Every aspect of militarism exacerbates environmental destruction- survival is impossible without addressing the ideological sources of destruction
Mag. Florian Polsterer in 2015
University of Luxembourg¶ European Master’s Degree in Human Rights and Democratisation¶ Academic Year 2014/2015; ¶ The Impacts of Militarism on Climate¶ Change: A sorely neglected relationship; European Inter – University Centre for Human Rights and Democratisation
It is obvious that during active combat fighter jets, destroyers, tanks and whole arsenals of¶ other weapon systems are extremely carbon-intensive165 and often discharge other highly ¶ toxic emissions, not to mention the emissions that are released by oil fires.¶ 166 This causes¶ catastrophic devastation at all levels of the biosphere167¶ . However, the active hostilities are¶ only responsible for a fraction of the actual damage to the environment.168¶ As if the relation between the natural environment and humanity was not complex enough,¶ the developments that this relationship is going through in times of crisis and conflict are¶ adding further complications in blurring the borders of war and peace. Environmental harm is¶ not confined only to combat, claims the environmental historian Tait Keller when he analyses¶ this relation and expands his focus beyond actual hostilities. He argues that the environmental¶ damage that was created by the First World War lies not so much in the destruction of actual¶ battlegrounds but rather in the change of human behaviour and drastically increased industrial¶ production. This new behaviour is essentially different in regards to consumerism and energy¶ consumption with connections to fossil fuels, deforestation, toxic waste and general¶ pollution.169 What actually destroyed our natural environment and is still active in its¶ destruction is “the spread of industrial methods and mentalities of production that hindered¶ natural processes, upset local ecological balances, and increased human exploitation the world¶ over.”170¶ In fact, the environmental (and human) sufferings created by militarism “are so far-reaching¶ that a full examination of them would produce countless volumes”.171¶ The International Peace Bureau lists a number of direct ways in which military activity affects¶ our physical environment172¶ :¶ Pollution of the air, land and water in peacetime¶ Immediate and long-term effects of armed conflict (explosions, landmines, unexploded¶ remnants, chemical weapons, burning oil wells and oil spills, etc.)¶ Land use (vast areas of land and water occupied by military bases, target ranges,¶ weapon stores, training grounds; pollution and degradation from storage,¶ deforestation, scorched earth tactics, etc.)¶ Weapons development and production (design, development, manufacturing, tests,¶ storage, transport, disposal, etc.)¶ Militarisation of outer space (rocket launches, missile systems and satellites, space¶ littering)¶ Additionally, indirect effects through the diversion of resources have to be taken into¶ account.¶ 1¶ This list is by no means exhaustive and one could find hundreds of disastrous examples, like¶ reduction of biodiversity from the extinction of 47 plant species and 19 classes of trees in the¶ Nagorno-Karabakh war174¶ , or the 91,000 litre oil spill in Micronesia from an US tanker that sunk¶ in 1944175¶ , or the 50 nuclear warheads and 11 nuclear reactors littering the ocean floor from¶ naval accidents in the Cold War176¶ , or the brain drain and waste of young lives by the military¶ sector, or the depletion of ecosystems for food and energy supply after conflicts, etcetera.¶ Literally “all aspects of military activity defile our environment in some way.”177¶ Special attention has to be paid to the huge and permanent costs of maintaining military¶ equipment and personnel, who require housing, infrastructure, heating, air conditioning,¶ transport, nourishment and many other goods and services. The production of military¶ equipment consumes enormous amounts of materials, like metal, rubber, plastics and rare¶ earths. Also there is massive energy usage involved, mostly from unsustainable resources.¶ Nuclear weapons are particular heavyweights in production and maintenance, not to speak of¶ their dismantling.178¶ When there is no actual combat, 70% of soldiers’ activities are military exercises and training,¶ consuming vast amounts of ammunition and fuel, disrupting local ecosystems or killing ¶ animals179¶ .¶ 180 Also, military material and technology is by no means faultless and accidents¶ occur regularly.¶ 181¶ Several authors regard MIMEC as the largest polluter on the planet.182 When all the facts¶ above are taken into account it seems quite possible that militarism is the biggest contributor¶ to climate change with its massive GHG emissions, destruction of ecosystems and biodiversity,¶ massive waste of energy supplies, huge impacts on social, cultural and economic behaviour,¶ destabilisation of international politics and obstruction of climate policies. Consequently, there¶ can be no successful overcoming the climate crisis without peace and dismantling MIMEC.¶ 182