The US liberal order uses alliance institutions to manage the hierarchical class and race relations that entrench the power of elites at the expense of equality
INDERJEET PARMAR in 2018
Professor of international politics and head of department of international politics at city, university of London; The US-led liberal order:¶ imperialism by another name?; International Affairs 94: 1 (2018) 151–172; doi: 10.1093/ia/iix240
The foundational values, interests and institutions of the (Anglo-)US liberal¶ international¶ order, with due respect for important but not fundamental recalibrations¶ and corrections along the way, are the sources of its current crises or at¶ least challenges. The mentalities and power structures of the LIO’s leaders are¶ constructed by hierarchical, imperial and racial–civilizational ways of thinking,¶ albeit in most cases subliminally embedded to the point of being unconscious¶ deep structures themselves.117 The American white Anglo-Saxon Protestant¶ (Wasp) establishment built and maintained the liberal order in a ‘competitively¶ cooperative’ alliance with their British counterparts,118 whose own imperial and¶ racial mentalities were hardly in conflict with those of their American cousins.119¶ Whatever changes occurred or were forced on US elites over time, those underlying¶ and mainly subliminal values have remained significant in decision-making,¶ including when nurturing new states and powers such as South Korea and China.¶ As a result, liberal internationalism as a ‘theory’ or approach to world order,¶ eliding and skirting matters of hierarchy, race and class just as it does in its outline¶ understandings of American democracy, misses a critical part of the picture—of¶ the dynamics of international power as well as the dynamics of domestic power.¶ Because of that elision, that failure to see, I suggest it is a legitimating ideology of¶ the American ruling elite. I have argued above that the LIO is better understood as a¶ system of hierarchy and inequality, and as what Persaud calls a ‘racio-civilizational’¶ phenomenon. What does that mean? It means that this system and its leaders cannot¶ yet comprehend an order that encompasses on the basis of something approaching¶ equality the broad mass of people—citizens—at home, let alone the non-western¶ peoples of the global South, or even their elites. The tweet from Donald Tusk¶ quoted above is revealing and instructive because it was addressed to President¶ Trump in simple and stark terms, worth repeating here: ‘Euro-Atlanticism means¶ the free world cooperating to prevent post-West world order’—so, please ‘do not¶ touch’. International alliances of elites, including those of the emerging powers¶ such as China, are in large part attempts to manage and channel change to prevent¶ radical power shifts, to sustain a world order that serves elites and masses, in West¶ and East, in starkly unequal ways. A Gramscian–Kautskyian synthesis combines¶ consideration of domestic and international class-based imperial hegemonies and¶ offers a good explanation of the existing order. However, it also offers a way out, in¶ theory, and provides ways to assess the likelihood of avenues towards egalitarianism¶ being taken by ruling elites. The prognosis is not positive at present, although the¶ bases of ways forward appear to be coming into view as political strife and electoral¶ shocks challenge the status quo.120