Legal reforms challenge essentialist notions of gender
Williams, 13 (Dr. Juliet A., associate professor in the Department of Gender Studies at UCLA, "Girls can be anything...but boys will be boys: discourses of sex difference in education reform debates," Nevada Law Journal, Vol. 13, 5-17-13, scholars.law.unlv.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1472&context=nlj)
*In this context the “gender essentialists” that Williams is talking about are those who think that masculine behavior is innately tied to their biological sex. Meaning that she is arguing we need to challenge notions that boys are and will always be aggressive, etc. She is also talking about sex stereotyping in the context of promoting single gender education environments*
Law has an important role to play in opening up space to contest gender essentialism. One way this may happen is through rigorous application of the still-evolving anti-stereotyping principle in constitutional equal protection analysis. The determination of whether a classification constitutes stereotyping generally has been understood to pivot on the question of whether an overbroad generalization is at play. As a result, the judicial account of sex difference has been characterized as a form of “sexual realism.”67 As Katherine Franke argues, in constitutional jurisprudence, “the wrong of sex discrimination is premised upon a right of sexual differentiation, that is, a fundamental belief in the truth of biological sexual difference.”68 From this perspective, “[d]iscrimination occurs when false or stereotypical differences are mistaken for real differences.”69 More recently, however, legal scholar Cary Franklin has demonstrated that the anti-stereotyping principle is being applied even in cases in which a biological sex difference is recognized. 70 Reflecting on the significance of the 1996 decision U.S. v. Virginia, in which the Supreme Court found the male-only admission policy at a state-supported military college unconstitutional, Franklin finds growing judicial support for the view that “equal protection law should be particularly alert to the possibility of sex stereotyping in contexts where ‘real’ differences are involved, because these are the contexts in which sex classifications have most often been used to perpetuate sex-based inequality.”71 In other words, the anti-stereotyping principle is now invoked to engage the question of the social meaning attributed to sex differences by a classification. In so doing, anti-stereotyping analysis thrusts the social construction of masculinity to the fore, a development that creates critical leverage for future challenges to essentialist pedagogies in court. The evidence rallied to support sex segregation must be carefully reviewed to ensure that sex stereotyping does not take the place of meaningful education reforms.72 Responding to legal challenges, proponents of “gender-friendly” educational initiatives portray their detractors as feminist ideologues unwilling to accept the simple facts of nature. But rhetorical warfare is no substitute for a fair and impartial review of existing evidence. Indeed, an important legacy of feminist legal reforms of the past several decades has been a progressive strengthening of the anti-stereotyping principle in sex-discrimination law.73 The vigorous application of a robust anti-stereotyping principle in law has played a critical role in defeating essentialist justifications for policies that promote the subordination of girls and women.74 But in the case of boys and men, essentialist discourses are proving more resilient. No doubt law once again has a central role to play in challenging essentialist policies that insist we accommodate rather than interrogate the basis for masculine behavior. VI. GIRLS CAN BE ANYTHING . . . BUT BOYS WILL BE BOYS After two decades of concerted gender advocacy in the United States, girls’ advocates and boys’ advocates are sharply divided when it comes to questions of gender difference. Building on legal reforms of the 1970s that were designed to curtail sex discrimination and gender bias in the classroom, advocates for girls traditionally have emphasized the need to challenge social attitudes and practices that stand in the way of girls’ success. Where at one time the dominant social view of girls emphasized inherent limitations, there is now a flourishing discourse of possibility and “the sky’s the limit” thinking about girls.75 The same cannot be said in the case of gender advocacy for boys, where essentialist claims have risen to the forefront. Indeed, among boys’ advocates, there is a growing demand to adjust educational environments and expectations to accommodate boys’ innate capacities and interests. What emerges, then, is a divergent discourse about kids, one which simultaneously proclaims that girls can do anything but boys will be boys.76 In this way, contemporary gender discourse in education suggests a striking shift in what anthropologist Sherry Ortner has called the “underlying logic of cultural thinking” about sex and gender.77 In a now classic essay, Is Female to Male as Nature is to Culture?, Ortner declared “the secondary status of woman” to be “one of the true universals” of human societies.78 Ortner attributes this “stubborn” fact to the universal association of woman with nature and man with culture, an attribution derived from “woman’s greater bodily involvement” with reproduction.79 But the message emerging from boys’ advocates today suggests a significant reversal in the familiar terms of gender discourse. In contemporary education reform debates, it is in discussions of girls that we most often encounter a transcendent rhetoric of possibility. In contrast, we are much more likely to be warned of the damaging effects of pushing boys beyond biologically-determined cognitive and emotional limits. One should not presume, however, that this shift indicates a reversal in the gender hierarchy, for the appropriation of an essentialist discourse by boys’ advocates may in fact serve to reinforce male privilege. Today, appeals to nature function as an implicit rejoinder to the suggestion that boys’ troubles emanate in practices of gender socialization that reward aggression and discourage the expression of emotional vulnerability in boys and men. Indeed, in the education-reform debates, the assertion of boys’ fixed and immutable nature has emerged as a powerful tool to subvert interrogation of masculinity. From this perspective, among the most important items of unfinished business for feminism today is a more serious reckoning with the effects of essentialized masculinity.80