Free beta access. 5 free AI tokens each week. Optional top-ups available. See what is included
Opening Word document…

Private sector can tackle cyber threats if US increases data sharing.

Shah and Sridhar 22 (Raj M. Shah and Kiran Sridhar. Shah is Chairman of Resilience Insurance and Managing Partner at Shield Capital. Sridhar is a risk researcher at the University of Cambridge. “How to Cyberproof the Private Sector.” Foreign Affairs. January 13, 2022. https://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/north-america/2022-01-13/how-cyberproof-private-sector)

To address the current cybersecurity deficit, the U.S. government will need to facilitate far greater sharing of intelligence data about cyberthreats throughout the economy. Congress can do this by passing legislation to overhaul the Cybersecurity and Infrastructure Security Agency’s (CISA) information-sharing program, the Automated Indicator Sharing (AIS) initiative, and by establishing the Bureau of Cyber Statistics to regularly publish security data. But information alone will not solve the current cybersecurity crisis. A comprehensive cyberdefense strategy will also require new ways of getting companies themselves to act quickly on the most important threats and to put in place the best defenses. Under prevailing market forces, there is a strong disincentive for cybersecurity firms to share information about threats. Although many of these firms have gathered rich data about the vulnerabilities and relative security of common software products, they do not share this intelligence with the end users of these products for fear it would erode their competitive advantage. As a result, most companies are ill-equipped to evaluate the security risks of the software they depend on. The Israeli firm Cybersixgill has estimated that 90 percent of company chief information security officers make cybersecurity decisions based on outdated intelligence data. And since there is very little information sharing, cyberattackers are often able to exploit the same vulnerability over and over again to inflict damage on thousands of enterprises around the world. Since companies are not basing their purchase decisions on an accurate assessment of risks, there is little incentive for software providers to emphasize cybersecurity. Software products that are designed with enhanced security features are rarely able to command a premium, and many software companies have made the rational calculation that putting expensive resources into cybersecurity will not be rewarded by the market. Nor do they tend to suffer when their products are attacked. After all, as computer scientists Ross Anderson and Tyler Moore have pointed out, the clients of software companies—not the software companies themselves—are the ones that bear most of the costs of a cybersecurity failure. Meanwhile, companies are often reluctant to disclose cyberattacks when they occur, for fear of damaging their reputations––or worse, subjecting themselves to litigation. That reticence allows malicious hackers to reuse the same methods elsewhere. And cyber insurers, firms who write insurance policies to cover financial losses sustained by data breaches and digital disruptions, are similarly unwilling to share information about the efficacy of particular security defenses, which they view as proprietary. As a result, many companies make critical cybersecurity investment decisions based on marketing or word of mouth rather than hard data. If information about threats were quickly shared around the world, cyberattacks would immediately lose much of their potency. Companies would be able to quickly prioritize and address urgent security flaws within their digital networks or operating systems and malign actors would no longer be able to exploit a single vulnerability to attack a large number of targets. But to date, the government has struggled to overcome built-in resistance in the private sector to information-sharing about cyberthreats.

Sign in to recut, update, or save this card.