The lenses with which we view war and peace influence the policy options we consider
Cady 10 (Duane L., prof of phil @ hamline university, From Warism to Pacifism: A Moral Continuum, pp. 115-117)
The very notion of restraint in war— common to all positions along the full continuum in varying degrees— puts the burden of proof on going to war and on how the fighting is done. These are the activities in need of justification. The moral presumption should be to peace, positive peace, rather than the pervasive presumption of warism and negative peace. Recognizing the grip that warism has on dominant culture may be the most formidable task of genuine peacemaking for the fore- seeable future because it is warism that blocks evolution toward more pacifistic societies. Only occasionally will individuals back into the most absolute form of pacifism; the cultural predisposition to warism confines most of us to a narrow range of options toward the war- realist end of the scale. This brings us full circle and we end this consideration of a moral continuum on the morality of war and peace where we began, confronting warism. The normative lenses of warism, the spectacles through which we in modern culture tend to see and interpret all that happens, turn out to be as much like blinders as lenses because they restrict our vision to a narrow range of options. Nietzsche said that if the only tool you have is a hammer, everything begins to look like a nail. Under such conditions it is pretty hard to resist hammering. Analogously, if the only vision we have is warist and the only tools we build are weapons, then every conflict invites military intervention and it is hard to resist war- ring. Unless we envision a wider value perspective than the warist, we will not see the nonviolent options before us. But to see more widely we need to acknowledge and remove the blinders. Peace education is a small, struggling, but growing segment of contemporary education. The dominant presumption of warism has made it difficult for those committed to peace education to develop and establish it as a legitimate discipline devoid of the image of mere anti- militarist propaganda. Some scholars call themselves peace educators while many within the traditional disciplines are reluctant to be so labeled; they may be sympathetic with genuine peace research and teaching but afraid of the stigma that goes with the label. Those scholars interested in applying their professional training and skills to peace issues face a monumental task. Education at all levels must address warism, just as they have had to address racism, sexism, ageism, classism, homophobia, and other forms of domination.4 There is increasing academic interest in what scholars call “institutional violence”— social structures like racism, sexism, and poverty that involve constraints that injure and violate; systems that have entrapping, coercive effects. Institutional forms of violence tend to be more covert than overt; nonetheless pacifists— peacemakers—of various sorts tend to work toward the recognition and abolition of these forms of oppression as the natural manifestation of their commitment to positive peace. Such work involves recovery of lost or neglected history, consideration of a full range of options beyond traditional social constraints holding the forms of domination in place, and serious, systematic, and legitimized study of conditions constituting positive peace. Preparing for war in an effort to prevent war and preserve the status quo must be distinguished from preparing for genuine positive peace in an effort to en- courage cooperation and preclude a resort to war. Unless such issues are entertained routinely across all educational levels— including the recognition of how the various forms of domination are entangled in and reinforced by warism— the presumption of warism will continue to drive us toward war realism and prevent progress toward an evolving positive peace.5 Easing the grip of warism may be unlikely, but then racial integration in public schools, abolition of slavery, women voting and holding public office, the end of apartheid in South Africa and the Iron Curtain in Europe, the election of an African American as U.S. president, all were exceedingly unlikely not long before they became realities. People imagine, work for, and sacrifice for important goals even if they never are achieved. To the wonder of us all, unlikely goals are sometimes reached. Martin Luther King, Jr., believed that “the arc of history bends toward justice.” He knew th
at racial segregation would end . . . some- day . . . so he called on Americans to “plan for the inevitable.”6 Similarly, pacifists envision a broad cultural evolution from warism toward (and eventually, to) pacifism, so pacifists ask us to prepare for the inevitable by recognizing and backing away from warism and by working to create and sustain the conditions of genuine positive peace. While education is crucial, peace educators cannot bear the burden of the wider cultural failure to see beyond warism. Scholars and teachers in traditional disciplines must address the relevant warist/pacifist issues of their fields just as feminist scholarship has been undertaken by academics in all fields, and just as racist claims have been tested and dispelled by research in all disciplines. Anti-warism work and positive peace making cannot be ghettoized in token departments and journals and dismissed for pushing an agenda; they must be undertaken across every curriculum, not marginalized but central, if we are to assist in preparing for the inevitable. It is remarkable how low peace research is among government and foundation priorities. The moral continuum here may prove useful in eroding warist obstacles to taking peace positively if only because it recognizes gradual variations among views within a single moral tradition rather than encouraging polarized views. Peace research and study need not lead to any conversion experiences; it would be surprising were they to do so, despite popular fears.
Ext Cady- it’s a net benefit to our fw