Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Humanitarianism reifies a monolithic humanity where privileged agencies articulate human insecurity – ambiguous conceptual boundaries allow for manipulation and violence

Watson in 2011

Department of Political Science, University of Victoria, Canada; The 'human' as referent object?: Humanitarianism as securitization, Security Dialogue, Vol. 42(1)

Yet, security is not the only discourse that may be used to legitimize the implementation of emergency measures. Turning to recent historical events, one is struck by the power of humanitarianism in legitimizing a wide range of rather extraordinary measures. The humanitarian discourse that shaped the response to the 2004 Indian Ocean tsunami resulted in unparalleled funding from both public and private sources: over US$13.5 billion was donated to disaster relief and recovery, and donors included an unprecedented total of 99 governments (Flint and Goyder, 2006; Telford and Cosgrave, 2007). Additionally, elites have used humanitarianism in varying degrees to justify military interventions in Somalia, Haiti, Bosnia, Angola, Mozambique, Kosovo, East Timor, Sierra Leone, the Democratic Republic of the Congo, Liberia, Zaire, Sudan, Côte d’Ivoire, Iraq and Afghanistan (De Waal and Omaar, 1994; Wheeler, 2004; Roth, 2004). Perhaps the pinnacle of justification for military intervention for the purposes of human protection emerged from the International Commission on Intervention and State Sovereignty’s (2001) report The Responsibility To Protect1 . The ICISS report explicitly outlines the foundations of the right to military intervention and garnered relatively widespread international support, including acceptance by the UN General Assembly (MacFarlane et al., 2004). The widespread endorsement of this report, combined with the continued use of humanitarianism to promote massive relief operations and military interventions, amply demonstrates that humanitarianism, like security, is a powerful discourse that legitimizes marshalling a vast amount of resources in the implementation of emergency measures. Humanitarianism as a justification for the use of military force is opposed by critics from all over the political and academic spectrum: from realists concerned with the use of force for reasons other than national security (traditionally understood) to critical theorists concerned with the imperialism of humanitarianism and its legitimization of violence (Slim, 2001; Ayoob, 2002; Bricmont, 2006; for overviews, see Welsh, 2004; McFarlane et al., 2004; Macrae, 1998). Yet, not all critics are completely dismissive of humanitarianism and the types of intervention it justifies. Those who still advocate for humanitarian action aim to create a concept of humanitarianism that either excludes the state and the use of force (ICRC, 2004; Rieff, 2002) or sets out clear parameters for ensuring that states employ force in a humane way and toward humanitarian outcomes (Weiss, 2001; Anderson, 1998; De Waal and Omaar, 1994). Consequently, scholars and practitioners alike have spilled much ink attempting to tie down the meaning of humanitarianism, in order to prevent its abuse at the hands of state and non-state actors. Despite these efforts, humanitarianism lacks rigid conceptual boundaries and is extendable, which facilitates ambiguous and manipulated uses (Chimni, 2000: 244). US and British elites’ justification of the invasion of Iraq in terms of humanitarianism is evidence enough of this problem. Yet, Chimni’s observation is eerily reminiscent of the critiques of the concept of security – that security is an essentially contested concept (Buzan, 1991) and that it is ambiguous and easily manipulated by elites (Wæver, 1995). Wæver (1995: 54–5) writes that security’s conceptual fluidity and discursive power encourages power-holders to use the instrument of security to gain control over an issue and use it for specific, self-serving purposes. He could just as easily have been referring to humanitarianism. In this article, I contend that the power of humanitarianism to legitimize extraordinary measures and the problem of its ambiguity and manipulability are best understood by approaching it as a form of securitization, similar in kind to societal and state security. Securitizing discourses (state, societal, humanitarian, etc.) identify a referent object that is threatened and endorse emergency measures to alleviate the threat. Approaching humanitarianism as a distinct sector of security with its own logic of threat and vulnerabilities addresses three critical gaps in securitization theory: its exclusion of non-state or societal referent objects of security (Buzan et al., 1998: 36; Hansen and Nissenbaum, 2009: 1160), its reliance on domestic and democratic forms of governance (Wilkinson, 2007; Vuori, 2008), and its problematic distinction between normal and emergency measures (Buzan et al., 1998: 25–7; Stritzel, 2007: 367; Rasmussen, 2001). Such an approach also contributes to our understanding of humanitarianism as a structured field in which certain actors hold a privileged position in the enunciation of human insecurity, in which a reified and monolithic form of humanity is declared, and that supports existing international norms pertaining to the provision of security for humans.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.