Only working with both public and private sectors solves
Jason Smith, 2-22-2022, Jason Smith currently serves as service chair and as assistant professor for security studies at the National War College. He has served as a leader and aviator in the US Coast Guard and the US Army, as advisor to the commandant of the Coast Guard, as senior policy advisor in the US Senate, and on the staff of the National Security Council. "Forget a Whole-of-Government Cybersecurity Strategy—It’s Time for a Whole-of-Nation Approach," Modern War Institute, https://mwi.usma.edu/forget-a-whole-of-government-cybersecurity-strategy-its-time-for-a-whole-of-nation-approach/ //jsam
Response Companies are pressuring government officials for a solution, or at least more freedom to act themselves. The government is not ignoring the problem, but countering cyberattacks requires not only the technical capability to hack back; it also involves understanding a complex web of attribution and considerations governing the use of force, law enforcement, policy, and obligations to protect the innocent. While many companies would like to take a more active role in punishing those caught hacking their systems, this might cause more harm than good. However, discounting private companies is also a mistake. Subscribing to social contract theory does not mean that private citizens do not have a role to play in ensuring societal well-being. Juries are made up of everyday citizens and private think tanks routinely advise the government on security issues. The social contract in a democracy must be participatory. In fact, it is this participation in the government that gives democracies their strength. Participation brings new ideas, energy, and accountability. A successful cyber posture that both defends against attacks and punishes those that are successful will take a concerted effort by government and the private sector. The government needs to take a lead in developing and executing a competitive strategy that bridges the public-private divide and increases the United States’ advantage. But what form should that partnership take? Ought offensive or defensive approaches be prioritized?