Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

AI collaboration between US-China are vital, and a translated Chinese report confirms development is NOT zero-sum.

Sullivan 21 (Lieutenant Colonel Sullivan is an Army pilot by trade, who lived and studied at the prestigious Fudan University in Shanghai, China, as an Olmsted Scholar. He was one of just five Army officers selected that year. Ryan has taken his experience in and knowledge of China and combined that with graduate-level work in the field of Artificial Intelligence to deliver an in-depth study of the critical elements of U.S.-China competition in Artificial Intelligence.) “The U.S., China, and Artificial Intelligence Competition Factors” 2021-10-04 https://www.airuniversity.af.edu/Portals/10/CASI/documents/Research/Cyber/2021-10-04%20US%20China%20AI%20Competition%20Factors.pdf?ver=KBcxNomlMXM86FnIuuvNEw%3D%3D // ZX

The purpose of this research is to examine the critical elements of U.S.-China competition over Artificial Intelligence (AI) norms and determine if the resulting contest is inherently zero-sum. The paper explores SinoAmerican AI competition through the lenses of values, cohesion, influence, and legitimacy to better understand each nation’s positional advantages and identify possibilities for cooperation in bilateral or multilateral engagements. Those engagements will be part of the overall Sino-American struggle for influence within international institutions and standard-setting organizations (SSO) over technical standards and, more importantly, values, norms and ethics guiding AI applications.In the new world order, competition over the establishment of AI norms is not zero-sum; however, the continued deterioration in mutual trust and bilateral relations will test both the U.S. and China to avoid transactional engagements or challenges to core interests which could escalate AI competition into AI conflict. Hal Brands and Zack Cooper argue that “many American conceptions of the competition with China rest on the false premise that this contest will be neatly bipolar – a replay of the East-West standoff in Europe during the Cold War. A much messier world is taking shape.”2 This messiness stems from 21st-century competition, which a report from RAND views as mixed sum, as shared interest and objectives converge in an international system that currently displays elements of unipolarity, bipolarity, and multipolarity.3 AI will play an instrumental role in reshaping the world order and the degrees to which each polarity element exists. Neither the U.S. or China can achieve its objectives alone, and both must seek support from other nations to achieve their desired ends. AI and other emerging technology will empower developing nations and middle powers to play a more prominent role in constructing a world order. Those middle powers, or “third countries, such as India, Indonesia and Turkey,” no longer feel the need “to align entirely with the United States, nor with China, when they can gain by playing Washington and Beijing against each other to produce a “multipolar competition, not a bipolar one.”4 This paper assumes that the liberal framework remains intact, and that AI competition will occur in an increasingly multipolar world order. Despite breakdowns in bilateral relations, zero-sum conflict is not predestined, as Shanghai scholar Wu Xinbo notes, “promoting pragmatic cooperation and constructive competition, effective management, control of risks, and prevention of major conflicts between China and the United States remains the basic direction of China’s diplomacy with the United States.”11 Several U.S. scholars and leaders such as Elizabeth Economy and Graham Allison also advocate cooperative approaches to competition by promoting coopetition, coevolution, or rivalry partnerships.12 Such strategies are hard to imagine in a period of increasingly strained bilateral relations and diverging values, and are likely to fail if the leaders of both nations maintain a binary approach to engagement. This paper explores competition through the lens of values, cohesion, influence, and legitimacy to better understand each nation’s positional advantages and identify possibilities for cooperation in bilateral or multilateral engagements. The U.S. and China remain the two nations best positioned to benefit from the increasing adoption of AI across society. Competition over AI is not zero-sum, in that both nations will derive value from AI growth, but the benefits are not shared equally. China’s substantial advantages in data and the size of its market lead experts to predict that China will account for nearly half of the estimated $15.7 trillion that AI will add to the global gross domestic product (GDP) by 2030, and almost double the expected growth in North America. Values competition is not zero-sum, but diverging AI values represent the most significant challenge to cooperation and limits the extent to which Sino-American collaboration on AI can continue in some areas. The synergy of economic, political, and technological challenges that AI competition creates demands action. Our nation’s gravest risk is to remain on the sidelines of global leadership and allow the CCP to promote a values system that prioritizes the Party over the nation and its people as a viable alternative to democracy. Failure to address federal data privacy and consumer rights concerns leaves China and Europe as the only two models offering “guardrails against invasive data collection.”106 Challenges and opportunities in forming alliances and relying on the collective to balance other nations’ interests and needs present opportunities and risks. Regarding China, Graham Allison offers that “while U.S. planners must consider all reasonable contingencies, basing our strategy to meet the China challenge on the expectation that the Chinese economy or political system fails would be a mistake.”107 Finding ways to cooperate or collaborate would prove beneficial to the collective, but such choices on a state-to-state basis could very well lead to conflict. Attempting to challenge or contain China without allies seems unlikely to succeed in the long term.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.