The aff’s presentation of the international liberal order as a benign good elides its role as a legitimating ideology for racial and class hierarchies within and between nations-it views western values as essential in intervening to tame racially inferior cultures
INDERJEET PARMAR in 2018
Professor of international politics and head of department of international politics at city, university of London; The US-led liberal order:¶ imperialism by another name?; International Affairs 94: 1 (2018) 151–172; doi: 10.1093/ia/iix240
Liberal internationalism is an ambiguous, multifaceted approach to understanding,¶ explaining, justifying and practising international politics. One aspect of it is as¶ a positive theory taught in academic International Relations (IR), derived from¶ liberalism as applied to international affairs, explaining how the foreign policies of¶ leading states, especially the United States and Britain, work. It is also a normative¶ world-view, used by some of its proponents to indicate what the world ought to¶ look like and how it might, and frequently does, work. Liberal internationalism,¶ therefore, is also a set of policies, institutions and established practices.13¶ As an IR theory, the key pillars of liberalism, as embodied in liberal societies,¶ are limited government, individual freedom, private property, pluralism and¶ tolerance, progress, institutions and cooperation for peace, and interdependence.¶ As a theory of US foreign policy, which is the object of analysis here, it encompasses¶ democratic values, economic interdependence, international institutions as¶ a framework for cooperation in addressing global crises and problems, and the¶ broad promotion of general welfare. Emerging historically from the era of rising¶ anti-colonialism and anti-imperialism, with the United States and Britain in the¶ lead, the US-led order laid claims to being opposed to colonial rule, and in favour¶ of national and human rights, within a system of international power undergirded¶ by rules binding hegemon and others alike. It was promoted not as a continuation¶ of empire by other means, but as a new system based on universalistic principles¶ applicable to all regardless of race, colour or history.¶ For my immediate purposes, it is unnecessary to disentangle the positive from the¶ normative, the theoretical from the practical, because this framework of thought¶ emerges both from deep principles and also as a set of solutions to international¶ problems, especially world wars. Hence, liberal internationalism is frequently¶ referred to as Wilsonianism, after the internationalist programme promulgated¶ by US President Woodrow Wilson after the First World War that included the¶ formation of the League of Nations, the forerunner of the longer-lasting post-1945¶ United Nations system.¶ I argue here that, as a theory, it operates as ideological legitimation even when¶ its proponents offer reform; it justifies the status quo. In that regard it differs little¶ overall from other theories like Marxism, for example, or realism. But because it¶ is the principal system of ideas and practices, and ideals, that are used to explain,¶ implement and defend the present international status quo, I would suggest that¶ it elides too much to be fully validated beyond the circle of its proponents. Of¶ course, it explains aspects of the world’s functioning; but its interpretation tends¶ to be benign: crises and challenges are explained as resolvable within the system’s¶ governing principles through socialization, integration and assimilation.¶ I use the term liberal internationalism, then, as an amalgam to suggest that,¶ while it is all of the above, upon reflection it serves within academia and in IR as a¶ positive theory of how things actually are—that is, as the opposite of an ideology.¶ It purports to be able to explain the world, at the same time as its adherents are¶ normative supporters of the theory. I show that it is actually ideological, because¶ it elides key factors of how the liberal world order actually works, and that other¶ theories suggest better ways of explaining the world.¶ In the next section of the article, I analyse liberal internationalist ideas and¶ claims in more depth and more critically, with a view to identifying key elements¶ of a more viable framework to explain the LIO—a critical theory influenced by¶ the work of Antonio Gramsci and to some extent synthesized with the work of¶ Karl Kautsky. The principal aim of this article is to identify the weaknesses of¶ liberal internationalism in practice with the purpose of opening space for subsequent¶ theorizing. In sum, what appears to be missing from liberal internationalism¶ is any recognition of domestic power inequalities—such as those based on¶ class and race—its broad attachment to (democratic) elitism, and its hierarchical¶ approach to other powers, especially in the global South.¶ While Wilsonian liberal internationalism is widely recognized as privileging a¶ belief in the free movement of people, capital, goods and services, less attention has¶ been given to its origins in a time when ‘international relations’ was overtly understood¶ as ‘race relations’, and its consequent implication in managing overtly racialized¶ imperial power after the First World War.14 The Wilson administration’s role¶ in racially segregating the US federal government had its foreign policy counterpart¶ in a belief in an eventual, but far distant, self-government of the colonies¶ and opposition to a Japanese proposal for a racial equality clause in the charter of¶ the fledgling League of Nations.15 The development of liberal internationalism,¶ then, was symbiotically bound to Wilson’s conviction that US intervention in¶ world affairs was essential, and to what were effectively parastatal organizations¶ created both by the federal executive and by private foundations—the Carnegie¶ Endowment for International Peace, among others. Wilsonian ‘theory’ was¶ practical, idealistic and ideological from the very beginning. It is also the case¶ that, long after overt racial discourses became politically damaging, subliminal¶ racial thinking remained—and (unconsciously) remains—a significant element of¶ liberal internationalism, affecting its analyses of the politics of domestic and global¶ demographic power shifts.16¶ Nevertheless, liberal internationalists are cosmopolitans—opposed to narrow¶ nationalism and trade protectionism, within a US-led international system. But its¶ core ideas—rule of law, superiority of the western idea (however lightly worn),¶ a rules-based institutional order open to all, in principle—are deeply embedded¶ in US political-intellectual elite think-tanks, university public policy schools,¶ corporate media and the leaderships of both main political parties,17 the core of¶ the white Anglo-Saxon Protestant establishment.18 Importantly, however, there¶ are influential voices in the emerging powers and regions that support the liberal¶ international order by calling for internal reform to take account of the changing¶ distribution of global power away from the West and towards the ‘rest’.19