Reject the perm’s imperfect progressivism – the claim that legal solutions are compatible with the alt only religitimizes militarism by obscuring moral responsibility and other broader systemic violence.
Stavrianakis 16 [Anna Stavrianakis, Senior Lecturer in International Relations at University of Sussex, MScEcon in Security Studies from University of Wales, Aberystwyth and PhD in Politics from University of Bristol, author of Taking Aim at the Arms Trade, “Legitimizing liberal militarism: politics, law and war in the Arms Trade Treaty”. Third World Quarterly, 37 (5), pp. 840-865, 2016, http://sro.sussex.ac.uk/id/eprint/57545/1/TWQ%20Legitimizing%20liberal%20militarism%20-%20accepted%20clean%20version.pdf] ***Note: the ATT is the Arms Trade Treaty, a previous attempt at restricting arms sales led by the US and the UK
The analysis of the ATT advanced here suggests instead, however, that it is precisely the turn to law, the supposed compatibility between military preponderance and human rights protection, and the failure to move beyond direct use of weapons, that helps legitimise (particular forms of) war. Critical legal studies scholars advocate “a form of law-politics to develop humanitarian principles into a concrete, normative agenda:” 154 and yet this is exactly what humanitarian disarmers have been trying to do with the ATT and previous arms transfer control regimes. It is important to recognize “that some degree of complicity in previous social structures is inherent in social change.” 155 Price argues that scholars should not underplay the morally progressive significance of “practices that at once contain elements of progressive change … yet at the same time are predicated on or produce the conditions of possibility for other forms of exclusion, hierarchy, inequality, repression or violence.” 156 However, the widespread emphasis on the progressive, if imperfect character of the ATT in scholarship and policy, has failed to interrogate the justificatory claims around moral responsibility that so pervaded its negotiation. These claims contribute to obscuring a significant scale of human rights violations and the wider systems of war preparation that arms transfers are a part of. Further, such claims are part of what sceptical southern states are responding to and resisting, thus making wider normative change more difficult. The ATT negotiation process shored up liberal states’ actions whilst invoking their benevolence and assuming them to be distinct from illicit or irresponsible actors. The supposed effectiveness of normative change is muted by the existence of regimes that claim already to exceed the standards of the ATT. This may not be the ideological glorification of war that we tend to equate with the concept of militarism, but the ATT signals the contemporary mobilisation of legitimacy for liberal war-making and war-preparation nonetheless.