Militarism causes war, suffering, and deepens inequality – only understanding militarism’s global reach will avert extinction
Gusterson and Besteman in 2019
Hugh Gusterson is Professor in the Department of Anthropology of¶ George Washington University; Catherine Besteman is Professor in¶ the Department of Anthropology of Colby College; Current Anthropology Volume 60, Supplement 19, February 2019; https://www.journals.uchicago.edu/doi/pdfplus/10.1086/700648
It goes without saying that militarism, like its close siblings¶ capitalism and colonialism, is deeply imbricated with suffering¶ and social injustice. While everyone who is not a pacifist can¶ reference armed struggles they consider for just cause (from¶ the Sandinistas for some on the left to the Afghan Mujahadeen¶ of the 1980s for some on the right), it is the very essence of¶ military operations that they kill and terrorize people—including, inevitably, innocent civilians as well as combatants.¶ Some military operations exact a higher death toll than others,¶ and some are more discriminate in picking targets than others¶ (and we should not be dismissive of the importance of these¶ distinctions), but it is the lowest common denominator of¶ military operations that they all inflict death, injury, and suffering. This suffering includes a lingering aftermath to conflict¶ that may take the form of cancer and other ailments settling¶ into a population over decades because depleted uranium¶ weapons, defoliants, heavy metals, solvents, and other toxins¶ were released in war or preparation for war; or it may take the¶ form of elevated rates of suicide, drug addiction, alcoholism,¶ and spousal abuse among mentally and spiritually injured¶ veterans. And, even when military forces are not used in war,¶ there is a high incidence of prostitution, violence against women,¶ and damage to public health and the environment around military bases (Lutz 2001; McCaffrey 2002; Vine 2015).18 Essays in¶ this volume by Lutz (2019) and Vine (2019) explore this kind of¶ damage with nuance and precision. Moreover, the ways military spending is directed tend to reinforce and deepen social¶ inequalities, enriching senior executives and stockholders of¶ large military contractors such as Lockheed Martin, Boeing,¶ BAE Systems, General Dynamics, Dyncorp, and CACI as well¶ as the penumbral swarm of retired military officers and highpriced consultants who provision them with advice, “studies,”¶ and lobbying services. It should come as no surprise that¶ macroeconomic analysis has found a clear correlation between¶ high levels of military spending and high levels of social inequality (Abell 1994; Ali 2007). Seen in this light it is surely of¶ the utmost concern that global military spending continues to¶ rise and that processes of militarization reach ever more deeply¶ into social and cultural life—from Hollywood movies to children’s toys and video game design (Allen 2017; Cheng 2013;¶ Enloe 2000a, 2000b; Gibson 1994; Jauregui 2015).¶ Much anthropological writing on militarism, imbued with¶ anthropology’s traditional preferential option for the poor and¶ marginalized, emphasizes the suffering militarism leaves in its¶ wake. However, some ethnographers have studied up or sideways (Stryker and Gonzalez 2014) to understand the perspectives of actors inside militarist organizations, and some strands¶ in the literature on the anthropology of militarism make descriptively real, for example, the aesthetic beauty soldiers and¶ weapons designers see in weapons, the threats soldiers and¶ planners fear, or the felt righteousness of the causes for which¶ warriors fight. In this volume Weiss (2019) provides a complex¶ evocation of the contradictions and ambivalent feelings experienced by Israeli soldiers rebelling against their expected role in¶ the subjugation and occupation of the Palestinian community.¶ Analyses such as Weiss’s provide a much-needed window into¶ the lived experience of militarist actors, challenging anthropologists to empathize with their dilemmas rather than just¶ condemning them. Anthropology cannot produce a complete¶ descriptive analysis of militarism without exploring the experience and cultural logics of soldiers, weapons scientists, and¶ intelligence officers—perhaps anthropology’s ultimate others—¶ as well as militarism’s victims. This raises problems of method¶ and writing. How do anthropologists study people who may not¶ want to be studied or are for other reasons inaccessible for¶ conventional fieldwork? This may involve defetishizing participant observation in favor of a mixed-method approach that¶ gives more weight to textual sources and set-piece interviews of¶ the kind journalists practice. And, when it comes to writing,¶ how do we write critically about militarist actors without leaving¶ our subjects (as well as some of our readers) feeling set up and¶ betrayed? Alternatively, how do we convey the cultural sense of¶ militarist practices and institutions without feeling complicit¶ (Gusterson 1997)?19¶ Militarism’s Global Web¶ This volume goes to print at a moment when military programs¶ continue to enjoy strong public support in the United States¶ despite the fact that militarist processes have set entire regions of¶ the planet (especially in the Middle East and the Horn of Africa)¶ ablaze. According to Brown University’s Costs of War project¶ (http://watson.brown.edu/costsofwar/) the US interventions in¶ Iraq, Afghanistan, and Pakistan have led to at least 370,000 direct deaths and 800,000 indirect deaths, have displaced over¶ 10 million people, and have so far cost US taxpayers $5.6 trillion.¶ If we then consider the conflict in Syria, that adds another¶ 350,000–500,000 deaths and, astoundingly, over 6 million more¶ refugees. And then there are the conflicts in Somalia, Yemen,¶ and Libya, which have killed and displaced many more. And,¶ while the numbers are horrifying enough, they do not begin to¶ speak to other dimensions of suffering and destruction associated with the sundering of families, the trauma of witnessing¶ relentless, organized violence for years, and the hopelessness¶ that comes from watching the collapse of social institutions.¶ From our perspective as analysts of militarism, these conflicts¶ in different countries, which tend to be reported separately in¶ the media, are coproduced by a single bundle of underlying¶ militarist processes and are integrated with one another, no¶ matter how much local dynamics may vary. Indeed, this is the¶ essence of militarism—its ability to be simultaneously local and¶ global, to connect different geographical spaces and meaning¶ systems through organized violence or the preparation for it,¶ while obscuring the workings of the connective circuitry. The¶ conflicts that appear to be “in” the Middle East, but that are¶ really global in their reach and origins, are simultaneously¶ “about” Sunni-Shi’a hostility in local Iraqi neighborhoods, the¶ rivalry between Pashtuns and Tajiks in Afghanistan, jihadists’¶ dreams of a new Caliphate, the diaspora’s fantasies of“home,” a¶ “clash of civilizations” in the heads of American neoconservatives, human rights hawks’ claims to want to protect Muslim¶ women’s rights, military planners’ search for pipeline routes¶ and geostrategic advantage, US presidents’ anxieties about reelection, and aerospace executives’ drive for increased profits.¶ Barefoot guerillas in the Hindu Kush, suicide bombers in Mosul,¶ US special forces knocking down doors in the middle of the¶ night, drone operators in Nevada, bemedaled generals in the¶ Pentagon, speakers in suits at Washington think tanks, refugees¶ clinging to flimsy boats in the Mediterranean, and assembly line¶ workers churning out ammunition for M16s may never meet¶ one another but are fundamentally joined by processes of mil¶ itarism that adhere to certain patterns: through a process of¶ polarization, they create and intensify enmities, turning neighbors against one another; they create novel alliances between¶ locals and outsiders; they inject weaponry beyond the normal¶ reach of local fighters; and they spread, through a sort of process¶ of contagion, exporting violence to and bringing weapons and¶ fighters from contiguous territories and diasporic communities.¶ Above all, following global capitalist and colonial pathways that¶ have sedimented over centuries, they tend to transmogrify the¶ bodily suffering and death of those in the periphery into wealth¶ in the metropole: jobs in munitions factories or in the everexpanding US Department of Defense, profits for shareholders¶ in arms manufacturers, book contracts for defense intellectuals,¶ and roles for actors in Hollywood war movies. This is not to say¶ that no one in the metropole suffers and dies, but militarism is a¶ global system that is tilted in favor of the West, which profits¶ from suffering beyond its borders.¶ A number of commentators observed that, after World¶ War II, Western societies failed to demobilize as they had after¶ World War I, and that the world was increasingly in a permanent war orientation: military research and development¶ continued; the arms industry remained a leading sector in the¶ economy; nuclear weapons were placed on hair-trigger alert,¶ and the horizon was constantly scanned for incoming missiles;¶ the United States built a global network of hundreds of military¶ bases, while both superpowers used military aid to build global¶ patron-client networks; the United States and the Soviet Union¶ used their military and intelligence forces to intervene in other¶ countries’ affairs; and conflicts, invariably worsened by superpower sponsorship of contending factions, regularly erupted in¶ the global south. Far from ameliorating this situation, the end of¶ the cold war has, in the context of a struggle for resource access¶ in the global south and the emergence of the so-called war on¶ terror, produced a further intensification of militarism, which¶ has morphed opportunistically as it has adapted to new economic, ideological, and strategic realities. If, instead of focusing¶ on particular conflicts, we try to hold in awareness the system of¶ global militarism in its entirety, we see a system that generates¶ expansionary energy from its own internal conflicts: as actors¶ within the system argue that threats from elsewhere within the¶ system justify the accumulation of weaponry, the use of force, or¶ the further securitization of daily life, the system deepens its grip¶ upon us To make this case is to recapitulate an argument made by the¶ great social historian E. P. Thompson (1980) in a much debated¶ essay on “exterminism, the last stage of civilization.” Analyzing¶ the cold war nuclear arms race, Thompson argued that Western¶ and Eastern bloc critiques of the other bloc seemed, in their own¶ context, progressive, but, seen from outside the entire conflict,¶ merely served to consolidate and expand the underlying system,¶ which he dubbed “exterminism.” He reframed democratic capitalism and communism not as contending systems but as complementary components of this exterminist system. Looking¶ forward, he feared that this system could only be ended in a¶ self-destructive genocidal spasm as its own contradictions became inescapable. The question before us now is whether exterminist militarism might be ended otherwise, slowly rolled¶ back (as slavery and colonialism were) through the combined¶ efforts of intellectuals, institutions, and social movements.¶ Until we recognize militarism for what it is, we cannot begin to¶ roll it back.