The aff’s attempt to reclaim security through the perm compartmentalizes understandings of militarism to believe progress is possible
James Eastwood in 2018
Queen Mary, University of London, UK, Rethinking militarism as ideology:¶ The critique of violence after¶ Security, Security Dialogue¶ 1–¶ 13¶ © The Author(s) 2018¶ Reprints and permissions:¶ sagepub.co.uk/journalsPermissions.nav¶ DOI: 10.1177/0967010617730949
The range of critical security studies literatures calling for desecuritization therefore do not yet¶ offer a full account of militarism as I have elaborated it above, in which organized political violence¶ is made desirable through ideology and thereby loses strategic impetus and restraint. This is¶ important because it has also shaped the response of those seeking to reclaim security against these¶ critiques. Revealingly, these responses tend either to reject the call for desecuritization as too pacifist¶ or to develop safeguards against the specific effects that these critics identify with ‘militarization’,¶ rather than engaging with the underlying ideological nature of militarism. While this has¶ certainly left their analysis wanting, and reveals an equally unsatisfactory conceptualization of¶ militarism, it also shows the limitations and vulnerability of critical security studies arguments¶ calling for desecuritization.¶ For example, Booth argues that security should only ever be the ‘means’ for the ‘end’ of emancipation¶ (Booth, 2007: 114–115) and that means and ends should be related ‘non-dualistically’ (i.e. the¶ means should be consistent with the ends sought; see Booth, 2007: 428–441). He explicitly includes¶ political violence as a means that must be subject to this rule (Booth, 2007: 429–431), and he even¶ embraces aspects of Gandhian nonviolence (Booth, 2007: 115). Discussing the critique offered by¶ securitization theory, he responds, ‘we would all presumably agree that the unnecessary securitisation¶ (militarisation) of issues is to be deplored, but there are occasions when introducing a military¶ dimension is sensible’ (Booth, 2007: 168). Booth’s ethical criteria for the use of force therefore give¶ him the confidence to respond that not all militarization is a bad thing, and that it can be used for¶ progressive ends. What is notable here is that Booth also invokes a thin notion of ‘militarization’,¶ more or less reducible to the decision to use force, to establish his claim. He is quite comfortable¶ with the risks of militarization identified by securitization theory because he believes he has circumvented¶ them. By contrast, the critique of militarism as ideology gives us more powerful tools to disagree¶ with Booth here. For Booth ignores the danger that, in conditions of militarism, war can begin¶ to serve a wide array of non-strategic instrumentalities as a result of its ideological penetration of¶ social relations. Militarism can entrench a pattern of conflict by binding social relations, subjectivities¶ and identities to the pursuit of war, thereby making war far less amenable to ethico-political¶ discipline than he imagines. By setting up emancipation as an imperative that must be ‘secured’,¶ including militarily, Booth opens a dangerous pathway to the entrenchment of violence.