Our alt’s theory of language allows an understanding of the relationship between discourse and socioeconomic structures.
Joscha Wullwebera in 2015
a Political Science Department, University of Kassell, Kassel,¶ Germany, Global politics and empty signifiers:¶ the political construction of high¶ technology, Critical Policy Studies, 9:1, 78-96, DOI:¶ 10.1080/19460171.2014.918899
Some words, phrases or slogans have their own set of dynamics and special importance¶ within international politics. They convey a global problem or threat such, as the¶ Cold War, the war on terror, or global warming and climate change. They label political¶ developments such as perestroika, the alterglobalization movement or the Arab Spring.¶ They articulate desired political and social developments and visions such as sustainable¶ development, social security, global justice and world peace. Some phrases accompany¶ and propel social change, including examples such as Liberty, Equality, and Fraternity¶ during the French Revolution, Bread, Peace and Land in the Russian Revolution, or We¶ are the 99 percent, the slogan of the Occupy movement (Laclau 2005, p. 97). Other terms¶ designate political programs, such as social market economy, neo-liberalism, green¶ economy, socialism and, of course, democracy.¶ Drawing on theorists such as Foucault, Derrida or Butler, many scholars in the field of¶ international relations (IR) theory have pointed out the importance of discourse for reality¶ construction (George 1994, Edkins 1999, de Goede 2006). Such approaches emphasize the¶ production of reality byway of articulatory practices while underlining the connection between¶ language, knowledge and power. Studies based on a Foucauldian genealogy (Foucault 1976,¶ 1979, 1985) or Derrida’s method of deconstruction (Derrida 1976, 1978, Cornell and¶ Rosenfeld 1992), for example, point to power relations that shape social reality. In this respect,¶ post-structural studies in IR are concerned with the construction of political identities.¶ Given the centrality of specific terms in global politics, it is surprising that the theory¶ of empty signifier proposed by Ernesto Laclau (1996a, 2005) has not been taken up¶ widely and systematically within IR theory. In fact, only very few studies at all draw on¶ the discourse theory of Ernesto Laclau and Chantal Mouffe (Laclau and Mouffe 1985, see¶ Daly 2004, Howarth and Torfing 2005, Wæver 2005, Hansen 2006). And of those that do,¶ even fewer make reference to the concept of the empty signifier (Neumann 1999,¶ Methmann 2010, Herschinger 2012). Although a number of such contributions have¶ successfully addressed a variety of political issues, none have systematically explored¶ the concept of the empty signifier or its analytical possibilities for global policy studies. I¶ argue that engaging with this concept provides fruitful insights for IR and critical policy¶ studies by opening up new dimensions for analysis. First, it accounts for the political¶ dimension of the centrality of certain terms; second, it highlights the very process of¶ constructing these terms and third, it foregrounds the political struggles which seek to¶ launch certain terms and define their content. More precisely, an empty signifier can give¶ meaning and hence identity to a policy field, a political process or a socioeconomic¶ program while at the same time being shaped by ongoing politics. The concept makes it¶ possible to explain, on the one hand, how some words or phrases take on political¶ importance, and, on the other hand, how ongoing political struggles seek to establish¶ the definition of certain terms, giving them a specific relevance for social processes.¶ Political identity construction is conceptualized with political strategies and dynamics,¶ which make the concept of the empty signifier interesting for gaining a better understanding¶ of different issues associated with global politics. The concept emphasizes the¶ importance of considering references to general public interest in global politics and the¶ way in which such interest is constructed. It strengthens the possibility of examining¶ political strategies in the process of developing policy programs.1 It also provides a foil¶ for scrutinizing the interplay between universal and particular interests.