Our alternative is a prior question to any policy making- we must examine hegemonic struggles over empty signifiers to understand the relationship between social groups and power
Joscha Wullwebera in 2015
a Political Science Department, University of Kassell, Kassel,¶ Germany, Global politics and empty signifiers:¶ the political construction of high¶ technology, Critical Policy Studies, 9:1, 78-96, DOI:¶ 10.1080/19460171.2014.918899
The conceptualization of the general interest as an empty space opens up an analytical¶ perspective that sheds light on the different political struggles to occupy that space. In this¶ respect, the concept of the empty signifier and its use for political analysis is not just about¶ the power of certain political terms. More fundamentally, it is about the construction of¶ political identities. The concept of the empty signifier, then, enables a refined operationalization¶ and, hence, analysis of the way certain political identities are constructed. Its¶ very starting point is the assumption that naming is a hegemonic operation and identity¶ construction, a political process. Based on this assumption, and as shown in the foregoing¶ analysis, the political processes that (seek to) launch or convey certain empty signifiers¶ and the political ‘selection processes’ are of interest for policy analysis. Once a universal¶ political term becomes hegemonic, struggles arise around this empty signifier: Who will¶ be able to fill the empty signifier with what kind of meanings; by which means it is¶ possible to broaden the chain of equivalence that points to this empty signifier? ‘To¶ hegemonize something is exactly to carry out this filling function’ (Laclau 1996a, p. 44).¶ Based on the assumption that it is only the exclusion that enables a stable identity, it¶ becomes analytically interesting to scrutinize the politics of exclusion. This raises the¶ question: Which meanings are excluded from that chain of equivalence?¶ As stated above, a privileged and positive relation of the empty signifier vis-à-vis the¶ (hegemonic) common good must be present. This implies that the empty signifier has to¶ have a positive connotation within the discourse formation in question (Torfing 1999, p.¶ 152). As has been shown, this is by no means self-evident, as an empty signifier can also¶ become the expression of deficiency and evil. In fact, the same empty signifier can¶ represent the common good for one discourse community and simultaneously constitute¶ the incarnation of evil for another (as in the case, e.g., of socialism and capitalism). It is a¶ task for the protagonists of a certain empty signifier to strengthen the relation to the¶ hegemonic common good within the discourse of interest. At the same time, alternatives¶ to the hegemonic project have to be presented as inconceivable and impracticable. Hence,¶ for an empty signifier to become established, it has to have strong repercussions within¶ the respective global discourse formation. Accordingly, it is imperative for empirical¶ purposes to analyze and assess the global political context.¶ Obviously, this is not just a struggle over words. On the contrary, these political terms¶ convey meaning, they structure the political arena and national policies; they privilege¶ some meanings, interests and practices over others, thereby excluding other political¶ alternatives. It is the claim of this contribution that empty signifiers matter for global¶ politics. Even more, empty signifiers are the very basis of and for (global) politics. They¶ give orientation, structure the horizon of truth and guide political practices.¶ Meaning, identity and social practices are in a permanent state of flux: ‘As society¶ changes over time this process of identification will be always precarious and reversible’¶ (Laclau 1996a, p. 46). While we can reflect on a ‘snap-shot’ of ongoing global politics¶ and analyze such a ‘frozen picture’ of political relations and practices, these practices¶ continuously change over time. In this way, objectivity becomes social objectivity whose¶ truth is in a state of permanent negotiation. More generally stated, the very existence of a¶ gap between particular meaning and universal meaning, and between particular interests¶ and universal interests makes it not only possible but also necessary for political struggles¶ to fill that gap. This is an essential condition for vibrant democracy.