Switch Side Debate builds critical thinking skills which are key to foster democratic values and prevent extinction.
Harrigan 08 [(Casey, Master of Arts in the Department of Communications at Wake Forest University) “A Defense of Switch Side Debate”, 2008, http://wakespace.lib.wfu.edu/bitstream/handle/10339/14746/harrigancd_05_2008.pdf]
While such pragmatic justifications for SSD are persuasive, they are admittedly secondary to the greater consideration of pedagogy. Although it is certainly true that debate is a game and that its competitive elements are indispensable sources of motivation for students who are otherwise apathetic about academic endeavors, the overwhelming benefits of contest debating are the knowledge and skills taught through participation. The wins and losses (and marginally-cheesy trophies), by and large, are quickly forgotten with the passage of time. However, the educational values of debate are so fundamental that they eventually become ingrained in the decision-making and thought processes of debaters, giving them a uniquely valuable durability. To this end, SSD is essential. The benef its of debating both sides have been noted by many authors over the past fifty years. To name but a few, SSD has been lauded for fostering tolerance and undermining bigotry and dogmatism (M uir, 1993), creating stronger and more knowledgeable advocates (Dybvig and Iversion, 2000) , and fortifying the social forces of democracy by guaranteeing the expression of minority viewpoints (Day, 1966). Switching sides is a crucial element of debate’s pedagogical benefit; it forms the gears that drive debate’s intellectual motor. Additionally, there are social benefits to the practice of requiring students to debate both sides of controversial issues. Dating back to th e Greek rhetorical tradition, great value has been placed on the benefit of testing each argument relative to all others in the marketplace of ideas. Like those who argue on behalf of the efficiency-maximizing benefits of free market competition, it is believed that arguments are most rigorously tested (and conceivably refined and improved) when compared to all available alternatives. Even for beliefs that have seem ingly been ingrained in consensus opinion or 7 in cases where the public at-large is unlikely to accept a particular position, it has been argued that they should remain open for public discussion and deliberation (Mill, 1975). Along these lines, the greatest benefit of switching sides, which goes to the heart of contemporary debate, is its inducement of critical thinking. Defined as “reasonable reflective thinking that is focused on decidi ng what to believe or do” (Ennis, 1987, p. 10), critical thinking learned through debate teaches students not just how to advocate and argue, but how to decide as well. Each and every student, whether in debate or (more likely) at some later point in life, will be placed in the position of the decision-maker. Faced with competing options whose costs and benefits are initially unclear, critical thinking is necessary to assess all the possible outcomes of each choice, compare their relative merits, and arrive at some final decision about which is preferable. In some instances, such as choosing whether to eat Chinese or Indian food for dinner, the im portance of making the correct decision is minor. For many other de cisions, however, the implications of choosing an imprudent course of action are pot entially grave. As Robert Crawford notes, there are “issues of unsurpassed importance in the daily lives of millions upon millions of people...being decided to a considerable extent by the power of pub lic speaking” (2003). Although the days of the Cold War are over, and the risk that “the next Pearl Harbor could be ‘compounded by hydrogen’” (Ehninger and Brockriede, 1978, p. 3) is greatly reduced, the manipulation of public support before the invasion of Iraq in 2003 points to the continuing necessity of training a well-in formed and critically-aware public (Zarefsky, 2007). In the absence of debate-trained critical thinking, ignorant but ambitious politicians and persuasive but nefarious leaders would be much more likely to draw the country, and possibly the world, in to conflicts with incalculable losses in terms of human 8 well-being. Given the myriad threats of global proportions th at will require incisive solutions, including global warming, the spread of pandemic diseases, and the proliferation of weapons of mass destruction, cultivating a robust and effective society of critical decision-makers is essential. As Louis Rene Beres writes, “with such learning, we Americans could prepare...not as immobilized objects of false contentment, but as authentic citizens of an endangered planet” (2003 ). Thus, it is not surprising that critical thinking has been called “the highest edu cational goal of the ac tivity” (Parcher, 1998). While arguing from conviction can foster limited critical thinking skills, the element of switching sides is necessary to sharpen debate’s critical edge and ensure that decisions are made in a reasoned manner instead of being driven by ideology. Debaters trained in SSD are more likely to evaluate both sides of an argument before arriving at a conclusion and are less likely to dismiss potential arguments based on his or her prior beliefs (Muir 1993). In addition, debating both sides teaches “conceptual flexibility,” where decision-makers are more likely to refl ect upon the beliefs that are held before coming to a final opinion (Muir, 1993, p. 290) . Exposed to many arguments on each side of an issue, debaters learn that public policy is characteri zed by extraordinary complexity that requires careful consideration before action. Finally, these arguments are confirmed by the preponderance of empirical research demonstrating a link between competitive SSD and critical thinking (Allen, Berkow itz, Hunt and Louden, 1999; Colbert, 2002, p. 82). The theory and practice of SSD has value beyond the limited realm of competitive debate as well. For the practitioners a nd students of rhetoric, understanding how individuals come to form opini ons about subjects and then a ttempt to persuade others is 9 of utmost importance. Although the field of communication has established models that attempt to explain human decision-making, such as the Rational Argumentation Theory and others (Cragen and Shields, 1998, p. 66) , the practice of SSD within competitive debate rounds is a real-world laboratory wh ere argumentative experiments are carried out thousands of times over during the course of a single year-long season. The theory of SSD has profound implications for those who study how individuals are persuaded, as well as how advocates should go about the process of forming their own personal beliefs and attempting to persuade others.