Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Their policy only framework is a link- it papers over key questions about the nature and structure of society- these are the backdrops that shape the very terrain of what ‘policy’ is

Matt Wood and Matthew Flinders in 2014

University of Sheffield, UK; Rethinking depoliticisation: beyond the governmental; Policy & Politics • vol 42 • no 2 • 151-70;

At first glance, our third face appears remarkably similar to societal depoliticisation, in the sense that it can be initiated both from within and outside the state, it primarily relates to debate and deliberation, and it focuses on the tools through which debates concerning political choice and contingency are closed down. The point of departure, however, lies in discursive depoliticisation’s focus, not on institutions, arenas or actors but on ideas and language. It therefore offers a decentred approach that cuts across conventional boundaries (that is, public/ private) and instead recognises the manner in which any speech act which seeks to form ‘necessities, permanence, immobility, closure and fatalism… concealing, negating or removing contingency’, is itself a powerful tool of depoliticisation (Jenkins 2011, 160). As such, depoliticisation occurs when the debate surrounding an issue becomes technocratic, managerial, or disciplined towards a single goal, and hence changed in content. (A process of discursive politicisation would therefore involve the promotion of a topic as a public issue where competing interpretations exist as choices.) The promotion of an issue, but alongside a single interpretation and the denial of choice would, therefore, create a form of depoliticisation from this discursive perspective. Moral panics, for example, serve to politicise certain issues in an explosive manner, while at the same time tending to depoliticise those issues by focusing attention on specific ‘folk devils’, alongside a grossly simplified narrative that posits a simple solution (constrain, reject, kill the folk devil) to a complex problem. The demonisation of social groups therefore adds a new twist to our understanding of depoliticisation, in the sense that a dominant sociology of knowledge rapidly emerges that tends to create an intense social reaction, while also succeeding in closing down debate and deliberation (see Cohen, 2002). At the centre of this third ‘face’ is therefore what might be termed a ‘Gramscian’ intellectual perspective, with an emphasis on radical thinking and the role of language and culture in relation to political debates. Analyses of the discursive ‘face’ of depoliticisation developed from radical theoretical literature during the post-Cold War period, which highlighted how the dominant ‘anti-political’ culture transcended certain political divisions, thereby creating the illusion of ‘consensus’. Scholars, such as Pierre Bourdieu (2003), Slavoj Žižek (2002), and more recently Chantal Mouffe (2005), argued in favour of new forms of radical democratic action that exposed the existence of antagonism and ‘difference’. Jacques Rancière (1995, 5) sums up the attitude of this literature to the post-Cold War world, arguing that politics ends ‘as a secret voyage to the isles of utopia’ to become ‘the art of steering the ship and embracing the waves, in a natural, peaceful movement of growth’. In other words, grand ideological clashes give way to technocracy and acceptance of neoliberal discourse. The value of identifying the existence of discursive depoliticisation is therefore simply the manner in which it exposes the power and capacity of certain political actors to promote ‘the politics of denial’ but, more importantly, the manner in which it seeks to re-politicise certain issues. Put slightly differently, the scholars who work within this approach tend to be critical social and political theorists who seek to challenge hegemonic interpretations of the ‘end of history’ and seek to promote the existence of antagonism, conflict, difference and choice (see for example Mouffe, 2005). ‘Politics’ from this perspective is therefore distinct from ‘the political’, as Žižek (2002, 193) explains: The difference [is] between ‘politics’ as a separate social complex, a positively determined sub-system of social relations… and ‘the political’ [le politique] as the moment of openness, of undecidability, when the very structuring of society, the fundamental form of the social pact, is called into question – in short, the moment of global crisis overcome by the act of founding a ‘new harmony. ‘Politicisation’, in this sense, is a radical act of recognising ‘the political’; the possibility that society can be constituted differently; it is the opposite of fatalism and denial. Discursive perspectives on depoliticisation therefore resonate with Bauman’s In search of politics (1999), in the sense that they are concerned with how language and a careful approach to the ‘framing’ of issues can serve to close down certain options by making any opposition appear almost ‘irrational’. This is an approach that has some traction in the governance literature, informing Rogers’ (2009a, 2009b) analysis of British economic policy making in the mid-1970s, Kerr et al’s (2011) study of David Cameron’s approach to statecraft ,and Flinders and Buller’s (2006) emphasis on discursive ‘preference shaping’ (the weakness of these studies being their exclusive focus on the discourse of politicians). Discursive depoliticisation therefore brings with it a powerful set of methods, theories and insights that reflect an intellectual history, including Habermas’ (1996) analysis of ‘scientism’ and its capacity to depoliticise both language and decision making, not to mention Foucault’s (Burchell et al, 1991) analysis of the depoliticising capacity of neoliberal ‘governmentality’ (see also Dean, 1999; Lemke, 2001). These meta-theoretical positions have come to inform governance studies in several ways. The ‘interpretive turn’ in political science has, for example, emphasised the role of beliefs and traditions, as well as dilemmas and competing narratives, and how these can politicise certain issues while depoliticising others (for example, Bevir and Rhodes, 2010). Within International Relations, by contrast, constructivist approaches have been deployed to expose the depoliticising power of discourse and language around global governance and international institutions, as illustrated in the work of Widmaier et al (2007) and Schmidt (2010).

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.