Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

The perm is best --- the alt fails alone but combining strategies provides meaningful routes for change

Paris, 10 – (Roland, Associate Professor, Graduate School of Public and International Affairs, University of Ottawa, “Saving Liberal Peacebuilding,” February 17, 2010, http://aix1.uottawa.ca/~rparis/Saving_Liberal_Peacebuilding_FINAL.pdf) // kt **modified for ableist language

If there is no realistic or preferable alternative to broadly liberal approaches, what can be done in the face of the current “crisis” of liberal peacebuilding? The first step is to question the extent to which this crisis is real or imagined. In this article, I have attempted to show that some of the most sweeping critiques of liberal peacebuilding have rested on dubious claims and logic, including the conflation of post-conquest and post-settlement peacebuilding; unnuanced analogies of peacebuilding and colonialism or imperialism; definitions of the liberal peace that are too broad; mischaracterizations of the peacebuilding record; and oversimplifications of the moral complexity of peacebuilding. Considered in this light, the purported crisis of liberal peacebuilding appears to be less severe and less fundamental than some have claimed. The challenge today is not to replace or move “beyond” liberal peacebuilding, but to reform existing approaches within a broadly liberal framework. This enterprise has both conceptual and policy elements. Peacebuilding remains ripe for theoretical treatments that shed light on the meaning and effects of these operations. In other words, the peacebuilding literature need not, and should not, be limited to narrowly policy-oriented or “problem solving” analyses. In the 1990s, most of the peacebuilding literature was preoccupied with practical policy issues and paid little attention to the relationships between peacebuilding and larger phenomena in international politics. The rise of more critical analysis since then has been part of a welcome broadening of the field, which now places greater emphasis on exploring the theoretical underpinnings and implications of these missions. The great strength of critical approaches has always been their focus on exposing and dissecting widely held assumptions and orthodoxies. But critical scholarship can lose its intellectual and empirical moorings if it fails to be self-reflective and self-critical – that is, if its logic, evidence and implications are not themselves subject to scrutiny and challenge. Nothing in the recent critical literature offers a convincing rationale for abandoning liberal peacebuilding, rather than reforming it. If anything, the rise of what I have called hyper-critical scholarship – and particularly its dubious yet seemingly ritualized rejection of liberal peacebuilding – has served to cloud rather than clarify our understanding of what peacebuilding is, and what it does. 38 Of course, there is no single “best” way of analyzing these missions or the broader phenomenon of international peacebuilding. This field of research is – and hopefully will remain – a diverse bazaar of different theoretical and empirical approaches, open to discussion and debate across intellectual traditions and methodologies. This article has sought to contribute to this debate by arguing for a rethinking and rebalancing of liberal peacebuilding critiques. In contrast to the unconvincing hyper-criticism of today, or the irrational exuberance of earlier years, a more constructively critical approach might build on the recognition that: (1) both liberalism and liberal peacebuilding are deeply problematic concepts – in theory and application – and their internal contradictions play themselves out in peacebuilding, sometimes in troubling and destructive ways; (2) liberally-oriented peacebuilding can, in principle, accommodate a great deal of internal variation and adjustment, including many of the specific changes proposed by many critics; (3) scholars who repudiate liberal peacebuilding or call for “alternative” strategies should be expected to reflect carefully on the normative underpinnings of their own arguments, and to clarify the alternatives they may be proposing, including the moral and practical implications of pursuing these alternatives. The third point should be particularly important for those who believe that critical peacebuilding scholarship has an important contribution to make to the field – and that the recent turn towards a reflexive anti-liberalism has diminished the force of these critiques. Adopting a constructively critical orientation does not mean accepting the current practices of peacebuilding. It does not mean that peacebuilding must be “top-down” instead of “bottom-up” – that is a criticism of centralism, not liberalism. It does not mean that peacebuilding should be fixated on formal institutions to the exclusion of informal or customary methods of governance – that is a criticism of formalism, not liberalism. It does not mean that peacebuilders should adopt a “fixed, non-negotiable concept of what the state should eventually look like”117 – that is a criticism of institutional isomorphism, not liberalism. Nor does it mean that peacebuilders should assume that liberalization will necessarily foster peace – that is a criticism of naïve Wilsonianism, one variant of liberalism.118 Addressing all of these real problems may entail probing the internal tensions of liberalism, but it does not require a sweeping rejection of liberal peacebuilding. In fact, there are many recent examples of constructively critical research that raise important theoretical and practical questions, some of which challenge liberal premises without making the mistake of discarding the baby with the bathwater. For instance: What are the sources and dynamics of “legitimacy” in international peacebuilding?119 What obligations, if any, do international actors have in rebuilding societies after conflict?120 What are the limits of external democracy promotion efforts?121 How might “non-elite” populations of host states be included more directly into peace negotiations and post-conflict institutional reform?122 What is the relationship between power-sharing arrangements and peace?123 How might ideas of “local ownership” be developed in a manner that avoids simplistic bromides about the need for greater local ownership or emancipation?124 Other examples include: How do “discursive frames” and organizational procedures shape the design and conduct of peacebuilding in practice?125 How can peacebuilding agencies learn from experiences across missions without falling into the trap of assuming that “technical” knowledge is readily transferrable across diverse local circumstances?126 Why does the UN seem to make peacebuilding commitments that it subsequently fails to fulfill in practice?127 What are the economic impacts of peacebuilding operations?128 What is the relationship between “peace conditionalities” in economic assistance and the durability of the ensuing peace?129 How can economic liberalization be pursued in ways that minimize the dangers of strengthening black markets?130 Under what circumstances should peacebuilding missions end, and how should they “exit”?131 This is just a small sampling of research questions that represent a broad mix of normative approaches. They point to even larger unresolved questions, including the crucial issue of how one should define peacebuilding “success.”132 Many of these research efforts also offer the possibility of making peacebuilding operations more effective, and more just, in the future. Whichever research paths one may chose to follow, those engaged in constructively critical analysis have an immense task ahead of them: peacebuilding is tremendously complex and prone to unanticipated consequences, yet it is also too important to lose or abandon. As long as both scholars and practitioners embrace an open, critical discussion of peacebuilding’s merits and flaws, without descending into unwarranted hyper-criticism, there is still hope of improving both the conception and delivery of international assistance to societies embarking on difficult transitions from war to peace.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.