Epistemology is prerequisite to any of their scenarios- all of their impacts rely on specific beliefs about violence that naturalize military power
Tyner and Henkin in 2015
James A Tyner and Samuel Henkin, Kent State University, Kent, OH, USA; ¶ War and Terrorism, Geography of; International Encyclopedia of the Social & Behavioral Sciences (Second Edition), 2015
Geography as an academic discipline has a long history of¶ peace-related research. Two early efforts include The Geography¶ of War and Peace (Pepper and Jenkins, 1985) and The Quest for¶ Peace: Transcending Collective Violence and War Among Societies,¶ Cultures and States (Vayrynen et al., 1987). In part, the¶ promotion of more peaceful geographers was in response to¶ the specter of nuclear annihilation. More recently,¶ geographers have critiqued not only the naturalness and¶ necessity of war (Kobayashi, 2009; Loyd, 2009a,b, 2011,¶ 2012; Gregory, 2010; Koopman, 2010, 2011; Ross, 2011;¶ Williams and McConnell, 2011), but have also promoted¶ a more normative vision of geography as an academic¶ discipline (Megoran, 2008, 2010, 2011; Inwood and Tyner,¶ 2011).¶ Such efforts have not been easy. As Williams and¶ McConnell (2011: 927) highlight, “our understanding of¶ what peace looks like, and how to research it, remains underdeveloped and analysis of its complexities and contradictions¶ problematically lacking.” Indeed, considerable discussion has¶ centered around the politics and contestation over the¶ ‘meaning’ and ‘definition’ of peace; this work has been¶ spurred, partially, out of a recognition of the false¶ dichotomy between ‘war’ and ‘peace’ as well as ‘violence’¶ and ‘nonviolence.’ Drawing inspiration from Galtung’s¶ (1969) influential separation of ‘direct’ and ‘structural’¶ violence, many geographers have destabilized the¶ epistemological foundations of a range of artificial, socially¶ constructed binaries, including but not limited to war,¶ peace, violence, nonviolence, conflict, and postconflict¶ (Kirsch and Flint, 2011; Ross, 2011; Loyd, 2012). Flint¶ (2011: 31) accordingly calls for an approach that views the¶ spaces of ‘peace’ and ‘war’ as intertwined; he suggests that¶ social relations are basis of construction of both and¶ concludes that instead of discrete categories, it is more¶ productive to think of a continuum of social settings in¶ which power relations and political differences always exist,¶ but in varying degrees of consensus and nonviolence¶ compared to disagreement and violence. Much of this work¶ has, subsequently, drawn attention to the ways in which¶ such false dichotomies fetishize the unremitting processes of¶ the ‘production of violence’ under the current mode of¶ global militarization (Farish and Vitale, 2011).¶ For Williams and McConnell (2011: 929; see also Loyd,¶ 2012), it is necessary to understand peace as a social and¶ spatial process, such as “shifts attention towards issues of power¶ and politics and opens up questions on contingency, agency and¶ embodiment .. Subsequently, the spectrum of violence and¶ non-violence is exposed for investigation and peace revealed to¶ be a highly differentiated landscape.” By extension, Springer¶ (2011, 2012) has challenged geographers to consider¶ ‘violence’ also as a process. For Springer (2012: 138) “to treat¶ the material expression of violence only through its directly¶ observable manifestation is a reductionist appraisal” and¶ “ignores the complexity of the infinite entanglements of social¶ relations.” It is more appropriate, therefore, to conceive of¶ violence not as ‘thing’ or ‘event’ or even ‘act’ but rather as¶ a process; violence as moment implies momentum. In other¶ words, the imposition of political-economic structures¶ designed to ‘make life’ are carried forward with a momentum¶ far beyond the initial act. Violence conceived as such therefore¶ redirects attention toward those actions and relations that are¶ hidden from empirical observation.¶ Those scholars working in the areas of peace have enlarged¶ the discussion to address other forms of conflict (and terrorism)¶ that have traditionally been neglected in the geographic study of¶ war and terror. Both feminist and critical geographers, in¶ particular, have highlighted the violence directed toward¶ (especially) women’s bodies – as manifest, for example, in the¶ geographies of intimate partner violence and rape (Katz, 2007;¶ Fluri, 2009; Tyner, 2012). This research has, by extension,¶ documented how the violence of sexism, racism, classism,¶ genderism, ableism, ageism, homophobia, and xenophobia –¶ to name but a few – continue to be legitimized through the¶ production of militarized and normalized geographical¶ imaginations. As Loyd (2009a: 865–866) concludes, “to¶ understand who is made most vulnerable where and how¶ socially produced harms are naturalized discursively and¶ materially, it is necessary to theorize specific economic,¶ political, and social relations of oppression and domination¶ and how they articulate (or intersect) in particular historical,¶ geographic moments.”