Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Multilateral regulation on autonomous weapons fails – allies and adversaries proliferate and no compliance

Anderson and Waxman 13 [Ken Anderson, Professor of Law at AUWCL, is a leading international and national security law scholar who has recently been focusing extensively on the regulation of emerging technologies, especially automation, robotics, and AI. Matthew C. Waxman is a nationally known authority on national security law, cybersecurity, terrorism, intelligence, and armed conflict. He brings the perspective of a former senior government official to his scholarship on war powers, the regulation of military technology, counterterrorism, surveillance, and cybersecurity. “Law and Ethics for Autonomous Weapon Systems: Why a Ban Won't Work and How the Laws of War Can,” 4/10/13, https://scholarship.law.columbia.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=2804&context=faculty_scholarship]//PJ

In any case, ambitions for a multilateral treaty regulating or prohibiting autonomous weapon systems are misguided for several reasons. For starters, limitations on autonomous military technologies, although quite likely to find wide superficial acceptance among some states and some non-governmental groups and actors, will have little traction among those most likely to develop and use them. Some states may want the United States to be more aggressive in adopting the latest technologies, given that possible adversaries are likely to have far fewer compunctions about their own autonomous weapon systems, and others are likely to favor any technological development that extends the reach and impact of U.S. and allied forces or enhances their own ability to counter adversaries’ capabilities. Even states and groups inclined to support treaty prohibitions or limitations will find it difficult to reach agreement on scope or definitions because lethal autonomy will be introduced incrementally—as battlefield machines become smarter and faster, and the real-time human role in controlling them gradually recedes, agreeing on what constitutes a prohibited autonomous weapon will be unattainable. Even assuming agreement could be reached, there are the general challenges of compliance: the collective action problems of failure and defection that afflict all such treaty regimes, especially when dealing with dual-use (civilian and military) underlying technologies. Finally, there are serious humanitarian risks to prohibition, given the possibility that autonomous weapons systems could in the long run be more discriminating and ethically preferable to alternatives. If all such systems are prohibited, and particularly if even research and development of relevant technologies is also prohibited, one never gets the benefits that might come from new technologies— and future generations will not even be aware of the potential benefits that were given up, because these prohibitions on development meant they were never even pursued. Prohibition precludes the possibility of such benefits, and proponents of it must acknowledge and bear responsibility for this risk.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.