Simulating international agents is key to topic education. Literature consensus shows.
Shellman and Turan 2006 [Stephen M., and Kürşad Turan. "Do simulations enhance student learning? An empirical evaluation of an IR simulation." Journal of Political Science Education 2, no. 1 (2006): 19-32.]
Our simulation includes many international organizations such as the World Bank, the UN Security Council, the Arab League, NATO, the European Union, Amnesty International, etc. Most students are involved in or connected to an inter- 285 national organization in some way or another, whether it is indirectly through a mutual group international organization representative or directly as the Secretary General of NATO. By the end of the simulation we feel and the results infer that students can identify with the problems international organizations address, the processes that govern at least one of the organizations included, and the constraints that 290 are placed on countries’ sovereignty. We find that students also feel that the simulation enhances knowledge of international organizations and their processes. In contrast, the modal value is equal to four for theoretical enhancement. These results convey that while the simulation enhances knowledge in all three areas, it does a better job enhancing the knowledge of concepts and organizations and their 295 processes than IR theories. Perhaps assigning discussion papers and asking more theoretically based questions during the debriefing could bring this number up. Moreover, some of the theories we cover in class have a domestic basis like Fearon’s (1994) audience cost model and Milner’s (1997) domestic institutions and interest groups based theoretical framework. The simulation, at the present time, unfortu- 300 nately lacks proper mechanisms to apply such theories to decisions, processes, and outcomes and to analyze their utility. Thus, the simulation constraints may explain why the modal value for theories is four and not five. That said, overall, we find support that the simulation enhances knowledge of substantive course material. The results fit with Brown and King (2000) who find 305 that students’ knowledge of international relations increases as a result of participating in the International Communications and Negotiations Simulations (ICONS).12 Also relevant are the results from Kumza and Haney (2001). They show that the use of film in a U.S. Foreign Policy summer course to stimulate active learning works. Using self-assessment surveys, Kumza and Haney (2001) show that students’ 310 increase their knowledge of U.S. foreign policy through films, discussions, and written exercises. Our results are consistent with those discussed above in that they support the hypothesis that active learning exercises enhance learning. Both the modal and median values calculated for country=organization enhancement are equal to five. More than 90% of the students stated that the simu- 315 lation enhanced knowledge of their assigned country or organization at a level four or above on the five-point intensity scale. This finding is consistent with Brown and King (2000) who found that participation in ICONS enhanced knowledge of the country assigned and U.S. foreign policy. In a typical introductory international relations course, professors rarely expose students to characteristics of particular 320 countries and or their current foreign policies. Our simulation forces students to research a particular country’s foreign policy or a particular international organization’s rules, history, and structure. In order to actively engage in the exercise, one needs to know what to talk about, who to talk to, and what to offer and not to offer in order to get what one wants. The research assignment can be eye-opening to many 325 students who are unfamiliar with international relations, particular countries, their foreign policies, and their regional affairs. We infer from our data that the simulation enhances students’ knowledge of particular countries and=or organizations. In terms of critical and analytical thinking skills, over 74% reported enhancement levels at four or above for question 6. This supports the hypothesis that our 330 simulation aids in the development of critical and analytical thinking skills. Our simulation compels students to make their own decisions and anticipate and=or react to the consequences. For example, students in the past have created fake Yahoo e-mail accounts using the instructor’s name and have used it to gather information from other groups. Another individual used her friendship with the head terrorist’s 335 roommate to acquire information about the terrorists operations. These are some of the more intelligent and sneaky tactics students innovate and implement during the simulation. The students ultimately create solutions to resolve international problems given constraints placed on their countries and organizations. These are skills that are difficult to teach by reading and lecturing. Rather, we argue that simulation 340 is the best method for teaching such skills, because students are confronted with novel problems and they are forced to experiment with strategies and tactics to accomplish them. Then, they are able to learn from their successes as well as their failures. Our finding is consistent with Leonard and Leonard (1995) who found that business school graduates believed courses involving simulation exercises prepared 345 them better for their future jobs than courses that only used case methods. We want to produce professionals in all fields who can analyze and solve novel problems, and the survey results suggest that our simulation develops these skills.