Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

1NC - Training and Interoperability are not topical under security cooperation

Bowne ’18 [Andrew 2018 Military Law Review, “Defending the New Fulda Gap: Deterring Russian Aggression Against the Baltic States Through Fiscal Legislation, 226 Mil. L. Rev. 147]

Despite bipartisan criticism of the perceived lack of funding from other NATO members, the United States still recognizes that its leadership in the Alliance is vital to its own national security. 78 There are clear benefits to combined defense in terms of national security, foreign relations, and the economy, 79 placing U.S. funding of NATO at the intersection of foreign and domestic policy. While the President has constitutional authority in defense, as the Commander-in-Chief, and to enter into agreements with foreign states, 80 Congress can affect both defense and foreign affairs through its power of the purse. 81 Accordingly, this section analyzes the reflection of U.S. foreign and defense policies through Congressional authorizations and appropriations that affect the implementation of Operation Atlantic Resolve's lines of operation, particularly in increasing interoperability and improving the defense capacity of the Baltic States. 82

A. Congress's Role in Funding NATO Operations

Congress's power to authorize expenditures through legislation is instrumental in national security and foreign relations, as it determines the amount and purpose for which expenditures are authorized. 83 Because military activities and foreign assistance require expenditures of funds, the United States cannot implement its strategic goals in Eastern Europe without fiscal authority. 84 The constitutionally provided power of the purse therefore places Congress as the cornerstone of the United States' participation in NATO operations. While U.S. funding for deterring Russian aggression is complex and lacks clarity, sources of funding generally fall within three categories: service component funds, the European Reassurance/Deterrence Initiative, and security cooperation.

B. Building Better Allies through Funding Resources

1. Service Operations & Maintenance Funds

As the Unified Combatant Command with an area of responsibility covering Europe and Russia, EUCOM is tasked with managing theater requirements, to include supporting NATO operations and meeting U.S. national security objectives. 85 While EUCOM has authority over the conduct of operations within this region, it is the military services that receive direct funding from Congress through Operations and Maintenance (O&M) funds. 86 Like all Unified Combatant Commands during the budget planning phase, EUCOM is limited to providing inputs to influence the armed services, and sets priorities for funding, but Congress may appropriate different amounts and purposes than requested by the combatant commander. 87

To the extent an expense is necessary, fits within EUCOM's mission, and funds are authorized and appropriated, O&M funds are available for the expenditure, 88 unless the expense is covered by a more specific appropriation. 89 Another caveat is that the expenditure of funds must be for the primary benefit of the United States. 90 These two limitations to the use of service O&M funds obfuscate the analysis of how to fund operations in support of the NATO mission properly. First, it is unclear which agency's funds can be used. Under the Foreign Assistance Act, the Department of State (DoS) is the agency responsible for coordinating all foreign development activities. 91 An exception to the Foreign Assistance Act is when Congress specifically authorizes the Department of Defense (DoD) to obligate defense funding for the benefit of a foreign state, military or population, or if the funding is for "little t" training. 92 Because "little t" training, which protects U.S. forces by promoting safety, familiarization, and interoperability with foreign forces, does not constitute security cooperation, such activities are funded by O&M. However, a second issue arises because most efforts to build NATO ally and partner capacity likely will exceed the parameters of "little t" training and will fall under the umbrella of foreign assistance. Accordingly, funding for such security cooperation programs will come from more specific appropriations, as described below.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.