The aff is corrupt through its core- it relies on a cadre of “experts” that financially gain from inflating the importance of the MIC- even a ‘state planned’ war economy ensures corruption
Thomas K. Duncan and Christopher J. Coyne in 2013
Department of Economics, George Mason University; The Origins of the Permanent War Economy¶ ; https://www.ccoyne.com/Origins_of_the_Permanent_War_Economy_-_final.pdf
By war’s end, all three interest groups—the military, organized labor, and war-related private¶ industry—had experienced the monetary and political gains offered by the dual crises of¶ depression and war. The iron triangle was complete, with the vested interests of “[b]ig business,¶ including its powerful friends and representatives…, and the newly but vastly empowered¶ military establishment together,” which “formed a potent political faction” (Higgs 2006, 73). As¶ “[u]nions could not afford endlessly to neglect their immediate self-interest,” organized labor¶ also remained “a junior partner in the postwar complex” (Koistinen 1973, 477). Despite popular¶ sentiment for a respite from the war effort, demobilization was short-lived, as American military¶ planners were already looking at the Soviet Union as the source of the next crisis with which to¶ exert their influence (Biddle 2007, 141). With only a short pause to gather its strength, the¶ military-industrial complex found itself attempting to influence policy against a potential threat¶ that would last for over four decades (see, for instance, Lazarowitz 2005). And, in the post-9/11 ¶ world, the military-industrial complex has again shifted focus to the transnational “War on¶ Terror” which has further extended and sustained the permanent war economy. Indeed, as¶ Mueller (2006) shows, an entire “terrorism industry” consisting of consultants, counter-terrorism¶ experts, and pundits has emerged in the wake of the 9/11 attacks.¶ In addition to providing insight into the origins of the permanent war economy, our¶ analysis has broader implications regarding the relationship between capitalism and foreign¶ military imperialism.19 Some critics of capitalism view foreign intervention as a logical¶ outgrowth of this type of economic system (see Oakes 1944; Vance 1951a, 1951b, 1951c, 1951d,¶ 1951e, 1951f; Baran and Sweezy 1966; Vatter 1985; Hossein-Zadeh 2006). From this¶ perspective foreign exploits provide a means for politically-connected capitalists to earn¶ significant profits. These critics are right, at least to a degree. What these critics are really¶ highlighting is a flaw in capitalism whereby investors and entrepreneurs are indifferent, at the¶ margin, between additional rents earned by seducing government and additional profits earned¶ by creating new and cheaper products which benefit the general public (see Buchanan 1980).¶ In the context of foreign military interventions, this implies that, given the chance, self interested capitalists will gladly engage in a mutually beneficial exchange with the state monopoly provider of military services. Private companies offer campaign contributions and¶ political support, and politicians and state bureaucrats offer rents in return. Although both parties¶ are privately made better off, there is a significant negative externality of allowing this exchange¶ because the permanent war economy diverts productive resources away from other uses that¶ improve general standards of living (see Duncan and Coyne, forthcoming). ¶ How is this dilemma to be resolved? One solution is to adopt a completely planned¶ economic system for military and defense production which removes capitalists from the process ¶ altogether. The flaw with this alternative, however, is that it assumes that government, absent¶ crony capitalists, will have less of an incentive to build and use weapons for imperialistic¶ purposes. The field of public choice, which demands the symmetry of assumptions between¶ private and public actors, calls this assumption into question. Further, historical evidence also¶ provides countless instances of government abuse of its monopoly on military force.