Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Depth outweighs breadth.

Tai et al ‘8

Tai et al 08 [(Robert) Curriculum, Instruction, and Special Education Department, Curry School of Education) “Depth Versus Breadth: How Content Coverage in High School Science Courses Relates to Later Success in College Science Course work” 2008]

The baseline model reveals a direct and compelling outcome: teaching for depth is associated with improvements in later performance. Of course, there is much to consider in evaluating the implications of such an analysis. There are a number of questions about this simple conclusion that naturally emerge. For example, ho w much depth works best? What is the optimal manner to operationalize the impact of depth-based learning? Do specific contexts (such as type of student, teacher, or school) moderate the impact of depth? The answers to these questions certainly suggest that a more nuanced view should be sought. Nonetheless, this analysis appears to indicate that a robust positive association exists between high school science teaching that pro v ides depth in at least one topic and better performances in introductory postsecondary science courses. Our results also clearly suggest that breadth-based learning, as commonly applied in high school classrooms, does not appear to offer students any advantage when they enroll in introductory college science courses, although it may contribute to higher scores on standardized tests. However, the intuitive appeal of broadly surveying a discipline in an introductory high school course cannot be overlooked. There might be benefits to such a pedagogy that become apparent when using measures that we did not explore. The results regarding breadth were less compelling because in only one of the three disciplines were the results significant in our full model. On the other hand, we observed no positive effects at all. As it stands, our findings at least suggest that aiming for breadth in content coverage should be avoided, as we found no evidence to support such an approach.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.