Cultural hegemony reentrenches militarism by labeling a war-culture as key to local identities
Bernazolli and Flint ’09 (Richelle M. – University of Illinois at Urbana-Campaign; Colin- University of Illinois at Urbana-Campaign; “Power, Place, and Militarism: Toward a Comparative Geographic Analysis of Militarization”)
Contemporary theories of place provide a framework within which geographers can bridge society-wide processes, such as state-building, with local actions, decisions, and experiences. In this view, places are widely conceptualized as networks of social relations, rather than simply the local-scale settings, or containers, in which social relations occur (Agnew 1996; Massey 1994). This overview of place literature will look at the key aspects of place that we will subsequently connect to processes of militarization: place as a recursive and contingent process of social construction; the role of the production and maintenance of ideology; and the contestation of dominant ideologies and identities as a component of the social construction of place. The recursiveness of place, which is central to contemporary usage of the concept, stresses that as places are socially constructed, they concurrently foment particular behaviors and attitudes, which in turn, reproduce the places. These processes vary between localities, so that the general phenomena observable at the level of ‘mass society’ are experienced uniquely from place to place (Agnew 1987). Thus, the unique and the general, the structure and the agent, are related in a network of interdependent localities (Agnew 1987). Historical contingency likewise ‘emphasizes institutional and individual practices as well as the structured features with which those practices are interwoven’ (Pred 1984, 280) and further contributes the notion that places are constructed over time. While social relations (and the places they constitute) are dynamic and even sometimes fleeting, new interactions and behaviors that appear in their place are not built on a ‘clean slate’, but instead on the remains of previous ones, inevitably shapedby what came before (Pred 1984; Massey 1994). Finally, the construction of place may often be the result of elite actions in pursuit of particular goals, as Johnston (1991) posits, but it is important to recognize that subaltern members of society also play a role – either by complying with elite agendas, or by resisting them (Pile and Keith 1997; Thrift 2000). Place, as a process, is a ‘powerful force in the ongoing hegemonic and counterhegemonic struggles,’ meaning that place reproduces the beliefs that have produced it, and this occurs in such a way that the beliefs eventually appear self-evident and commonsense (Cresswell 1996, 13; Kirby 1993). This idea provides the crucial link between place and ideology. As noted earlier, while places may manifest as areas of resistance to the state, they also play a crucial role in reproducing the geography of the state’s hegemony (Agnew 1987). In a militarized society, this ‘geography of hegemony’ would unfold in a number of ways, particularly in terms of the cultural manifestations of militarism: the adoption and visible signs of military culture and values and ensuing support for militaristic policies. Such activities give rise to a local sense of identity, or sense of place, which often – but not always – serve to perpetuate dominant ideologies and identities (Agnew 1987; Pred 1984; Williams 1977). Places may also be constructed with the aim of resisting elite identities, ideologies, and objectives (Cresswell 1996; Kirby 1993; Pile and Keith 1997). In such cases, rather than serving as the local tools of overarching structures, the social relations and attitudes comprising localities may formulate in opposition to the policies of the state (Kirby 1993). Recent empirical work on the practices of memorialization and commemoration demonstrates how places may consist of competing forces: those which seek to perpetuate dominant ideologies and identities and those which seek to contest them (Alderman and Dwyer 2004; Graham and Shirlow 2002; Johnson 2003; Schein 2006). Ideologies, both dominant and marginalized, are inscribed into the cultural landscape, making this facet of place both a reflection of the human activities and ideals that have gone into constructing it, and at the same time, constitutive of them (Mitchell 2000; Schein 1997). Questions of power, then, are critical to gaining an understanding of how place based activities produce particular landscapes (Dowler et al. 2005). The complexity of place, with its multiple facets and meanings, is important to recognize. However, Agnew’s three aspects of place may be seen as core ‘variables’ around which a research framework may be organized. Agnew (1987, 1996) identified location, which is a place’s role or function in the wider economy; locale, which represents the primary institutions organizing social relations and identity in a place; and sense of place, which refers to the sense of identity tied to a locality. A fourth dimension, connectivity, or linkages to other places and other scales, should also be considered within a place-based research framework (Massey 1994). Agnew’s aspects of place will be revisited later in this article, as we propose possible comparative research designs for the study of militarization. As discussed above, several theories of place have set the foundation for discussing the construction of places within the political processes of state formation and maintenance. One set of processes involved is militarization. But what, exactly, is militarization accomplishing? These processes, constituted in large part by the activities of people in everyday settings, work to make militarism a taken-for-granted, or ‘natural’ facet of many societies. Hence, a useful concept for conceptualizing militarism is that of cultural hegemony, which up to now has been used in research focusing on class relations within capitalist societies. Cultural hegemony, as the following section will discuss, is a term developed by Italian Marxist theorist Antonio Gramsci ca. 1930 in order to explain why the working class had internalized or adopted the capitalist values of the bourgeoisie – in effect, reproducing a system that perpetuated their meager existence. However, this term, in concert with Gramsci’s theories of power, can be readily adapted from an explanation of the adoption of capitalist values to an explanation of the adoption of militaristic values.