Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Feminist international relations impose the idea of “gender” being based upon the “heteronormative binary”.

Chamindra Weerawardhana 2017 – Political analyst, PhD in Comparative Politics at Queen's University Belfast, Research in conflict management in deeply divided societies with a special focus on Northern Ireland and Sri Lanka. “Profoundly Decolonizing?: Reflections on a Transfeminist Perspective of International Relations”. https://muse.jhu.edu/article/679260

The field of feminist security studies highlights how “security” is interrelated to issues of gender and sex in many important ways (Wibben and Stern 2014; Hudson 2011, 586; see also Sjoberg 2009; Sjoberg and Martin 2010). Although feminist security studies strongly challenges the dominant, repressive, and invariably patriarchal ways in which national security, international security coalitions, foreign policy priorities, and defence mechanisms are conceived, it is a considerably “restrictive” field. Publications in journals such as Politics and Gender demonstrate that the near-totality of contributors are cis, white, able-bodied women in Western academia. Feminist security studies focuses invariably on the gender binary, thereby limiting its brand of feminism to cis (and largely white) able-bodied women. It is a field that seldom accommodates a diversity of perspectives or includes voices of women of color, Indigenous women, or Trans and queer feminist scholars and activists. This approach to feminist security studies perpetuates a cycle of exclusion and exceptionalism, adjudicating on who gets to articulate what in the field, and who gets academic credence as a “feminist.” Concluding an article on feminist security studies, Hudson (2011, 589) calls upon fellow academics in that research area to avoid inflicting unto others what has been done unto them in the past in the form of exclusionary practices and in defining the boundaries of feminist security studies to say who is in and who is out. In terms of theorizing, critical voices on the potential of feminist security studies to engage with and destabilize gendered power relations are receiving increasing scholarly attention (see, e.g., Åhäll 2016). Yet even such critical voices take a considerably cisgender feminist turn, with subjective and restrictive interpretations of what is implied by “feminist.” In Practice: The Gender Binary as the Status Quo in International Politics The consequences of mostly whitefeminist theorizing of international relations and security studies can be observed in the agendas and targets of supranational organizations, regional bodies, and powerful governments. The UN’s gender policies and strategic goals, as well as those of powerful governments, are structured in a way that perpetuates gender-related conservatisms and norms, which, to borrow from Ahmed (2016, 23), are also heteronorms. The UN’s concept of gender mainstreaming involves ensuring that the goal of gender equality is made central to all activities—policy development, research, advocacy, legislation, resource allocation, planning, implementation, and monitoring of programs and projects (UN Women, n.d.). Many scholars of feminist IR have explored challenges and inconsistencies in the way in which gender mainstreaming is perceived by the UN and other supranational bodies (see, e.g., Youngs 2008; Daly 2005; Rees, 2005; Walby 2005; Perrons, 2005; Beveridge and Nott 2002; Hafner-Burton and Pollack 2002; True 2003, 2009, 2010). Gender mainstreaming, as it is practiced by the international community, persistently interprets “gender” around the “heteronormative binary” (see Zalewski 2010, 21–22) and consequently regularly ignores interfaces between race, sex, gender, nationality, ethnicity, sexuality, and power (25; see also Jauhola 2010). Today, UN bodies have begun to pay increased attention to Transgender issues through their emphasis on sexual orientation, gender identity/expression, and sex characteristics (SOGIESC), especially in collaboration with platforms such as the International Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Intersex Association (ILGA). However, the overall ethos of such engagements continues to be somewhat inconsistent, in that they fail to acknowledge the salient reality that anti- Trans discrimination—if not discrimination against gender identities that do not fall within the binary—is inherently linked to misogyny, patriarchal oppression, and inequities that are at the heart of gender-related oppression, which especially take their toll on underprivileged cis women of color in the Global South, Indigenous peoples across the world, and also women from ethnic minorities in the West.10 In a similar vein, the UN’s women, peace, and security (WPS) agenda is also essentially founded not only upon a narrow and restrictive understanding of gender(s) fixed on the gender binary, but also on the basis of stereotyping (cisgender) women as the vulnerable “other.” Even when discussing women affected by armed conflict, WPS resolutions locate the (cisgender) male soldier as the ultimate referent (Jansson and Eduards 2016, 12). A fast-growing body of work examines the rationale and problems of implementing WPS resolutions (Olonisakin, Barnes, and Ikpe 2011; Gizelis and Olsson 2015; Farr 2011; Barnes 2011; Harrington 2011; Reeves 2012; Adrian-Paul 2012). Scholars of feminist security studies have also critically engaged with the WPS agenda (Pratt and Richter-Devroe 2011; Schnabel and Tabyshalieva 2012; Boyd 2014). Critics highlight that Resolution 1325 does not confront the structural roots of gender inequalities, including entrenched understandings of patriarchy, masculinity, and militarized power (Barnes 2011). Resolution 1325 and the subsequent WPS resolutions (including Resolution 2122 of 2013) largely perceive women through a prism of wartime victimhood (see, e.g., Meger 2016). This logic locates the cis male soldier as the agent of preventing violence against women, and, as scholars have repeatedly pointed out, legitimizes military activity once sexual violence against women is addressed. In sum, the UN’s conception of gender equates cis women and cisnormative femininity with peace and is entrenched in cisnormative gender stereotypes (Shepherd 2008). This reading of women in contexts of armed conflict fails to identify patriarchy as the primary cause of violence against women, which prevents UN resolutions from consistently addressing the exclusion of women and gender-plural people from conflict management initiatives. It also prevents supranational bodies (and governments) from focusing on a logic of addressing the visceral excesses of patriarchal attitudes and developing a consistent logic of women’s empowerment, especially in post-war contexts in the Global South. The problems inherent in the WPS agenda and gender mainstreaming primarily stem from the fact that the very authority that drafts these policy guidelines is also one that is largely spearheaded by influential states with power acquired through centuries of colonization, and by white settler-controlled authorities that are squarely responsible for the human, socioeconomic, cultural, and linguistic genocide of First Peoples, especially women and gender-plural peoples of Turtle Island and elsewhere. Since its inception, the UN has proved to be incapable of addressing atrocities committed by these powers upon non-white peoples. Western superpowers have carte blanche on the international sphere, often justifying their military aggressions and violence in foreign lands on the basis of protectionist discourses along (cis)gender faultlines, such as the often-repeated “objective” of protecting “women and children,” echoing a discourse of masculinist protectionism built upon a patriarchal and hence patronizing understanding of democratic citizenship and world politics. In the face of such discourses, the UN has been conspicuously silent and partaking in the agendas of Western powers. This calls into question the UN’s capability, in its present form, of addressing the challenges facing women/gender minorities in contexts of armed conflict and natural disaster. An effective strategy must be grounded in the recognition of a broader understanding of gender beyond the binary, and a decolonizing logic of empowering cis and Trans women and all other gender-plural people. Most importantly, such an approach must profoundly challenge the logics of warfare as articulated by powerful states and ensure that women and gender-plural people occupy frontline roles in all aspects of conflict management and resolution initiatives. It is in articulating a policy perspective of this nature, with decolonizing, equity, justice, and empowerment at the center, that a Transfeminist approach to IR will gain prime significance. As outlined below, key ideas in Transfeminism, when applied to IR, provide a promising avenue to develop a strongly intersectional, feminist, Global South(s)-focused and decolonizing twenty-first-century perspective on world politics.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.