The judge has agency to prevent depoliticization- it’s an iterative process between speaker and audience- voting neg prevents the depoliticizing frame from succeeding
Matt Wood and Matthew Flinders in 2014
University of Sheffield, UK; Rethinking depoliticisation: beyond the governmental; Policy & Politics • vol 42 • no 2 • 151-70;
But – to continue a by now familiar pattern – if a focus on technical, managerial and scientific discourses provides a relevant but not particularly original set of insights, then a focus on security, risk and resilience arguably provides a more imaginative and contemporary perspective. Put simply, securitisation theory has in recent years identified a distinct pattern of depoliticisation that tends to involve the identification of an existential threat that requires emergency executive powers, and, if the audience accepts the securitising move, the issue is depoliticised and is considered a ‘security’ issue outside the rules of normal politics (Balzacq, 2005; Salter, 2008; 2011; Salter and Piche, 2011). As such, security studies often regard the politicisation of an issue as representing a form of ‘desecuritisation’ (Kinnvall and Nesbitt-Larking, 2010; Salter and Piche, 2011). This discursive process may be called ‘securitisation’ in the sense that it makes issues ‘more firmly constrained… decisions about them are taken in technical terms’ (Edkins, 1999, 11). Such an interpretation goes against the influential view of Buzan et al (1998, 120) that securitisation represents a form of hyper-politicisation, due to the manner in which it creates heightened public attention around a social issue (compare Salter, 2011, 120; Buofino, 2004). The theory of moral panics and the concept of a ‘folk devil’, however, provide a way of reconciling these positions. In essence, the creation of an intense political controversy (that is, hyper-politicisation) is little more than a tool through which to then impose a definitive position that closes down political debate (thereby depoliticising the issue). It is in exactly this vein that scholars have examined the ‘war on terror’ (De Goede, 2008a; 2008b; Balzacq, 2008; Salter, 2011), illegal immigration (Huysmans, 2000; 2006), financial security (De Goede, 2004), fear of crime (Parnaby, 2006), as well as climate change and resource depletion (Carvalho and Burgess, 2005; Trombetta, 2008; Corry, 2012). Possibly the most novel insights delivered by this perspective are the manner in which discursive depoliticisation must engage with different types of audience that each require a specific language type (generally identified as popular, elite, technocratic and scientific), and how the process of securitisation through which an issue is depoliticised is rarely passive or static, but is generally an iterative process between speaker and audience. This, in turn, brings us back to wider issues concerning depoliticisation, governance and the state which in themselves encourage us to engage with Mary Douglas’ (1999) work on the depoliticisation of risk, Ulrich Beck’s (2001) analysis of ‘new’ risks, Frank Furedi’s (2005) writing on the ‘politics of fear’, or even some comment on the link between politicisation and depoliticisation in the context of Bauman’s (2001) ‘liquid modernity’. But for now these temptations must be denied in favour of a more focused account of why this paper’s attempt to ‘rethink depoliticisation’ actually matters.