavowals were gradually subordinated through a new crystallisation of US ‘conventional wisdom’, which ceased to view ongoing military campaigns as events beyond the ‘ordinary’. This unnoticed transmogrification was achieved through the constant ‘reframing’ of the geopolitical policies of the US as merely ‘necessary, protective, defensive’ measures as the ‘Pentagon propaganda machine’ worked assiduously with the mass media to de-legitimate opposition to these interventions and promote a numbing, universal ‘patriotic’ discourse.36 Second, Falk emphasised the attention the power elite has given to the avoidance of US war casualties, using technologies that effectively shift the fatalities of war-fighting onto (largely) foreign non-combatants. After Vietnam great care was given to the maintenance of consent through popular disengagement from the realities of intervention. Then President Carter began the reconstruction of US military intervention capabilities with the Rapid Deployment Force. Such new capabilities allowed for lightning US intervention in Panama in 1989. In 2003 ‘Shock and Awe’ – achieved through the rapid advance of overwhelming force – were thought to be the military tactics that would bring Iraq under US dominance before the American populace had an opportunity to react to events. In this instance, as Falk emphasised, Iraqi national resistance quickly formed and a prolonged battle ensued. ‘Fast intervention’, conducted with an array of high-tech weaponry, is designed to assure relatively few US military personnel killed in action. Thus, there is a constant substitution of capital for manpower in the field of battle for many reasons, one being that US corpses quickly pierce the carefully constructed fog of intellectual hegemony deployed to ensure US citizen consent in the application of military force in distant Southern nations. Interventions, then, have been facilitated through new processes and procedures carefully constructed to create a sufficient degree of autonomy to permit the US state to ‘project power’ and intervene without broad societal resistance. Nonetheless, prolonged engagements resulting from creative forms of asymmetric national resistance regularly erode and degrade US social consent, requiring its constant reconstruction. This erosion of consent can be forestalled to a considerable degree thanks to a culturally well-entrenched allegiance to US militarism. Militarism entails both individual and societal deference to all things military – including the military definition of reality, as Mills argued: ‘military power has become an ascendant end in itself…heightening the prestige and increasing the power of the military…tends to become a basis of national policy’.37 However, US militarism has always, ultimately, been a civilian-dominated construct, although since 1945 the civil–military relationship has frequently been ‘fractious, combative and problematic’.38 Militarism is the societal belief that the use of force in international relations – as a preferred option – can achieve national objectives. Furthermore, it is the dominance of military affairs in the construction of national priorities and policies. Militarism, in the US guise, does not mean that high-ranking military cadres precipitate episodes of ‘power projection’. Rather, most frequently, this role is filled by civilians – often in the face of opposition or scepticism from the Joint Chiefs of Staff. Militarists believe in the ‘logic of violence’, although there is no logic to violence except its assurance of ‘blowback’. Militarism has its deepest roots in the south states of America, where ‘valour’ and unquestioning ‘patriotism’ have long been held up as the highest of societal values. Today US military bases are spread throughout the southern states, reflecting the abiding influence of generations of jingoistic Senators and Congressional Representatives. US militarism is embraced by an influential portion of the civilian population, regardless of geography, particularly through the institutional power of the Veterans of Foreign Wars (VFW, with 1.4 million members), the American Legion (2.4 million veteran members) and retired officer associations. Of equal importance, with the end of national military service (in 1973), a multi-generational ‘caste’ of military families formed, with the south states constituting its strongest representation.39 Thus, the ideological hegemony needed to enable near-constant military interventions since the end of the Cold War is not structurally fragile. Neither is it unassailable. Regardless of the calamitous conditions arising from US interventions – including massive civilian casualties and displacement – a vociferous portion of the populace embodies unmitigated support for US military ‘power projection’. Another portion of the population – always risking the accusation of treasonous practices – embraces a counter-hegemonic position either as pacifists and/or because of their critique of the structural political economy of US military interventions. At any moment in time a vast proportion of the apolitical US populace has no strong commitment to either the permanent militarist faction or to those who hold an a priori position of opposition. Under conditions of prolonged military engagement this structurally uncommitted and easily deceived portion of the populace slowly and quietly withdraws its consent for interminable exercises in power projection. This is normally characterised as ‘war fatigue’ the ‘Vietnam Syndrome’ or some other sweeping term adopted by mass media entities that interpret, and communicate, the results of (frequently manipulated) public opinions polls. Manufactured consent, then, can be challenged at crucial conjunctures. Nonetheless, deeper structural and inertial forces tend – time and again – to reassert the intellectually hegemonic construct of US militarism.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.